Contribution of Subthreshold States to the Residual Energy Distribution of 159 Dy
Tadafumi Kishimoto, Toru Sato · 2025
Read Contribution of Subthreshold States to the Residual Energy Distribution of 159 Dy by Tadafumi Kishimoto, Toru Sato (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18562.txt.
Introduction
Tadafumi Kishimoto and Toru Sato add atomic states that are often left out to a calculation of nuclear decay in a 2025 physics paper. They study the residual energy distribution in electron capture by dysprosium-159. In that process, an atom swallows one of its own electrons and emits a neutrino. Subthreshold atomic states, hole states that energy rules forbid, are usually left out of standard spectral work.
Including those states raised the capture rate near the region where the neutrino leaves with zero momentum by more than an order of magnitude. The rise grows further with larger energy release values, against the standard view. The analysis shows the spectral function can be probed in tests, with results that matter for such studies.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tadafumi Kishimoto, Toru Sato |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18562
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Contribution of Subthreshold States to the Residual Energy Distribution of 159 Dy Tadafumi Kishimoto, Toru Sato Abstract We investigate the residual energy distribution in the electron capture (EC) process of 159 Dy, emphasizing the role of subthreshold atomic states, which have typically been omitted in conventional spectral analyses. By incorporating these energetically forbidden hole states into the spectral function P ( E ) P(E) , we demonstrate a significant enhancement - over an order of magnitude - in the EC rate near the zero-momentum neutrino emission region. This enhancement increases further with larger Q Q values, contrary to standard expectations. Our analysis shows that P ( E ) P(E) can be experimentally determined, resolving ambiguities near the endpoint and enabling new approaches to ‘ultra-low Q Q value’ EC reactions for neutrino mass studies. Observations of neutrino fluxes led to the discovery of neutrino oscillations Cleveland et al. 1998 ; Fukuda et al. 1998 ; Ahmad et al. 2002 , demonstrating that neutrinos are massive particles. Despite numerous efforts to measure the neutrino mass, only upper limits have been established thus far. Cosmological studies place an upper limit of approximately 1 eV on the sum of all neutrino masses Bennett et al. 2013 ; Ade et al. 2016 . Similarly, the absence of neutrinoless double beta decay provides an upper limit of 0.04-0.3 eV for the Majorana mass Abe et al. 2023 ; Agostini et al. 2023 . Recent direct measurements have established an upper limit of 0.9 eV for the electron neutrino mass Aker et al. 2022 . Although the mass differences between the three neutrino species are known, the absolute masses of the neutrinos remain undetermined. Measurement of the decay kinematics provides a model-independent method for determining the neutrino mass. Among the three neutrino species, the electron neutrino offers the best opportunity for mass measurement, owing to its smallest decay kinetic energy. The influence of the electron antineutrino mass can be observed in the shape of the spectrum of beta decay or EC. 3 H decay has been the focus of extensive study due to its Q value of 18.7 keV Aker et al. 2022 . Even with this low Q value, the fraction of the decay rate in the region of interest (ROI) for the energy width ( \Delta E ) at the endpoint region is ({\Delta E\over Q})^{3}\sim 10^{-13} for \Delta E\sim 1 eV, where the sub-eV neutrino mass effect is expected to manifest. 187 Re decay has an even smaller Q value of 2.49 keV Nesterenko et al. 2014 . The fraction of ROI 10^{-10} is much higher than that of 3 H. However, its total decay rate (1/lifetime) is 9 orders of magnitude smaller than that of 3 H because the smaller Q value results in a smaller total decay rate, and 3 H undergoes an allowed transition whereas 187 Re undergoes a forbidden transition. The suitability of a particular decay process for study primarily depends on the Q value, although other factors must also be considered. For EC, the situation differs somewhat. The decay rate of the EC process is proportional to Q^{2} , which reflects only the phase space of the emitted neutrino. Consequently, a small Q value is more advantageous for EC than for beta decay. For instance, in 163 Ho decay, which has a Q value of 2.6 keV Velte et al. 2019 , this characteristic proves advantageous for neutrino mass studies. Recently, candidates for ‘ultra-low Q value’ beta decay and EC have been reported Redshaw 2023 ; Keblbeck et al. 2023 . Among these, EC to 159 Dy, specifically to the 5/2^{-} excited state of 159 Tb, has been proposed to have the smallest Q value Ge et al. 2021 . It is Q-\Delta_{\rm nucl}=1.18(19) keV, where Q=364.93(19) keV and \Delta_{\rm nucl}=363.5449(14) keV is the energy of the nuclear excited state. The measurement of the residual energy left in the daughter atom provides the total energy of the neutrino, enabling the extraction of the neutrino mass from the spectrum shape near the endpoint region. For EC, however, the spectrum shape is controlled not only by the phase space factor of the neutrino but also by the strength distribution of electron hole states. In the EC process, electrons are absorbed from the s_{1/2} or p_{1/2} orbitals, and the residual energy is predominantly determined by the energy of the atomic hole state. For the 159 Dy EC, the binding energy of the atomic N orbit is 0.4 keV, which is only 0.78 keV away from the point of minimum neutrino energy. To date, predictions of the neutrino energy spectrum have included only energetically allowed hole states (”continuum states”), where the excitation energy of the residual atom E_{\rm ex} satisfies E_{\rm ex}<Q-\Delta_{\rm nucl}-m_{\nu} . In this paper, we highlight the importance of including EC to energetically forbidden excited states (”subthreshold states”) of the daughter atom. We demonstrate that the contribution of these states enhances the partial capture rate by more than an order of magnitude near the minimum neutrino energy for 159 Dy. This analysis opens new avenues for exploring ‘ultra-low Q value’ EC reactions in neutrino mass searches. The transition matrix element of EC is given as: \displaystyle T_{{\cal F}{\cal I}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{G_{\beta}}{\sqrt{2}}\int d\bm{x}<{\cal F}|J_{\mu}(\bm{x})\bar{u}(\bm{p}_{\nu})e^{-i\bm{p}_{\nu}\cdot\bm{x}}\gamma^{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})\psi_{e}(\bm{x})|{\cal I}>. (1) Here, |{\cal I}> and {\cal F}> represent the initial and final nuclear and atomic states, respectively. J_{\mu} and \psi_{e}(\bm{x}) are the hadronic weak current density and the electron field operator. The rate of EC is given as: \displaystyle\lambda_{\rm EC} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 2\pi\int\frac{d\bm{p}_{\nu}}{(2\pi)^{3}}\sum_{{\cal F},\bar{{\cal I}}}\delta(E_{\cal I}-E_{\cal F}-E_{\nu})|T_{{\cal F}{\cal I}}|^{2}, (2) where \sum_{{\cal F},\bar{\cal I}} represents the sum over the final states and the average over the initial spin states. The neutrino energy is given as E_{\nu}=E_{\cal I}-E_{\cal F}=Q-\Delta_{\rm nucl}-E_{\rm ex} . The energy differential rate of EC, corresponding to the experimentally obtained energy spectrum, is expressed as the product of the nuclear reduced matrix element C , the atomic spectral function P(E_{\rm ex}) , and the phase space factor of the neutrino p_{\nu}E_{\nu} while neglecting the small width of the nuclear excited state: \displaystyle\frac{d\lambda_{\rm EC}}{dE_{\nu}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{G_{\beta}^{2}}{2\pi}p_{\nu}E_{\nu}CP(E_{\rm ex}), (3) where its integration over neutrino energy gives the EC decay rate: \displaystyle\lambda_{\rm EC} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{m_{\nu}}^{Q-\Delta_{\rm nucl}}\ \frac{d\lambda_{\rm EC}}{dE_{\nu}}dE_{\nu}. (4) The response of the atomic system is accounted for through the spectral function, which is defined by summing over all possible atomic final states with excitation energy E_{\rm ex} : \displaystyle P(E_{\rm ex})=\sum_{\bar{i}}<i|\psi^{\dagger}_{e,\alpha}(0)\delta(E_{\rm ex}-H_{\rm atom})\psi_{e,\beta}(0)|i>(1-\gamma_{5})_{\alpha,\beta}. (5) Here, |i> denotes the atomic ground state of the parent atom, and H_{\rm atom} is the Hamiltonian of the daughter atomic system, with the ground state energy set to zero. \alpha and \beta represent the Dirac components of the electron field operator \psi_{e} . The Dirac matrix 1-\gamma_{5} projects left-handed electrons. For the allowed Gamow-Teller transition, the dependence on neutrino energy for the nuclear transition matrix element can be safely neglected at low energy. In a leading-order approximation, the lepton wave functions are evaluated at the origin Horiuchi et al. 2021 leading to Eq. ( 5 ). The nuclear reduced matrix element C in Eq. ( 3 ) is expressed as: \displaystyle C \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{|<F||\bm{A}||I>|^{2}}{2J_{i}+1}. (6) Here |F> and |I> represent the final and initial nuclear states, respectively, and \bm{A}