Structure of leptonic Yukawa couplings in the Zee model
Chuan-Hung Chen · 2025
Read Structure of leptonic Yukawa couplings in the Zee model by Chuan-Hung Chen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18757.txt.
Introduction
Chuan-Hung Chen, writing alone in 2025, studies how tiny neutrino masses arise in one model of particle physics. In the Zee model, those masses come from two sets of couplings, one to a new single field and one to a new Higgs pair. The link between the sets had left much of the model hard to pin down.
Chen uses a neat trait of one coupling set — it is skew in form — to derive a single clean identity. The identity ties the two sets to the mass pattern yet does not depend on the second set at all. Five entries of that set can then be read off, and Chen shows the trick on one sample pattern.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chuan-Hung Chen |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18757
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Structure of leptonic Yukawa couplings in the Zee model Chuan-Hung Chen Abstract The radiative neutrino mass matrix m ν m^{\nu} in the Zee model depends on leptonic Yukawa couplings F F to a singlet scalar and Y ℓ Y^{\ell} to a new Higgs doublet. Leveraging the skew-symmetric structure of F F , we derive a unique identity linking F F and m ν m^{\nu} that is explicitly independent of Y ℓ Y^{\ell} . This relation implies that five entries of Y ℓ Y^{\ell} can, in principle, be determined directly from m ν m^{\nu} and F F , while the remaining four can be selected based on phenomenological assumptions. As an illustration, we apply this framework to the two-zero texture B 2 B2 , highlighting its enhancement of the muon g − 2 g-2 . I Introduction The Majorana neutrino mass matrix can generally be expressed through the master formula Cordero-Carrion:2018xre ; Cordero-Carrion:2019qtu : m^{\nu}=\kappa(F\,MY^{\ell}+Y^{\ell T}\,M^{T}F^{T})\,, (1) where F and Y^{\ell} are Yukawa coupling matrices, M is the fermionic mass matrix of the intermediate states, and \kappa denotes model-dependent prefactors for tree-level, one-loop, or two-loop realizations. The Zee model, uniquely among neutrino mass models, features a skew-symmetric F with three independent entries, corresponding to couplings of an SU(2)_{L} singlet charged scalar to doublet leptons Zee:1980ai . This structure requires Y^{\ell} , which encodes couplings of the new scalars to leptons, to include flavor-changing neutral currents (FCNCs); otherwise, the vanishing of the diagonal elements of m^{\nu} would conflict with neutrino oscillation data. FCNCs in the lepton sector are tightly constrained by charged lepton-flavor violation (cLFV) processes, including tree-level muonium-antimuonium oscillations and trilepton decays \ell_{i}\to\ell_{j}\ell_{k}\ell_{l} , as well as loop-induced channels such as radiative decays \ell_{i}\to\ell_{j}\gamma and \mu-e conversion in nuclei. Interestingly, a value of Y^{\ell}_{22} of order 0.1 , consistent with cLFV bounds, can significantly enhance the muon anomalous magnetic dipole moment ( g-2 ) Chowdhury:2022moc ; Heeck:2023iqc . To accommodate neutrino oscillation data, cLFV bounds, and/or the muon g-2 , specific textures for F and Y^{\ell} are often assumed Chowdhury:2022moc ; Heeck:2023iqc ; Herrero-Garcia:2017xdu ; Primulando:2022vip . An alternative parametrization, defining MY^{\ell}=Z+Q with FQ=Q^{T}F , yields m^{\nu}=FZ-Z^{T}F . Here, the five-entry Z is fixed by F and m^{\nu} , while Q , irrelevant to m^{\nu} , introduces four parameters q_{i} Machado:2017flo , constructed from F and Y^{\ell} . This parametrization is subsequently adopted in phenomenological studies Heeck:2023iqc . While texture-based and Z\textendash Q parametrizations aid numerical fits, they obscure the underlying relationships among F , Y^{\ell} , m^{\nu} , and cLFV constraints, with Y^{\ell} appearing only indirectly through the q_{i} in the latter. To elucidate the underlying structure of m^{\nu} , F , and Y^{\ell} without additional assumptions, we analyze Eq. ( 1 ) in detail. Two key features emerge: (i) the skew-symmetric F defines a pseudovector u satisfying F\cdot u=0 , which leads to u^{T}m^{\nu}u=0 Felkl:2021qdn , establishing a relation between F and m^{\nu} that is independent of Y^{\ell} ; (ii) only five of the nine entries in Y^{\ell} can be determined by m^{\nu} and F , leaving four undetermined. Accordingly, we derive complete expressions for Y^{\ell} in terms of m^{\nu} , m_{\ell} , and F , and identify viable choices for the undetermined entries under constraints such as m_{e}\ll m_{\mu,\tau} , muonium–antimuonium oscillations, \mu\to 3e , and \mu\to e\gamma . We demonstrate that setting specific Y^{\ell} entries to zero can evade cLFV constraints. As an illustration, the framework is applied to the two-zero texture B2 . The paper is organized as follows. Sec. II briefly summarizes the relevant interactions in the Zee model. In Sec. III , we derive the unique correlation between the skew-symmetric Yukawa matrix F and m^{\nu} , and present compact relationships among new scalar couplings, m^{\nu} , and the charged-lepton masses. Guided by phenomenological considerations, we identify candidate entries of Y^{\ell} that are insensitive to m^{\nu} . Their vanishing simplifies the numerical analysis. Sec. IV applies the framework to realize the two-zero texture B2 and presents the associated results. A summary of the study is given in Sec. V . II Leptonic Yukawa couplings and radiative neutrino mass matrix In this section, we briefly review the relevant interactions in the Zee model. To radiatively generate Majorana neutrino masses without introducing additional exotic fermions, the standard model (SM) is extended to include a second Higgs doublet, H_{2} , and a charged scalar singlet, \chi^{+} . Lepton number is explicitly violated by the trilinear term H^{T}_{1}i\tau_{2}H_{2}\chi^{-} in the scalar potential, where \tau_{2} is the second Pauli matrix. Based on the SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y} gauge symmetry, the relevant Yukawa couplings and the trilinear scalar interaction can be written as: -{\cal L}\supset\bar{L}\left(y^{\ell}_{1}H_{1}+y^{\ell}_{2}H_{2}\right)\ell_{R}+L^{T}Ci\tau_{2}FL\chi^{+}+\mu H^{T}_{1}i\tau_{2}H_{2}\chi^{-}+H.c.\,, (2) where y^{\ell}_{1,2} are leptonic Yukawa coupling matrices, C is the charge-conjugation operator, and F is a skew-symmetric Yukawa matrix. In the Zee model, y^{\ell}_{1} and y^{\ell}_{2} must not be aligned in order to fit the observed neutrino oscillation data. Since quark couplings play no role in this context, we do not discuss them further. The Higgs flavor basis H_{1} and H_{2} is used in Eq. ( 2 ), where H_{1} and H_{2} are defined such that the neutral component of H_{1} acquires a vacuum expectation value (VEV) responsible for electroweak symmetry breaking, while H_{2} has a vanishing VEV Davidson:2005cw . Their components in the SU(2)_{L} doublets can be expressed as H^{T}_{1}=(G^{+},(v+H^{0}_{1}+iG^{0})/\sqrt{2}) and H^{T}_{2}=(H^{+},(H^{0}_{2}+iA^{0})/\sqrt{2}) . Here, G^{+} and G^{0} denote the Goldstone bosons, H^{0}_{1,2} are CP-even neutral scalars, and A^{0} is a CP-odd scalar. If CP-even and CP-odd scalars do not mix, A^{0} corresponds directly to a mass eigenstate. The CP-even scalars H^{0}_{1} and H^{0}_{2} , as well as the charged scalars H^{+} and \chi^{+} , can mix. Their relations with the physical mass eigenstates can be parametrized as: \left(\begin{array}[]{c}H^{0}_{1}\\ H^{0}_{2}\\ \end{array}\right)=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}c_{\beta-\alpha}&s_{\beta-\alpha}\\ -s_{\beta-\alpha}&c_{\beta-\alpha}\\ \end{array}\right)\left(\begin{array}[]{c}H\\ h\\ \end{array}\right)\,,~~\left(\begin{array}[]{c}H^{+}\\ \chi^{+}\\ \end{array}\right)=\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}c_{\theta}&-s_{\theta}\\ s_{\theta}&c_{\theta}\\ \end{array}\right)\left(\begin{array}[]{c}H\\ h\\ \end{array}\right)\,, (3) with c_{\beta-\alpha}=\cos(\beta-\alpha) , s_{\beta-\alpha}=\sin(\beta-\alpha) , c_{\theta}=\cos\theta , and s_{\theta}=\sin\theta . Note that the mixing between H^{+} and \chi^{+} arises from the trilinear \mu term in Eq. ( 2 ). If the charged lepton mass matrix is diagonalized through m^{\ell}_{\rm dia}=v/\sqrt{2}(V^{L\dagger}_{\ell}y^{\ell}_{1}V^{R}_{\ell}) , the Yukawa couplings of H^{0}_{1,2} , H^{-} , and \chi^{+} to physical charged leptons can be written as: \displaystyle\begin{split}-{\cal L}^{\ell}_{Y}&=\bar{\ell}_{R}m^{\ell}_{\rm dia}\ell_{L}\left(1+\frac{H^{0}_{1}}{v}\right)+\bar{\ell}_{R}Y^{\ell}\ell_{L}(H^{0}_{2}+iA^{0})\\ &+\sqrt{2}\bar{\ell}_{R}Y^{\ell}\nu_{L}H^{-}+2\nu^{T}_{L}CF\ell_{L}\chi^{+}+H.c.\,,\end{split} (4) with Y^{\ell}=(V^{\ell\dagger}_{L}y^{\ell}_{2}V^{\ell}_{R}/\sqrt{2})^{\dagger} . As neutrino masses arise radiatively, the neutrinos appearing in the tree-level interactions of Eq. ( 4 ) are effectively massless. Based on the interactions in Eq. ( 4 ) and the charged scalar mixing angle \theta defined in Eq. ( 3 ), the loop-induced Majorana neutrino mass matrix mediated by charged scalars can be expressed as: m^{\nu}=\kappa(Fm_{\ell}Y^{\ell}+Y^{\ell T}m_{\ell}F^{T})\,, (5) where m_{\ell}={\rm diag}(m_{e},m_{\mu},m_{\tau}) is the diagonal charged-lepton mass matrix, and \kappa is the loop factor, given by \kappa=\frac{\sqrt{2}s_{2\theta}}{16\pi^{2}}\ln\left(\frac{m^{2}_{H^{+}_{1}}}{m^{2}_{H^{+}_{2}}}\right)\,. (6) Here, s_{2\theta}=\sin 2\theta , and m_{H^{+}_{1}} and m_{H^{+}_{2}} denote the physical masses of H^{+} and \chi^{+} , respectively. Introducing the unitary transformation \nu_{L}\to U^{\dagger}\nu_{L} , the Majorana neutrino mass matrix in Eq. ( 5 ) can be diagonalized as m^{\nu}_{\rm dia}=U^{T}m^{\nu}U . The unitary matrix U then appears in the weak charged-current interaction as \bar{\ell}_{L}\gamma^{\mu}U\nu_{L}W^{-}_{\mu} . After removing the unphysical phases of U , U contains six independent parameters: three mixing angles, one Dirac CP-violating phase, and two Majorana phases. The standard parametrization of the mixing matrix U