Self-similarity in creeping salt crystallization

R.J. Wijnhorst, M. Prat, N. Shahidzadeh · 2025

Read Self-similarity in creeping salt crystallization by R.J. Wijnhorst, M. Prat, N. Shahidzadeh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18779.txt.

Introduction

Salt that creeps across a surface as it crystallizes can build roses in deserts and pillars by salt lakes, and the same efflorescence eats away at buildings and soils. Wijnhorst, Prat, and Shahidzadeh dig into how these growths organize themselves.

Under controlled evaporation, the porous salt crusts turned out to be self-similar: the same crystallization pattern repeats at scale after scale. Small crystal clusters echo the shape of the whole deposit, like florets in a cauliflower. Imaging and fractal analysis showed orderly cubic microcrystals packed in a hierarchy inside the crust. A growth model then delivered a surprise. The final height of a deposit is set mainly by how much salt was there at the start, not by flow forces inside the crust.

Catalog record

CREATORR.J. Wijnhorst, M. Prat, N. Shahidzadeh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18779

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Self-similarity in creeping salt crystallization R.J. Wijnhorst, M. Prat, N. Shahidzadeh Abstract The self-amplifying creeping of salts can produce striking macroscopic structures, such as desert roses in arid regions and salt pillars near saline lakes. While these formations are visually remarkable, salt crystallization—often seen as efflorescence on surfaces—also poses significant challenges for cultural heritage conservation, materials science, and soil management. In this study, we investigate the mechanisms underlying self-organized crystallization within efflorescence deposits. Our findings reveal that these porous salt deposits exhibit pronounced self-similarity, with the crystallization process recurring at multiple length scales. This results in smaller replicas of the overall structure nested within larger ones, creating fractal geometries similar to those found in cauliflower and broccoli. By performing controlled evaporation experiments and microscale analysis using advanced imaging techniques combined with fractal dimension analysis, we uncover the hierarchical and size-controlled precipitation of cubic microcrystals within the porous efflorescence. Furthermore, we develop a hierarchical growth model demonstrating that the ultimate height of the macroscopic salt deposit is primarily determined by the initial mass of salt, rather than by the interplay of capillary and viscous forces when salt solution flows within the porous salt structure. These insights provide a deeper understanding of mineral precipitation and growth, illustrating how natural self-organization at the microscale can give rise to spectacular hierarchical structures. Our results have important implications for managing salt-related phenomena in both natural and engineered environments, and for addressing practical challenges in conservation and materials science. keywords NaCl, salt crystallization, efflorescence, salt creep, self-similarity, emergence, fractals † † affiliation: Van der Waals-Zeeman Institute, Institute of Physics, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands † † affiliation: Institut de Mécanique des Fluides de Toulouse (IMFT), Université de Toulouse, CNRS, Toulouse, France † † email: [email protected] Salts in natural environments create spectacular landscapes but can also pose significant threats to ecosystems and historical artifacts Pitman and Läuchli 2002 ; Cooke 1981 ; Shahidzadeh-Bonn et al. 2010 . Salts can dissolve in water and be transported over long distances, precipitating again where the water evaporates. This can occur, for example, when the water table rises by capillarity to the surface of soils ( granular materials ) to evaporate or when evaporation occurs near salt lakes. This is the origin of salt creeping, a phenomenon where salt crystals continue to precipitate far from an evaporating salt solution boundary Washburn 2002 ; Huang and Huang 1976 ; Hird and Bolton 2016 ; Qazi et al. 2019 . Qazi et al. demonstrated the self-amplifying mechanism of salt creeping far from the solution source. Due to multiple nucleation sites at the evaporation front , the spreading of the salt solution is enhanced well beyond the initial liquid/air front of the solution Hird and Bolton 2016 ; Qazi et al. 2019 . This, in turn, enlarges the evaporative area, leading to faster precipitation; this creates a self-amplifying process. The process results in three-dimensional crystalline networks at macroscopic distances from the salt solution source Qazi et al. 2019 . Such crystallization process can initiate and grow on flat surfaces known as salt creeping and on the surface of porous materials such as soil or stones, known as salt efflorescence Desarnaud et al. 2015 ; Qazi et al. 2019 ; Veran-Tissoires et al. 2012 . The process results in spectacular structures in natural environments, such as the formation of desert roses (assemblies of CaSO_{4} or BaSO_{4} crystals) in arid regions, salt pillars or other spectacular morphologies near the Black and Dead Sea coasts, and in Ethiopia’s Danakil Depression (see Figure 1 a) Shahid and Abdelfattah 2009 . Additionally, salt creep can lead to soil salinization, vegetation decline, and water quality issues, impacting biodiversity Pitman and Läuchli 2002 . Furthermore, the salt’s ability to ’creep’ causes damage in areas further than expected and can also damage outdoor electronics Hienonen and Lahtinen 2000 and built cultural heritage, leading to costly restoration efforts. The efflorescence of the most ubiquitous salt on Earth, Sodium Chloride (NaCl), is commonly referred in the literature as ’cauliflower-shaped morphology’ or ’patchy’ efflorescence due to its resemblance to cauliflower or broccoli (see Figure 1 b) Eloukabi et al. 2013 ; Veran-Tissoires and Prat 2014 ; Bergstad and Shokri 2016 ; Shahidzadeh-Bonn et al. 2008 . It has been reported that these cauliflower structures, once formed on top of porous/granular materials, are also porous and can subsequently absorb liquid by capillarity from the partially saturated porous materials upon evaporation (Figure 1 c) Eloukabi et al. 2013 ; Sghaier and Prat 2009 ; Lazhar et al. 2020 . Here, we report on the microscale structure of precipitated salt as efflorescence and show that salt creeping induces the formation of a hierarchical porous medium. The internal porous structure is made of crystals with a fractal structure characterized by a self-organized, self-similar arrangement of salt crystals. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) images of (NaCl) efflorescences reveal a structure similar to cauliflowers and show that this phenomenon covers many orders of magnitude in length scales, appearing fractal Wijnhorst et al. 2024 . Our results show that the first precipitating large crystals create large pores between them, enabling smaller crystals to nucleate within these spaces, forming smaller pores, and so on. The hierarchicalporous structure of the precipitated salt cluster, with different pore size distributions, allows salt water to be absorbed by capillary pumping, enabling crystallization to continue even further; i.e. the salt solution continue to creep on its own precipitated crystals. The regularity in the crystal size has enabled us to create a predictive model, showing that the competition between capillarity and viscous effects does not limit the efflorescence height. The only limiting factor is the salt source, that is the amount of available salt solution. Our findings reveal how structures such as desert roses or salt pillars can grow to such macroscopic heights with a self-organized strucutre in nature. Figure 1: a) Desert rose in Tunisia (courtesy of Romane Le Dizes Castell), b and c) salt efflorescence grown on top of porous sandstone seen from the side and the top, c) Macroscopic NaCl Pillars grown from evaporating brine solution d) top view of one of the branches of the pillar taken off showing a cauliflower shaped of the polycristalline structure For this purpose, we grown NaCl efflorescence (a) from almost saturated salt solution (5.5 M) in a hydrophobic (borosilicate) glass beaker to mimic the case of evaporation from salt lakes. Hydrophobic treatment based on silanisation is needed to suppress salt creep on hydrophilic glass walls of the beaker and induce preferential salt creeping on macroscopic precipitated salt crystals during evaporation (Figure 1 d). In addition, (b) we grow efflorescence on top of sandstone for situations where salt grows on top of porous materials saturated with salt solution (Figure 1 d). For the latter, before and after liquid immersion, the sandstone samples were weighed followed by sealing with three layers of parafilm on the lateral sides and bottom base to ensure drying solely from the top surface. Cone-shaped sandstone samples were used to facilitate the growth of larger efflorescence structures at an earlier stage of evaporation due to the high number of Péclets that is a characteristic of evaporation in truncated shapes Wijnhorst et al. 2024 . The volume of the

Read the complete text