Comparing Periodic Point Invariants for Parameterized Families of Maps

Lucas Williams · 2025

Read Comparing Periodic Point Invariants for Parameterized Families of Maps by Lucas Williams (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18339.txt.

Introduction

Lucas Williams compares, in a 2025 topology paper, two ways of counting what repeats when a map is applied again and again across a whole family of maps. For a single map, two classic traces were known to carry the same information: the Fuller trace and the set of Reidemeister traces of all iterates.

Williams shows the family version breaks that tie. When maps vary over a compact parameter space, the fiberwise Fuller trace detects strictly more than the Reidemeister collection, settling a conjecture by Malkiewich and Ponto. The construction also yields a geometric picture of elements in the kernel of the ghost map from a modern homology theory, tying dynamics to deep algebra.

Catalog record

CREATORLucas Williams
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18339

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Comparing Periodic Point Invariants for Parameterized Families of Maps Lucas Williams Abstract . We compare different periodic point invariants for families of maps parameterized over a compact manifold. Malkiewich and Ponto showed that, in the case of a single map, the Fuller trace is equivalent to the collection of Reidmeister traces of iterates. In this paper, we show that, in contrast to the case of a single map, the fiberwise Fuller trace is a strictly more sensitive invariant than the collection of fiberwise Reidemeister traces of iterates. This resolves a conjecture of Malkiewich and Ponto. 1. Introduction Let M be a compact manifold and f\colon M\to M a continuous map. The Lefschetz trace of f , denoted L(f)\in\mathbb{Z} , can be interpreted as a weighted sum of the fixed points of f . The Lefschetz trace has many generalizations which have been studied from a homotopical and K -theoretic vantage point in papers such as [ DP80 , KW07 , MP22 , Pon10 , GN99 ] . In the present work, we will focus on generalizations of the Lefschetz trace that count the n -periodic points of f , or equivalently the fixed points of f^{n} , where f\colon E\to E is a family of maps parameterized over a compact manifold. In the case of a single map, f\colon M\to M , the Lefschetz traces vanishes if f is homotopic to a map with no fixed points. The converse however, is false. To obtain a complete obstruction to the removal of fixed points from f , the Lefschetz trace must be refined to the Reidemeister trace R(f) . The Reidemeister trace takes values in the 0th homology of the twisted free loop space of f , which is defined as \Lambda^{f}M=\{\gamma\colon I\to M\mid f(\gamma(1))=\gamma(0)\}. If M is a compact manifold of dimension not equal to 2, then the Reidemeister trace, R(f) , is a complete obstruction to the removal of fixed points from f . In other words, f is homotopic to a map without fixed points if and only if R(f) vanishes [ Jia80 , Wec42 ] . In [ MP22 ] , Malkiewich and Ponto study several invariants for n -periodic points of f:M\to M , or rather, the fixed points of f^{n} . The easiest of these to define is the collection of Reidemeister traces of iterates, \{R(f^{k}):k\mid n\} . The other invariant is a C_{n} -equivariant construction called the Fuller trace of f . The Fuller trace is defined by first observing that the fixed points of the C_{n} -equivariant map \displaystyle M\times\dots\times M \displaystyle\xrightarrow{\Psi^{n}(f)}M\times\dots\times M \displaystyle(x_{1},\dots,x_{n}) \displaystyle\mapsto(f(x_{n}),f(x_{1}),\dots,f(x_{n-1})) are precisely the n -periodic points of f\colon M\to M [ Ful67 , Dol83 ] . Here the C_{n} -action cycles the coordinates of M^{\times n} . Moreover, if f is homotopic to a map with no n -periodic points then \Psi^{n}(f) is C_{n} -equivariantly homotopic to a map with no fixed points. The n th Fuller trace of f is the C_{n} -equivariant Reidemeister trace of \Psi^{n}(f) , and is an obstruction to removing the n -periodic points from f by a homotopy. The n -Fuller trace is a map of genuine C_{n} -spectra R_{C_{n}}(\Psi^{n}(f))\colon\mathbb{S}\to\Sigma_{+}^{\infty}\Lambda^{\Psi^{n}f}M^{\times n}. In [ MP22 , Corollary 1.3] , Malkiewich and Ponto answer a conjecture of [ KW10 ] by proving that the set of Reidemeister traces \{R(f^{k}):k\mid n\} can be recovered from the Fuller trace R_{C_{n}}(\Psi^{n}(f)) . The vanishing of R_{C_{n}}(\Psi^{n}(f)) implies the vanishing of R(f^{k}) for all k|n . Combining this result with [ Jez01 ] yields the following Corollary. If M is a smooth (or PL) compact manifold of dimension at least three, R(f^{k}) vanishes in the homotopy category of spectra for all k|n if and only if R_{C_{n}}(\Psi^{n}(f)) vanishes in the homotopy category of C_{n} -spectra if and only if f is homotopic to a map with no n -periodic points. To summarize, for sufficiently high dimensional manifolds, the Fuller trace and the collection of Reidemeister traces of iterates are equivalent and both are complete obstructions to the removal of n -periodic points. The present work seeks to study the generalizations of these invariants to the fiberwise setting. In contrast to the setting of a single map, we will show that the fiberwise Fuller trace is not equivalent to the collection of fiberwise Reidemeister traces of iterates. To be precise, we prove the following theorem which resolves [ MP22 , Conjecture 1.9] . Theorem 1.1 . There is a family of maps f\colon E\to E parameterized over a base space B for which the fiberwise Reidemeister traces R_{B}(f) and R_{B}(f^{2}) both vanish, but for which the fiberwise Fuller trace R_{B,C_{2}}(\Psi_{B}^{2}f) is non-vanishing. This theorem demonstrates that, in contrast to the case of a single map, the fiberwise Fuller trace is a strictly stronger invariant than the collection of fiberwise Reidemeister traces of iterates. As a side note, this provides a nice example of equivariant stable homotopy theory playing a crucial role in a problem in differential topology. In future work, joint with Cary Malkiewich and Kate Ponto, we plan to follow up the present paper by investigating the following conjecture. Conjecture 1.2 . [ MP22 , Conjecture 1.8] The fiberwise Fuller trace, R_{B,C_{n}}(\Psi_{B}^{n}f) , is a complete obstruction to the removal of n -periodic points from a family of endomorphisms f\colon E\to E over B when B is a finite dimensional cell complex and E\to B is a manifold bundle with fibers of dimension 3+\dim(B) . 1.1. Organization In section two, we provide background on invariants of fixed and periodic points. In section three, we give an explicit construction which realizes 1.1 . Sections four is devoted to proving 1.1 . 1.2. Acknowledgments Many thanks to John Klein, Cary Malkiewich, and Kate Ponto for helpful conversations and suggestions. Thanks also to the organizing and scientific committees of the 2022 workshop “Homotopical Methods in Fixed Point Theory” which served as the author’s introduction to this subject matter. This paper represents a part of the author’s dissertation written under the supervision of Cary Malkiewich at Binghamton University. 2. Preliminaries In this section we give the necessary background for the paper. We will begin with a minimal discussion on equivariant parameterized stable homotopy theory. We will then cover the relevant background in fixed point theory. Finally, since our main computations will be cobordism theoretic, we will give a few preliminaries on this topic as well. Definition 2.1 . Let B be a G -space. A retractive G -space over B is a G -space X equipped with an equivariant retract p\colon X\to B . Definition 2.2 . Let B be a G -space and X a retractive G -space over B . Let A be a G -space which we will think of as a retractive G -space over * . The external smash product of A and X , denoted A\,\overline{\wedge}\,X , is a retractive G -space over B defined as the pushout: {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces A\times B\cup_{*\times B}*\times X} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces A\times X} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces*\times B} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces A\,\overline{\wedge}\,X.} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\ulcorner} Definition 2.3 . Let B be a G -space and X a retractive G -space over B . The suspension of X over B is \Sigma_{B}X=S^{1}\,\overline{\wedge}\,X . Note that the k -fold suspension of X

Read the complete text