Unquestionable Bell theorem for interwoven frustrated down conversion processes
Paweł Cieśliński, Marcin Markiewicz, Konrad Schlichtholz, Jan-Åke Larsson, Marek Żukowski · 2025
Read Unquestionable Bell theorem for interwoven frustrated down conversion processes by Paweł Cieśliński, Marcin Markiewicz, Konrad Schlichtholz, Jan-Åke Larsson, Marek Żukowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-19207.txt.
Introduction
Pawel Cieslinski and co-authors prove a Bell theorem result for a new kind of quantum interference setup, in work from 2025. The setup weaves together processes that create photon pairs, so that interference rests on path identity rather than on aligned paths. A past experiment showed striking interference in this setting, but a loophole remained.
The authors show that if measurement choices are only phase shifts, a classical local model can mimic the interference, and they give that model. The loophole closes when the final pair-creation stages are switched on and off as the measurement choice. With that switching, the observed interference breaks a classic inequality that no local model can break. The result puts the nonclassical nature of the new interferometry on firm ground.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Paweł Cieśliński, Marcin Markiewicz, Konrad Schlichtholz, Jan-Åke Larsson, Marek Żukowski |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-19207
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unquestionable Bell theorem for interwoven frustrated down conversion processes Paweł Cieśliński, Marcin Markiewicz, Konrad Schlichtholz, Jan-Åke Larsson, Marek Żukowski Abstract In the Wang et al. paper “Violation of Bell inequality with unentangled photons” [Science Advances, 1 Aug 2025 Vol 11, Issue 31], in which a brilliant experiment involving two interwoven frustrated down conversion processes is reported, Bell non-classicality of the observed interference processes is conjectured under some tacit additional assumptions. To clear any doubts about Bell non-classicality of the interference processes observed by Wang et al., we give an unconditional Bell-type proof that a modified version of the experiment indeed would reveal a violation of local realism. The data of the Wang et al. experiment show destructive interference which surpasses the required threshold for Bell non-classicality in the modified version, and thus effectively constitutes a positive experimental Bell non-classicality test employing our proposal. The essence of our method is to abandon the usual approach in which macroscopically controlled optical phases define the measurement settings in a Bell experiment. Instead, in our case, the local settings are determined by switching on or off the local pumping fields of the parametric down conversion crystals at the local measuring stations of “Alice and Bob”. We also show that in a standard framework of local hidden variable theories that do not require any additional assumptions, it is possible to construct a local realistic model which exactly reproduces the probabilities on which the conjecture by Wang et al. violation of local realism was based. Thus, we prove that the tacit additional assumptions in the Bell analysis of Wang et al. constrain the class of local realistic models refuted by the experiment. Also, we claim that the non-classical effects in the Wang et al. experiment cannot be ascribed to unentangled photons. I Introduction The series of trailblazing parametric down conversion experiments by Mandel and his group culminated with a two-crystal experiment in which the interference depended on the level of path-indistinguishability of a photon, the source of which was undefined – one of the two crystals [ 1 ] . Soon after this, the Zeilinger group designed and performed an experiment that they have called frustrated downconversion [ 2 ; 3 ] . In the latter, an interference was observed in the two-photon counts behind the second down conversion crystal. It depended on the phase relationships of the pumping field at the first and second down converters, and on the phase shifts in the paths via which the signal and idler photons could potentially travel from the first crystal to the second one. As these phase relations are such that the entire two-stage down conversion can interfere destructively, the process has gained the name of a frustrated down conversion. While the process was interesting by itself, the interference was of the first order, as it could be monitored by observing, e.g., just the signal output of the second crystal. In recent years, outstanding experiments extending these ideas were reported in [ 4 ] and [ 5 ] . These involved higher order interference in coincidences of two pairs of photons counted at two different measuring stations (potentially space-like separated) involving as the initial state the interwoven emissions from the two down conversion crystals, then sent to the measuring stations, which have as their integral part local parametric down conversion crystals phase matched with the incoming idler and signal paths, see Fig. 1 . The specific alignment of the construction leads to fundamental indistinguishability of the sources of the pairs of emitted photons. This is reflected in interference effects in coincidence count readouts in which two pairs of photons are registered at the two measuring stations. As the source of the photons belonging to each such photon of each pair is fundamentally unknown, one can observe interference in coincident counts of this kind (up to, in theory, even a completely destructive one). Such a configuration, first tested in [ 4 ] after a topological transformation, resembles a Bell experiment. In the paper [ 5 ] , the authors presented a pioneering desk-top version of such an experiment. As we shall show, the observed destructive interference is deep enough to make it impossible for any local realistic model to explain the experiment . We present it here by following the standard Bell-type analysis, without any additional assumptions. Just based on the realism, locality, and independence of the processes of choosing the settings of the local measuring apparatuses from any other processes in the experiment. In the original paper [ 5 ] , the presented construction of correlation functions does not follow the Bell’s approach, and therefore the attempt at the Bell-like analysis presented there is, in our opinion, just conjectural. Note that we are not alone in this opinion [ 6 ] . We show that the Bell analysis in [ 5 ] rests on tacit additional assumptions. In our re-analysis we explicitly construct a local realistic model for the correlations which are the basis of the claims in [ 5 ] . This analysis uses the modeling ideas given in [ 7 ] and applied in [ 8 ] to give a local realistic model of the Franson interferometry [ 9 ] . This method was also used to show that the experiment proposed in [ 10 ] is not a proper Bell test, see [ 11 ] . Moreover, we provide an analysis which shows that the statement in their title, about unentangled photons, cannot be upheld. The essence of our approach for showing unconditional Bell inequality violation is to abandon the usual approach in optical Bell tests, in which the macroscopically controlled optical phases define the measurement settings. Instead, in our case, the local settings are determined by switching on or off the local pumping fields of the parametric down conversion crystals at the local measuring stations of “Alice and Bob”. This method was inspired by the trailblazing paper by Hardy [ 12 ] and recently developed at ICTQT, see papers [ 11 ; 13 ; 14 ; 15 ] in which weak homodyne measurements operating in the aforementioned on-off mode allowed to propose a version of the Tan-Walls-Collett [ 10 ] experiment unconditionally revealing the Bell non-classicality of a single photon prepared in a superposition state of propagating to Alice and Bob. In the original Tan-Walls-Collett version, as in the case of [ 5 ] , the settings were determined by phases, and this phase modulation was shown in [ 13 ] to be insufficient to reveal Bell non-classicality of the interference. II Interwoven frustrated down conversion processes set-up In this section, we consider the experimental set-up the schematics of which is given in Fig. 1 . The figure covers the original version of the set-up of [ 5 ] , and our modification. II.1 Description of interwoven frustrated parametric down conversion setup The pump beam is first split into two beams, each entering the first layer of nonlinear crystals represented by the light blue rectangles, where the parametric down conversion process occurs. The resulting output modes are then interwoven and directed toward two separate stations: Alice’s on the left and Bob’s on the right. Next, a local phase shift \alpha is applied in