Linear Superposition Effect at Sources and in Waves
Bingli JIAO · 2025
Read Linear Superposition Effect at Sources and in Waves by Bingli JIAO (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-18330.txt.
Introduction
Bingli Jiao examines how the superposition rule for waves squares with energy conservation in a 2025 physics paper. Adding wave fields point by point can seem to clash with adding their energies, which grow with the square of the field. Jiao argues the rule applies at the sources as well as in the waves, so two close dipoles act as one merged dipole whose effective power is twice the plain sum.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bingli JIAO |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 10 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-18330
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Linear Superposition Effect at Sources and in Waves Bingli JIAO Abstract The superposition law (SL) sums the components of electromagnetic (EM) waves at each spatial point when these waves meet in space. In contrast, the energy conservation law requires energy to be summed in the quadratic form of the EM fields. The mathematical discrepancy of the two laws can lead to different physical results. Specifically, when two co-phase radiation dipoles are placed in close proximity, their radiation waves undergo a co-phase interference throughout space, therefore causing a net increase in wave’s power globally. In the exploration of this, we find that the SL applies not only to waves, but also to the radiation dipoles. By defining the superposed dipole conceptually, we describe the effective radiation power that is twice the power-sum of the two waves, providing a comprehensive understanding of the SL, which is supported by the results of the previous theoretical and experimental studies. Effect of Linear Superposition The Superposition Law (SL) governs the wave-behavior when two or more waves meet in space, and its linear additivity has been confirmed by experiments. In comparison, the Energy Conservation Law (ECL) can be regarded as a law of nonlinear addition — more precisely, one with a squared superposition property — and to some extent it is an empirical law. When the SL is applied to two electromagnetic (EM) waves of the same frequency, the resultant field can be expressed as \begin{split}\overrightarrow{E}(x,y,z,\omega t)=\overrightarrow{E}_{1}(x,y,z,\omega t)+\overrightarrow{E}_{2}(x,y,z,\omega t)\end{split} (1) where \omega is the angular frequency, and x,y,z are the Cartesian coordinates. The vectors \overrightarrow{E}_{1}(x,y,z) and \overrightarrow{E}_{2}(x,y,z) represent the electric field strengths of waves 1 and 2, and \overrightarrow{E}(x,y,z) that of their superposition, respectively. Equation ( 1 ) relates to the energy metric by taking the square operation and the time average as <E^{2}(x,y,z)>=<{E}_{1}^{2}(x,y,z)>+<{E}_{2}^{2}(x,y,z)>+<{\Gamma}(\phi)> (2) with \Gamma(\phi)=2E_{1}(x,y,z)E_{2}(x,y,z)\text{cos}[\phi(x,y,z)] (3) where \langle\cdot\rangle represents the operator of time averaging, \Gamma(\phi) the interference term and \phi the phase difference between the two radiation waves. However, it is found that the energy conservation is a special case of ( 2 ), expressed as <{E}^{2}(x,y,z)>=<{E}_{1}^{2}(x,y,z)>+<{E}_{2}^{2}(x,y,z)>, (4) which definitely requires the nullification of the interference, i.e., \Gamma(\phi)\equiv 0 in ( 3 ). However, since both theoretical analyses and experimental observations substantiate the cases of non-zero values of the interference term, the condition \Gamma(\phi)\equiv 0 cannot, in general, be sustained. Thus, the validity of the SL stands in fundamental conflict with the ECL at the local level, often expressed in terms of power densities in the Poynting theorem. In order to preserve the ECL, researchers attempt to eliminate the local energy abnormalities in ( 2 ) by taking the spatial average, which is expressed as \mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}>\}=\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{1}>\}+\mathfrak{A}\{<E_{2}^{2}>\}+\mathfrak{A}\{<\Gamma(\phi)>\}, (5) with an expectation that \mathfrak{A}\{\Gamma(\phi)\}\equiv 0 (6) where \mathfrak{A}\{\cdot\} represents an operator that calculates the spatial average value over entire space. Unfortunately, ( 6 ) fails in the model studied by Levine in 1980 [1], where the co-phase interference, i.e., \phi\approx 0 , occurs through space, resulting in \mathfrak{A}\{\Gamma(\phi)\}\approx[\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{1}>\}+\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{2}>\}] (7) with assumption of \mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{1}>\}=\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{2}>\} , instead of being zero. As a result, the energy is doubled at the stage of wave’s description, as expressed by \mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}>\}=2[\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{1}>\}+\mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}_{2}>\}]\ \ \ (8) where \mathfrak{A}\{<E^{2}>\} is the total radiation power and ``2" on the right side of the equality is the energy-doubling factor. Actually, the concept of this energy-doubling has been accepted there [1-4]. It is worthy of mention that the abnormal phenomenon reflected in ( 8 ) was incorrectly attributed to the EM coupling between the sources [1]. This mistake was clarified by researchers who arranged the two sources in a spatially symmetric structure, whereby no matter what EM coupling occurs, the symmetry allows the two sources to radiate in a co-phase manner. In this case, the energy-doubling can still occur at the wave stage. Taking one step further logically, if the energy of the waves is doubled, then the energy of the sources must also be doubled [2]. This is the issue that we will focus on through further analysis. We may infer that the energy behavior above is a property of wave superposition including those with the probability wave, as were observed not only in classical electromagnetic fields [5,6], but also in quantum mechanics [7–9]. Effective Dipole To be specific, we design a symmetric radiation system in free space and represent the two identical dipole antennas as vectors without loss of generality, as illustrated by the snapshot in Fig. 1(a) , to radiate the same power in a co-phase manner. \mathfrak{G} denotes a spherical surface that restricts our study to the far-field regime, with the conditions given by \ \ \ \ \ \ |l+2d|<<\lambda\ \ \text{and}\ \ \ \lambda<<r\ \ \ \ \ \ \ \text{for}\ \ \ \ \ l,d\neq 0\,\ (9) to guarantee the occurrence of co-phase interference of the waves throughout space, where l is the distance between the two charges in each dipole, d is the distance between the two dipoles, \lambda is the wavelength and r is the radius in spherical coordinates. To begin, we examine one radiating dipole and its radiation field while temporarily neglecting the presence of the other dipole. The electric field can be written as [9] <\overrightarrow{E}_{i}>=j\frac{\omega\beta\eta(lq)}{4\pi r_{i}}e^{-j\beta r_{i}}sin(\theta_{i})\overrightarrow{e}_{\theta_{1}}\ \ \ \text{for}\ \ i=1\ \ \text{or}\ \ 2 (10) where \overrightarrow{E}_{i} denotes the electric field strength generated by dipole i , \omega is the angular frequency, \beta=2\pi/\lambda is the wave number, \eta_{0}=\sqrt{(\mu_{0}/\epsilon_{0})} is the intrinsic impedance, r_{i} is distance from dipole i to observation point on the spherical surface and \overrightarrow{e}_{\theta_{i}} is the direction of the electric field, as shown in Fig. 1(a). A key conclusion drawn from ( 10 ) is the fact that the power flow from dipole i vanishes along the z -axis (since \theta_{i}=0 or \pi ), which implies that the EM coupling between the two dipoles is, in principle, zero. To confirm this, refer to [2], which shows the experimental result that the EM coupling can be negligible [2]. In this regard, the individual dipole radiates as if it were alone in performing power, given by [9] P_{i}=\frac{\pi\omega^{2}}{3\lambda^{2}}\eta(lq)^{2} (11) where P_{i} is the radiation power of dipole i . We note that “ {lq} ” in both Eqs. ( 10 ) and ( 11 ) represents the physical metric of the radiation dipole to be considered later. In the far-field regime, we work with the approximations of r_{1}\approx r_{2}\approx r and \overrightarrow{e}_{\theta_{1}}\approx\overrightarrow{e}_{\theta_{2}}\approx\overrightarrow{e}_{\theta} , under which the superposition of the two electric fields expressed in ( 10 ) yields <\overrightarrow{E}_{s}>\approx j\frac{\omega\beta\eta(2lq)}{4\pi r}sin(\theta)e^{-j\beta r}\ \overrightarrow{e}_{\theta}, (12) where <\overrightarrow{E}_{s}> is the resultant field. By comparing ( 12 ) with ( 10 ), we find that the radiation dipole changes from “ lq ” to “ 2lq ”, demonstrating the effect of linear superposition. By referring to “ 2lq ” as an effective dipole, we find further that the total radiation power is doubled by considering Eq. ( 11 ) P_{s}=\frac{\pi\omega^{2}}{3\lambda^{2}}\eta(2lq)^{2}=4P_{i}=2(P_{1}+P_{2}) (13) where P_{s} is defined as the effective radiation power (ERP) of the two dipoles, doubling the sum-power of the individual waves. Since there is no EM coupling between the two dipoles, the radiation power of each dipole remains unchanged, as shown in ( 11 ). Therefore, we turn to accept the fact that the ERP