Closed Formulas for η \eta -Corrections in the Once Punctured Torus
Nelson Abdiel Colón Vargas · 2025
Read Closed Formulas for η \eta -Corrections in the Once Punctured Torus by Nelson Abdiel Colón Vargas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18334.txt.
Introduction
Nelson Colón Vargas derives closed formulas in a mathematics paper from two thousand twenty-five. He works in the Kauffman bracket skein algebra of a torus with one puncture. On a closed torus, a known product-to-sum rule gives products explicitly, but the puncture adds correction terms.
For a family built by threading with Chebyshev polynomials, he gives the correction as an explicit expansion. Its coefficients factor into geometric sums, and its terms follow a parity pattern from the Chebyshev recurrence. He also treats a maximal-thread case, where the gap becomes a cascade that lowers thread degree by two at each step. The formulas recover low-determinant behavior and give compact rules for these families.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nelson Abdiel Colón Vargas |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18334
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Closed Formulas for η \eta -Corrections in the Once Punctured Torus Nelson Abdiel Colón Vargas Abstract We study η \eta -correction terms in the Kauffman bracket skein algebra of the once-punctured torus K t ( Σ 1 , 1 ) K_{t}(\Sigma_{1,1}) . While the Frohman-Gelca product-to-sum rule is explicit on the closed torus, punctures introduce correction terms in the ideal ( η ) (\eta) whose structure has resisted systematic description beyond low-determinant cases. We give a closed form for the family P n = ( 1 , 0 ) ⋅ T n ( ( 1 , 2 ) ) P_{n}=(1,0)\cdot T_{n}((1,2)) : the correction ϵ n \epsilon_{n} has an explicit Chebyshev expansion with coefficients that factor as geometric sums in t ± 4 t^{\pm 4} governed by parity. Tracking creation and cancellation of η \eta through the Chebyshev recurrence, and using diffeomorphism invariance, the formula transports to all products C 1 ⋅ T k ( C 2 ) C_{1}\cdot T_{k}(C_{2}) with | det ( C 1 , C 2 ) | = 2 |\det(C_{1},C_{2})|=2 . We further treat the primitive maximal-thread regime, where one Frohman-Gelca summand is fully threaded and the other is simple or doubly covered. In this case we obtain a closed form for the discrepancy: an η \eta -linear cascade with Chebyshev S S -coefficients that lowers the thread degree by two at each step. Equivalently, in this maximal-thread regime we solve the specialized Wang-Wong recursion in closed form; the coefficients match their fast algorithm term-by-term (up to the T 0 T_{0} normalization) and subsume Cho’s | det | = 2 |\det|=2 case. The resulting rules give compact, scalable formulas for symbolic multiplication in K t ( Σ 1 , 1 ) K_{t}(\Sigma_{1,1}) . 1 Introduction The Kauffman bracket skein algebra K_{t}(F) encodes topological information about framed links in the thickened surface F\times[0,1] by imposing local skein relations and a stacking product. When F is a torus, Frohman and Gelca [ FG ] famously showed that multiplication of (threaded) simple closed curves admits a clean product-to-sum rule expressed in terms of the noncommutative torus. Passing to a punctured torus, however, introduces a central element \eta represented by a small loop about the puncture; resolving crossings that encounter the puncture generates additional terms lying in the ideal (\eta) , and the elegant closed-torus formula fractures into a main Frohman–Gelca part plus an \eta -correction. Understanding the structure of these correction terms is central to both the internal algebraic theory and to computational applications in topological quantum field theories, quantum character varieties, and quantum simulation architectures. Understanding the structure of these \eta -correction terms is central to both the internal algebraic theory and to computational applications in topological quantum field theories, quantum character varieties, and quantum simulation architectures. Recent work has established fundamental structural properties of K_{t}(\Sigma_{1,1}) through connections to other areas of mathematics. Bousseau [ Bo ] proved the Thurston positivity conjecture for K_{t}(\Sigma_{1,1}) by connecting the skein algebra to enumerative geometry, realizing the structure constants through counts of curves on complex cubic surfaces using quantum scattering diagrams. Similarly, Queffelec [ Q ] established a general positivity result for the Jones-Wenzl basis on all orientable surfaces (other than the torus) by proving the full functoriality of \mathfrak{gl}_{2} Khovanov homology for webs and foams. These geometric and categorical approaches establish the existence of important structural properties. Despite substantial progress, a conceptual description of \eta -corrections has been available only in restricted regimes. For parallel curves ( |\det|=0 ), the problem reduces to Chebyshev identities with no correction terms. Cho [ C ] established that products of simple curves with |\det|=\pm 2 produce a single \eta . More recently, Wang-Wong [ WWo ] gave a fast algorithmic method that computes the Frohman-Gelca discrepancy D (hence the \eta -correction) on \Sigma_{1,1} via a five-term recursion, thereby determining all products in principle. We introduce a symbolic, pattern-level description that scales, accommodates threaded factors, and exposes the combinatorial mechanism by which \eta -terms propagate. Let C=(p,q) denote a primitive simple closed curve on \Sigma_{1,1} (identified with a homology class in H_{1}(\Sigma_{1,1};\mathbb{Z})\cong\mathbb{Z}^{2} with \gcd(p,q)=1 ). Threaded curves arise by Chebyshev evaluation: if k>1 and (kp,kq) is a multiple of C , then we define (kp,kq)_{T}:=T_{k}(C) . When we multiply a threaded curve T_{n}(C_{2}) by a simple curve C_{1} whose algebraic intersection with C_{2} has modest absolute value, even for |\det(C_{1},C_{2})|=\pm 2 , the naive approach of expanding T_{n} via its recurrence quickly generates a tangle of intermediate products, each possibly introducing puncture loops. Manual calculation becomes uninformative just beyond the smallest values of n . This paper makes progress on this challenge by providing closed formulas for significant families of threaded products. Our main contributions are threefold. First, we provide a closed formula for the canonical infinite family of products P_{n}:=T_{n}((1,2))\cdot(1,0), whose underlying simple curves (1,2) and (1,0) have determinant -2 . Writing L_{k}=\sum_{\ell=-k}^{k}t^{4\ell} , we prove that for n\geq 3 , P_{n}=t^{-2n}(n+1,2n)_{T}+t^{2n}(n-1,2n)_{T}+\epsilon_{n}, (1) where the correction term is \epsilon_{n}=\eta\sum_{k=0}^{\lfloor(n-1)/2\rfloor}\left(T_{n-1-2k}((1,2))-\delta_{n-1-2k,0}\right)L_{k}. (2) Second, Cho [ C ] proved that mapping class group diffeomorphisms carry any primitive pair of curves with |\det|=2 to the standard pair (1,0) and (1,2) . Using this diffeomorphism result, our formulas for P_{n} transport to show that for any simple curve C_{1} and any threaded curve T_{k}(C_{2}) with |\det(C_{1},C_{2})|=2 , the product C_{1}\cdot T_{k}(C_{2}) is explicitly computable by a finite symbolic procedure whose structure mirrors ( 1 )–( 2 ). This yields practical reduction rules useful for large symbolic expansions and quantum circuit compilation. Third, we identify the geometric source of this pattern through what we call the primitive maximal-thread mechanism . For primitive curves (p,q) and (r,s) with determinant n=pr-qs\geq 2 , suppose that one of the Frohman–Gelca summands is threaded with degree n (i.e., either n=\gcd(p+r,q+s) or n=\gcd(p-r,q-s) ). We prove that the product takes the closed form (p,q)\cdot(r,s)=t^{\varepsilon n}T_{d_{1}}(C_{+})+t^{-\varepsilon n}T_{d_{2}}(C_{-})+\epsilon, where C_{+}=(p+r,q+s) , C_{-}=(p-r,q-s) , and d_{1}=\gcd(p+r,q+s) , d_{2}=\gcd(p-r,q-s) with \min\{d_{1},d_{2}\}\in\{1,2\} and \max\{d_{1},d_{2}\}=n , the correction term has the explicit form \epsilon=\eta\cdot\sum_{j=0}^{\left\lfloor\frac{n-2}{2}\right\rfloor}t^{\varepsilon(n-2-2j)}\cdot\left(T_{n-2-2j}(C_{*})-\delta_{n-2-2j,\,0}\right)\cdot S_{j}\left(t^{2}+t^{-2}\right), where the signs and curves are determined by which summand carries the maximal threading. The work extends foundational results of Cho [ C ] on low-determinant cases, incorporates \eta -degree bounds from our previous work with Frohman [ AF ] , and computational methods from Wang–Wong [ WWo ] . The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews skein algebra conventions, threading, and determinant-based correction behavior. Section 3 introduces the family P_{n} , records low- n computations, and proves the parity lemmas that control \eta creation. Section 4 establishes the closed-form expression for P_{n} and develops equivalent coefficient factorizations. Section 5 formulates and proves the primitive maximal-thread correction structure. 2 Preliminaries 2.1 The Kauffman Bracket Skein Algebra K_{t}(F) Given an oriented surface F , we consider framed links within the cylindrical space F\times[0,1] , which are embeddings of disjoint unions of annuli. Taking formal \mathbb{C} -linear combinations of these links and imposing the Kauffman bracket skein relations yields: \displaystyle\langle\raisebox{-3.50006pt}{\includegraphics[width]{crossing.pdf}}\rangle \displaystyle=A\langle\raisebox{-1.99997pt}{\includegraphics[width]{h_smooth.pdf}}\rangle+t^{-1}\langle\raisebox{-3.00003pt}{\includegraphics[width]{v_smooth.pdf}}\rangle \displaystyle\langle L\cup\bigcirc\rangle \displaystyle=(-t^{2}-t^{-2})\langle L\rangle An algebra structure emerges from the product operation given by “stacking” along the [0,1] direction. Definition 2.1 (Simple Closed Curve) . A simple closed curve on the torus is a curve that does not intersect itself.