Nonlinearities of Schwarzschild Black Hole Head-on Collisions
Alex Kehagias, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto · 2025
Read Nonlinearities of Schwarzschild Black Hole Head-on Collisions by Alex Kehagias, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17993.txt.
Introduction
Alex Kehagias, Davide Perrone, and Antonio Riotto compute a nonlinear effect in black hole collisions in this 2025 physics paper. When two non-spinning Schwarzschild black holes hit head-on at near light speed, the merged hole rings down with gravitational waves. That ringdown holds a quadratic quasi-normal mode, a second order echo of the main tone. The event is deeply nonlinear. Yet the authors show that second order perturbation theory suffices for this mode's amplitude, reached by a simple bootstrapping procedure.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alex Kehagias, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17993
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonlinearities of Schwarzschild Black Hole Head-on Collisions Alex Kehagias, Davide Perrone, Antonio Riotto Abstract We derive analytically the amplitude of the quadratic quasi-normal mode generated in the ringdown stage of the gravitational waveform produced by the ultra-relativistic head-on collision of two non-spinning Schwarzschild black holes. Although being a highly nonlinear event, second-order perturbation theory suffices and that nonlinearities may be derived by a simple bootstrapping procedure. Introduction – The advent of gravitational wave (GW) astronomy has ushered in a new era for high-precision tests of strong-field gravity Berti et al. 2015 ; Berti et al. 2018 ; Franciolini et al. 2019 ; Abbott et al. 2021 . Current ground-based interferometers—LIGO, VIRGO, and KAGRA—together with the forthcoming space-based mission LISA, are achieving sensitivities that enable detailed studies of the ringdown phase of black hole (BH) mergers Berti et al. 2006 ; Abbott et al. 2016a ; Abbott et al. 2016b ; Abbott et al. 2023 ; Abac et al. 2024 . A central objective of these efforts is to characterize BH perturbations at late times, where both linear and nonlinear effects leave distinct signatures in the emitted GWs. Traditionally, our understanding of BH ringdowns has relied heavily on linear perturbation theory. Within this framework, BHs are expected to display exponentially damped oscillations—quasinormal modes (QNMs)—at intermediate times, followed by a late-time power-law decay Berti et al. 2025 . Significant progress has been made towards refining predictions for both QNM spectra and late-time tails Ching et al. 1995 ; Krivan et al. 1996 ; Krivan et al. 1997 ; Krivan 1999 ; Burko and Khanna 2003 ; Burko and Khanna 2009 ; Hod 2009 ; Burko and Khanna 2011 ; Racz and Toth 2011 ; Zenginoğlu et al. 2014 ; Burko and Khanna 2014 ; Baibhav et al. 2023 ; Rosato and Pani 2025 ; Ianniccari et al. 2025 . These linear predictions have been robustly validated through numerical relativity simulations and increasingly precise GW observations. In recent years, growing attention has shifted toward nonlinear aspects of BH perturbations Gleiser et al. 1996 ; Gleiser et al. 2000 ; Campanelli and Lousto 1999 ; Garat and Price 2000 ; Zlochower et al. 2003 ; Brizuela et al. 2006 ; Brizuela et al. 2007 ; Nakano and Ioka 2007 ; Brizuela et al. 2009 ; Ripley et al. 2021 ; Loutrel et al. 2021 ; Pazos et al. 2010 ; Sberna et al. 2022 ; Redondo-Yuste et al. 2024a ; Mitman et al. 2023 ; Cheung et al. 2023 ; Ioka and Nakano 2007 ; Kehagias et al. 2023 ; Khera et al. 2023 ; Bucciotti et al. 2023 ; Spiers et al. 2023 ; Ma and Yang 2024 ; Zhu et al. 2024 ; Redondo-Yuste et al. 2024b ; Bourg et al. 2024 ; Lagos et al. 2025 ; Perrone et al. 2024 ; Kehagias and Riotto 2025a ; Bucciotti et al. 2025 ; Bourg et al. 2025 ; Ben Achour and Roussille 2024 ; Kehagias et al. 2025 ; Kehagias and Riotto 2025b ; Kehagias and Riotto 2025c ; Perrone et al. 2025 ; Ianniccari et al. 2025 ; Ma et al. 2025 . These studies have revealed phenomena beyond the scope of linear theory addressing the properties of second-order QNMs and new families of power-law tails. While considerable attention has been given in reproducing analytically the numerical results for the nonlinearities popping out from the coalescence of BH binaries in quasi-circular orbits, basically no consideration has been devoted to the nonlinearities generated by ultra-relativistic head-on collisions of equal-mass, non-spinning BHs with different boosts. This might be understandable as the high-energy head-on collision of two BHs is thought to be a highly nonlinear event, possibly not tractable by a simple second-order approach. In the standard decomposition in Regge–Wheeler and Zerilli perturbation theory, the ringdown GW strain of a Schwarzschild BH can be schematically be written as rh(t,\theta,\phi)=\sum_{\ell mn}A_{\ell mn}e^{i\omega_{\ell mn}(x-t)}{}_{-2}Y_{\ell m}(\theta,\phi), (1) where A_{\ell mn} is the amplitude of the mode (n,\ell,m) , {}_{-2}Y_{\ell m}(\theta) are the spin-weighted spherical harmonics and x=r+2M\ln(r/2M-1) ( M being the mass of the resulting BH), which describe the angular pattern of the wave and are the natural basis used for the extraction of the mode amplitudes Cheung et al. 2023 . In the head-on collision of two BHs the linear 200 mode dominates the ringdown of the nonspinning Schwarzschild remnant Sperhake et al. 2008 and the resulting nonlinear mode 200\times 200 has an amplitude which has been calculated by numerical simulations to be Cheung et al. 2023 A^{\Psi_{4}}_{200\times 200}=(1.700\pm 0.115)(A^{\Psi_{4}}_{200})^{2}, (2) quite independently from the initial conditions, above all the boost factor. Here \Psi_{4} is the Weyl scalar, which is related to the GW strain h asymptotically at large distances by the relation Cheung et al. 2023 r\Psi_{4}=-2r\ddot{h}. (3) Correspondingly, A^{h}_{200\times 200}=\frac{\omega_{200}^{2}}{2}A^{\Psi_{4}}_{200\times 200}=(0.118\pm 0.008)(A^{h}_{200})^{2}, (4) where we have used the value G_{N}M\omega_{200}\simeq 0.3737 for the QNM frequency Berti et al. 2006 . To the best of our knowledge, this numerical result has never been derived analytically. We report here the same ratio for the coalescence of BH binaries in quasi-circular orbits resulting into a spinless Schwarzschild BH Cheung et al. 2023 (see also Refs. Mitman et al. 2023 ; Redondo-Yuste et al. 2024a ) A^{h}_{220\times 220}=(0.1637\pm 0.0018)(A^{h}_{220})^{2}, (5) which, as we shall see, will be useful in the following. The goal of this Letter is simple: to derive the nonlinearity ( 4 ) analytically. We achieve this by some logical and rather simple steps. The first one involves the Close Limit Approximation (CLA), which allows to think of a seemingly untractable highly nonlinear problem as a more standard problem of second-order BH spectroscopy. The second is the independence of the nonlinearity from the initial conditions and spin Redondo-Yuste et al. 2024a . Let us discuss them in turn. Figure 1: Schematic representation of the initial data and the effective potential of a BH. We used the tortoise coordinate x=r+2M\ln(r/2M-1) . The Close limit approximation – The CLA was originally introduced in Ref. Price and Pullin 1994 (see also Ref. Pullin 1997 for further analytical developments). The basic idea is to choose the initial configuration of the two BHs so that they are extremely close, enough to be surrounded by a common apparent horizon. From a technical perspective, this means they effectively constitute a single BH. Since the apparent horizon already surrounds both BHs, the system can be regarded as a perturbed version of a single BH spacetime—such as Schwarzschild or Kerr—with appropriate boundary conditions to account for the deformation. In this CLA, the dynamics of the BH collision is primarily governed by the response of a single BH “ringing down” as it dissipates the distortions caused by the merger. Remarkably, the CLA has shown strong agreement with full numerical relativity simulations, even in cases where the expansion parameter is only marginally small Gleiser et al. 2000 ; Sopuerta et al. 2006 . At first glance, this level of accuracy might seem unexpected, especially considering that the ultra-relativistic head-on collision of two BHs is one of the most nonlinear and complex problems in general relativity. The explanation lies in the nature of the initial data: much of it is concentrated within the peak of the Regge–Wheeler or