Understanding Benefits and Pitfalls of Current Methods for the Segmentation of Undersampled MRI Data Journal: Computers in Biology and Medicine
Jan Nikolas Morshuis, Matthias Hein, Christian Baumgartner · 2025
Read Understanding Benefits and Pitfalls of Current Methods for the Segmentation of Undersampled MRI Data Journal: Computers in Biology and Medicine by Jan Nikolas Morshuis, Matthias Hein, Christian Baumgartner (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18975.txt.
Introduction
Jan Nikolas Morshuis, Matthias Hein, and Christian F Baumgartner present a 2025 arXiv paper benchmarking ways to segment undersampled MRI scans. Fast scans collect less data, and many teams now outline anatomy straight from the partial data instead of rebuilding the full image first. Methods grew up in isolation, on private data, with no shared yardstick. The authors supply the first unified comparison of seven approaches.
The tests use two datasets with raw coil data and human-drawn outlines. One-stage models fuse rebuild and outline in one net; two-stage models rebuild first, then segment. Plain two-stage methods that respect the measured data won. The authors warn that fancy specialized designs did not earn their complexity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jan Nikolas Morshuis, Matthias Hein, Christian Baumgartner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18975
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Understanding Benefits and Pitfalls of Current Methods for the Segmentation of Undersampled MRI Data Journal: Computers in Biology and Medicine Jan Nikolas Morshuis, Matthias Hein, Christian Baumgartner Abstract MR imaging is a valuable diagnostic tool allowing to non-invasively visualize patient anatomy and pathology with high soft-tissue contrast. However, MRI acquisition is typically time-consuming, leading to patient discomfort and increased costs to the healthcare system. Recent years have seen substantial research effort into the development of methods that allow for accelerated MRI acquisition while still obtaining a reconstruction that appears similar to the fully-sampled MR image. However, for many applications a perfectly reconstructed MR image may not be necessary, particularly, when the primary goal is a downstream task such as segmentation. This has led to growing interest in methods that aim to perform segmentation directly on accelerated MRI data. Despite recent advances, existing methods have largely been developed in isolation, without direct comparison to one another, often using separate or private datasets, and lacking unified evaluation standards. To date, no high-quality, comprehensive comparison of these methods exists, and the optimal strategy for segmenting accelerated MR data remains unknown. This paper provides the first unified benchmark for the segmentation of undersampled MRI data comparing 7 approaches. A particular focus is placed on comparing one-stage approaches , that combine reconstruction and segmentation into a unified model, with two-stage approaches , that utilize established MRI reconstruction methods followed by a segmentation network. We test these methods on two MRI datasets that include multi-coil k-space data as well as a human-annotated segmentation ground-truth. We find that simple two-stage methods that consider data-consistency lead to the best segmentation scores, surpassing complex specialized methods that are developed specifically for this task. 1 Introduction Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has proven to be a powerful modality to segment anatomical structures and pathologies due to its high soft-tissue contrast. However, a major disadvantage of MRI acquisition are the long scan times required. This does not only lead to high healthcare costs and longer waiting times but also to increased patient discomfort ( Oztek et al. 2020 ) and potential artifacts in the MRI image due to patient movement ( Zaitsev et al. 2015 ) . Faster MRI acquisition is therefore desirable and currently a major research topic ( Heckel et al. 2024 ) . A widely used strategy to accelerate MRI acquisition is to reduce the amount of data collected, resulting in an undersampled k-space. This undersampling leads to gaps in the measurement data. Replacing these gaps with zeros, however, can lead to visible degradations of the MRI image, impacting it’s usefulness for diagnostics. To address this issue, current reconstruction methods aim to estimate the fully-sampled MR image by utilizing some form of prior information. This prior can either be learned, as is the case for machine learning-based reconstruction approaches ( Heckel et al. 2024 ) , or it can be based on known properties of MR images like sparsity and smoothness constraints as it is done in compressed sensing methods ( Donoho 2006 ; Lustig et al. 2007 ) . Utilizing prior information in addition to the available measurements typically yields reconstructions that more closely resemble the fully sampled ground truth MRI image. A tradeoff exists between the quality of the reconstruction and the acceleration factor – higher accelerations allow shorter measurement times but typically also lead to worse reconstructions. What acceleration factor to choose largely depends on the downstream task: For instance, ( Radmanesh et al. 2022 ) have shown that even though an accurate reconstruction might not be possible for high accelerations, the reconstructed images can still be used for initial screening by radiologists, who can decide which patients need further examination. Therefore, the acceleration factor of the MRI can be increased significantly if the purpose of the acquisition is not the creation of accurate reconstructions but rather the downstream task of initial screening. Similarly, the ultimate purpose of an MRI acquisition might be to find segmentations of anatomical or pathological structures to track disease progressions ( Wirth et al. 2020 ) . For many segmentation tasks, not all details displayed in a fully-sampled MRI image are required, and larger structures are still recognizable even for high acceleration. The task of segmenting undersampled MRI images is therefore of high interest due to its applicability and its potential to save costly measurement time. Figure 1 : We separate modern methods that are optimized to segment undersampled MRI data into two categories: Two-Stage Approaches and One-Stage Approaches. Two-stage approaches first reconstruct the undersampled MR image and a simple UNet is then used to segment the reconstructed image. One-stage approaches try to combine both tasks and it is often claimed that this combination of tasks is helpful to achieve better reconstructions and segmentations. Our results suggest the contrary finding. A number of works have explored methods to jointly optimize MRI reconstruction for optimal segmentation and reconstructions rather than for reconstruction fidelity alone ( Sui et al. 2021 ; Tolpadi et al. 2023 ; Calivá et al. 2020 ) . Unfortunately, the majority of these methods suffer from common validation pitfalls ( Isensee et al. 2024 ) and do not compare to each other directly and instead only compare to simple baseline methods ( Calivá et al. 2020 ; Sui et al. 2021 ) . Moreover, most methods only consider single and private datasets ( Tolpadi et al. 2023 ; Sui et al. 2021 ; Calivá et al. 2020 ) and sometimes only single acceleration factors ( Tolpadi et al. 2023 ) , such that the behavior of the algorithms across datasets and across acceleration factors remains unknown. To improve comparability between methods, a recent MICCAI challenge—the K2S Challenge ( Tolpadi et al. 2023 ) —invited participants to perform segmentation given only undersampled k-space data and evaluated submissions based on the quality of the resulting segmentations. Interestingly, the winning method that predicted the best segmentations also obtained the lowest reconstruction fidelity of all submissions and did not explicitly optimize for high reconstruction scores. Moreover, the third-placed method skipped the reconstruction altogether and trained a segmentation network on the undersampled data directly. However, results from challenges such as the K2S Challenge should be interpreted with caution ( Maier-Hein et al. 2018 ; Wiesenfarth et al. 2021 ) , as it is often unclear which specific factors within a method’s implementation are responsible for its performance ( Eisenmann et al. 2023 ) . Apart from the network architecture, implementation decisions like data augmentation, number of iterations, and ensembling also play a crucial role and might be even more important than the underlying architecture ( Isensee et al. 2020 ) . Moreover, the K2S challenge was performed on a single and now private dataset. Therefore neither prior work nor the results of the K2S challenge can be used to answer the question of which method for segmenting undersampled MRI data performs the best and if high-quality reconstructions are indeed needed for better segmentation performance. In order to address this research gap and generate additional insight about segmenting undersampled MRI data, this paper provides the first fair comparison and a unified evaluation framework for many state-of-the-art methods in the current literature. By providing a rigorous