Exploration of Hexagonal, Layered Carbides and Nitrides as Ultra-High Temperature Ceramics
Kat Nykiel, Brian Wyatt, Babak Anasori, Alejandro Strachan · 2025
Read Exploration of Hexagonal, Layered Carbides and Nitrides as Ultra-High Temperature Ceramics by Kat Nykiel, Brian Wyatt, Babak Anasori, Alejandro Strachan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18455.txt.
Introduction
Kat Nykiel, Brian Wyatt, Babak Anasori, and Alejandro Strachan hunt for new ceramics that can survive the fiercest heat in jet engines and hypersonic craft. Layered crystal forms are known to toughen these ultra-high temperature materials, but which chemistries can form them, and how stable they are, remained open.
The team screened a wide grid of metals paired with carbon or nitrogen in layered arrangements, using heavy computation to test stability and stiffness. Dozens of new layered materials passed, with stability rivaling known phases. Learning models fed with the computed data then predicted melting points, and a handful of candidates topped twenty-five hundred kelvin. The authors argue the widened menu could ease manufacturing too, since some layered forms grow from flaky precursors at lower temperatures.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kat Nykiel, Brian Wyatt, Babak Anasori, Alejandro Strachan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18455
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Exploration of Hexagonal, Layered Carbides and Nitrides as Ultra-High Temperature Ceramics Kat Nykiel, Brian Wyatt, Babak Anasori, Alejandro Strachan Abstract Layered, hexagonal crystal structures, like zeta and eta phases, play an important role in ultra-high temperature ceramics, often significantly increasing toughness of carbide composites. Despite their importance open questions remain about their structure, stability, and compositional pervasiveness. We use high-throughput density functional theory to characterize the thermodynamic stability and elastic constants of layered carbides and nitrides M n+1 X n with n n = 1, 2, and 3, M M = Ta, Ti, Hf, Zr, Nb, Mo, V, W, Sc, Cr, Mn and X X = C, N. The stacking sequences explored are inspired by the possible use of MXenes as precursors to enable relatively low temperature processing of high-temperature ceramics. We identified 67 new hexagonal, layered materials with thermal stability comparable or better than previously observed zeta phases. To assess their potential for high temperature applications, we used machine learning and physics-based models with DFT inputs to predict their melting temperatures and discovered several candidates on par with the current state of the art zeta-like phases and five with predicted melting temperatures above 2500 K. The findings expand the range of chemistries and structures for high-temperature applications. Materials that can perform at extreme temperatures and other stressors are of interest in hypersonics, nuclear reactors, and even solar power plants [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Ultra-high temperature ceramics (UHTCs), typically defined as materials with stable properties above 2300 K, include the highest-known melting temperature materials, found in the Hf-C system at \sim 4500 K [ 4 ] . The cubic TaC phase, another Group VB carbide, achieves a comparably high melting temperature of \sim 4200 K [ 4 ] , while the hexagonal Ta 2 C phase has a melting temperature of \sim 3600 K [ 5 ] . Notably, the Ta-C system forms an additional phase, the hexagonal \zeta -Ta 4 C 3-x phase, which is advantageous due to its high reported fracture toughness of 15.6 ± 0.5 MPa m 1/2 and fracture strength of 508 ± 97 MPa [ 6 ] . This high fracture toughness has been attributed to cleaving along the missing carbon layers in the vacancy-ordered \zeta -Ta 4 C 3-x phase [ 6 ] . This Ta 4 C 3-x \zeta -phase has a reported upper stability limit of \sim 2400 K [ 7 ] , though others have suggested this phase is metastable up to 3200 K [ 8 ] . In addition, the Ta 3 C 2 phase has been suggested as the perfectly ordered zeta phase in the Ta-C system, with the Ta 4 C 3-x phase being metastable [ 9 ] . Non-Ta \zeta -M 4 C 3-x carbides has been experimentally observed in V-C and Nb-C multi-component systems [ 10 ] , though disagreements about their upper stability limits exist [ 11 ] . Reports of these limits range from 1590 K [ 12 ] to 1980 K [ 10 ] for V-C and 1850 K [ 10 ] for Nb-C. The \zeta -Nb 4 C 3-x phase exhibits slow formation kinetics [ 10 ] , making its upper stability limit comparatively difficult to study. Additional work is needed to clarify the upper stability limits of these phases. This study explores the thermodynamical stability and melting of a wide range of possible layered, hexagonal structure and chemical space. One factor complicating the determination of stability of zeta and similar phases is the high temperature and pressure required for their formation. The synthesis of \zeta -Ta 4 C 3-x is performed by pressing powders at at 2100 K [ 7 , 13 ] or by pressureless sintering at 2270-2300 K [ 8 ] . Alternative synthesis routes are therefore highly desirable. In this work, we explore layered hexagonal phases that could be produced by stacking 2D MXenes. This process can provide a lower-temperature processing alternative to high-temperature ceramics. Stacking of 2D materials to form bulk structures has been documented in other chemical spaces, with successful synthesis reported in transition metal dichalcogenides [ 14 ] and BaFZnP [ 15 ] , among other systems. MXenes, a class of layered 2D materials where M denotes a transition metal and X is carbon or nitrogen, are a promising alternative as recently proposed [ 16 ] . MXenes contain alternating M and X layers in an FCC sequence in the ratio M_{n+1}X_{n} , for n = 1,2,3 and share their chemical space with UHTCs. The five transition metals commonly used in UHTCs have been successfully incorporated into MXenes: Hf [ 17 ] , Ta [ 18 ] , Zr [ 19 ] , Ti [ 20 ] , and Nb [ 21 ] . Stacking of 2D MXene sheets into bulk systems creates a set of vacancy-ordered zeta-like , layered structures; for example, sintering Ti 3 C 2 T X sheets has resulted bulk layered structures [ 22 ] . We systematically explore the stability, structure, and elastic constants of the 352 layered bulk structures that can be formed by stacking up to three M_{2}X , M_{3}X_{2} , or M_{4}X_{3} layers. We also expand the chemical space beyond Group VB elements with M = Ta, Ti, Hf, Zr, Nb, Mo, V, W, Sc, Cr, Mn and X = C, N. We discovered 67 new materials with stability comparable or better than the ones previously reported. We use ML and physics-based models to explore the thermal stability of these alloys and find several potential structures for high-temperature applications. Results Figure 1: Workflow schematic. The domain of investigated hexagonal, layered structures includes is defined in the first panel. The second panel shows several of the unique unit cells, on which we run density functional theory. We use the DFT results as inputs to a parsimonious neural network, as shown in the third panel. Figure 1 summarizes our approach. We start with the 16 unique layered unit cells resulting from stacking MXene-like sheets, including rotations and translations that change the stacking sequence. These 16 structures are listed in the Supplemental Information. We describe the stacking sequence of each structure using the letters h and c to indicate the hexagonal (ABA) or cubic (ABC) stacking around the layer, following Jagodzinski-Wyckoff notation. M-M layers are indicated by a dash in the sequence, e.g. hch - hch . An example of this descriptor is provided in Figure 5 in Methods for the prototypical vacanacy-ordered zeta phase. We refer to these structures as vacancy-ordered because the M-M layers between sheets contain an ordered plane of carbon vacancies. Considering the chemical space of 11 metals, C and N, we used DFT to relax and compute the elastic constants of 352 materials, see Methods for the simulation details. We computed the thermodynamic stability of all configurations by constructing the convex hull of each chemical system, including all available structures within each chemical system from the Materials Project [ 23 ] . Figure 2 shows the convex hull for Ta-C, the prototypical UHTC system, with insets demonstrating possible M-X layering at each composition, and the number of stable systems for each metal system. Interestingly, we find that the majority of layered