Copyright Protection for 3D Molecular Structures with Watermarking
Runwen Hu, Peilin Chen, Keyan Ding, Shiqi Wang · 2025
Read Copyright Protection for 3D Molecular Structures with Watermarking by Runwen Hu, Peilin Chen, Keyan Ding, Shiqi Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17702.txt.
Introduction
Runwen Hu and three co-authors built in 2025 MolMark, the first deep learning system that hides a mark inside 3D molecules to prove who made them. AI tools now design drug candidates, yet nothing stops quiet reuse or settles who came first. MolMark learns to tweak atom-level features so a sixteen-bit code rides inside the structure. Its handling of shape keeps the mark intact when the molecule is turned, shifted or mirrored.
On standard test sets and two leading design tools, the marks survived while over ninety percent of key traits held. Reading the hidden bits back topped ninety-five percent accuracy after such moves. The system plugs into current tools with little change to their output. The authors frame the mark as a path to fair credit in AI discovery. It gives labs a way to sign their work invisibly.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Runwen Hu, Peilin Chen, Keyan Ding, Shiqi Wang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 71 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17702
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Copyright Protection for 3D Molecular Structures with Watermarking Runwen Hu, Peilin Chen, Keyan Ding, Shiqi Wang Abstract Artificial intelligence (AI) revolutionizes molecule generation in bioengineering and biological research, significantly accelerating discovery processes. However, this advancement introduces critical concerns regarding intellectual property protection. To address these challenges, we propose the first robust watermarking method designed for molecules, which utilizes atom-level features to preserve molecular integrity and invariant features to ensure robustness against affine transformations. Comprehensive experiments validate the effectiveness of our method using the datasets QM9 and GEOM-DRUG, and generative models GeoBFN and GeoLDM. We demonstrate the feasibility of embedding watermarks, maintaining basic properties higher than 90.00% while achieving watermark accuracy greater than 95.00%. Furthermore, downstream docking simulations reveal comparable performance between original and watermarked molecules, with binding affinities reaching -6.00 kcal/mol and root mean square deviations below 1.602 Å. These results confirm that our watermarking technique effectively safeguards molecular intellectual property without compromising scientific utility, enabling secure and responsible AI integration in molecular discovery and research applications. Figure 1: Application scenarios and performance of the proposed watermarking method in protecting molecules. a , Preventing unauthorized use. Alice embeds a specific watermark into molecules. Bob misuses them by violating the usage agreement, after which Alice detects the infringement and protects her copyright. b , Tracking data leakage. Alice distributes uniquely embedded molecules to different users. Elaine leaks her copy to unauthorized users, and Alice detects the leakage and successfully traces it back to Elaine. c , Overview of the proposed watermarking method. The encoder \mathcal{E}_{\phi} embeds watermarks into molecules without compromising their properties, and the decoder \mathcal{D}_{\theta} extracts the watermarks from molecules processed by transformations. d , Structure of eight pairs of molecules, in which the original molecule and embedded molecules are arranged vertically. The structure of the molecules only undergoes slight changes after watermark embedding. e , Effectiveness of the embedded molecules in the downstream task (molecule docking). For the original molecules and the embedded molecules, the amino acid residues and hydrogen bond lengths in molecular docking are similar, reflecting that the embedding watermark has an insignificant impact on the effectiveness of molecules. Synthetic molecules are crucial in biological, chemical, and medical research, benefiting scientific discoveries such as protein engineering [ 1 , 2 ] and drug discovery [ 3 , 4 ] . The development of artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly facilitated molecule design, establishing a new paradigm for biomedical and biochemical research [ 5 ] . Recent progress in AI-based generative models has catalyzed substantial advancements in molecule generation. For example, Gebauer et al. [ 6 ] and Luo et al. [ 7 ] proposed to generate 3D molecules by employing the autoregressive model and flow-based model, respectively. The diffusion models have also been widely explored in molecule generation tasks [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] . Moreover, the Bayesian Flow Network [ 11 ] (BFN) is adopted to design unified generation pipelines of molecules [ 12 , 13 ] and proteins [ 14 , 15 ] , alleviating the differences between continuous and discrete data of molecules. These breakthroughs have greatly advanced the field of molecule generation, laying the groundwork for downstream applications and further research. Although AI-driven technologies have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in generating molecular structures with diverse properties that promote the development of cutting-edge technologies like environmentally friendly chemicals [ 5 , 16 ] and materials [ 17 , 18 ] , these advancements also introduce significant challenges related to copyright and security, as the generated molecules fall outside the comprehensive regulatory frameworks. For example, unauthorized users potentially claim ownership of the generated molecules, which infringes on the copyright of the creators. Such misuse can lead to the proliferation of pirated molecular resources, exposing critical vulnerabilities in the protection of scientific innovation. Similar issues have emerged in the text and image generation models, where tools like ChatGPT can be used for academic dishonesty [ 19 ] , diffusion models [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] for creating fake images [ 23 , 24 ] , and video generative models [ 25 ] for producing forged videos. These malicious activities pose serious security concerns and societal instability. In the context of molecule generation, the potential biopharmaceutical safety risks require strict regulation. As such, developing methods for embedding watermarking in molecules offers a promising pathway to safeguard intellectual property, prevent unauthorized replication, and ensure the trustworthy deployment of AI-generated molecular innovations [ 26 ] . However, protecting molecules is an emerging research topic in the field of information hiding. While copyright protection has been explored for traditional multimedia [ 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] and generated proteins [ 32 , 33 ] , no dedicated methods have been developed for protecting molecules. The challenge of protecting molecules lies in the complexity of the task. Existing watermarking methods face compatibility problems when applied to molecules that are characterized by delicate and highly constrained architectures. Firstly, the finite number of atoms in a molecule imposes strict limitations on the available space for embedding watermarks. Secondly, molecular structures are highly sensitive to perturbations, and a slight change can disrupt atomic distances that break chemical bonds and render the molecules ineffective. Thirdly, watermarking methods must exhibit robustness to affine transformations ( e.g., rotation, scaling, translation), as molecules retain their basic properties under such operations; however, most existing approaches remain vulnerable. These challenges highlight the pressing need for a robust watermarking framework specifically designed for molecular structures. In this study, we propose the first AI-driven watermarking method designed specifically to safeguard the intellectual property of molecules. Initially, the encoder embeds the watermark into the structures of molecules, in which the node features are utilized to assist the embedding and maintain the molecular properties. Subsequently, the decoder extracts the watermark from the embedded molecules, providing copyright protection for molecules. To achieve robustness against affine transformations, we extract the invariant features for watermark embedding and extraction, after which the multidimensional scaling (MDS) strategy is utilized to solve the problem of numerical instability. During the training, we propose a dynamically balanced training strategy to optimize the proposed watermarking method, achieving the goal of copyright protection while maintaining the properties of molecules. We comprehensively evaluate the proposed method through key performance analyses. Preservation of molecular properties: embedding a 16-bit watermark results in only a slight decrease in atom stability (99.72% → 97.69%) and molecule stability (95.00% → 94.60%), ensuring their suitability for subsequent scientific research. Docking performance: the embedded molecules retain strong binding ability, with the best binding affinity changing minimally (-6.25 kcal/mol → -6.00 kcal/mol) and RMSD changing from 1.585 Å to 1.602 Å. Robustness to transformations: under affine transformations, the bit accuracies consistently exceed 95.00%. These results mark a significant step forward in molecular watermarking, offering a robust and reliable solution for safeguarding molecular intellectual property. 1 Results To evaluate the performance of the proposed watermarking method, we utilize two benchmark datasets in molecular machine learning for comparison. The QM9 dataset [ 34 ] comprises approximately 134,000 molecules, each containing up to 29 atoms including hydrogens. The GEOM-DRUG dataset [ 35 ] includes 37 million conformations across roughly 450,000 drug-like molecules, offering a broader and more complex