On the analysis of eruptive events with non-radial evolution

Abril Sahade, M. Valeria Sieyra, Mariana Cécere · 2025

Read On the analysis of eruptive events with non-radial evolution by Abril Sahade, M. Valeria Sieyra, Mariana Cécere (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17583.txt.

Introduction

Abril Sahade, M. Valeria Sieyra, and Mariana A. Cecere compare tools for tracking solar eruptions that veer off the radial path in 2025. Big eruptions from the Sun drive space weather at Earth. Their sideways drift shapes how hard they hit. Nearby magnetic fields steer that drift, yet forecasting it is hard. The team revisits a strongly bent eruption from 2010.

An improved tracking frame and a topology based path method were applied. Both point to field line channeling as the main guide. The path method matched the event well. The authors pitch it as a diagnostic for strong drift cases. Better early direction calls could sharpen space weather alerts. The study also tests how the tools agree.

Catalog record

CREATORAbril Sahade, M. Valeria Sieyra, Mariana Cécere
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17583

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the analysis of eruptive events with non-radial evolution Abril Sahade, M. Valeria Sieyra, Mariana Cécere Abstract Coronal mass ejections (CMEs) are major drivers of space weather disturbances, and their deflection from the radial direction critically affects their potential impact on Earth. While the influence of the surrounding magnetic field in guiding CME trajectories is well established, accurately predicting non-radial propagation remains a challenge. In this work, we introduce and compare recently developed techniques for analyzing the early deflection of eruptive events. We revisit a largely deflected prominence-CME event of 2010 December 16 using an improved tracking framework and a new application of the topological path method. Our results suggest the deflection of the eruption is dominated by the channeling of the magnetic field lines. This study offers new physical insight into CME guidance mechanisms and validates the predictive capability of the topological path, highlighting its potential as a diagnostic tool for estimating the propagation direction of strongly deflected events. keywords Sun: coronal mass ejections (CMEs), Sun: prominences, Sun: magnetic fields 1 Introduction Solar eruptions are energetic explosive events that inject plasma and magnetic fields into the interplanetary medium. They are typically observed in the lower corona as solar flares and/or prominence eruptions, and later in white-light images of the upper corona as coronal mass ejections (CMEs). When directed toward Earth, CMEs can trigger severe geomagnetic storms capable of disrupting global communication and navigation systems, damaging satellites, and causing large-scale power grid failures. As the number of missions operating throughout the heliosphere continues to grow, accurately predicting the evolution of CMEs in the interplanetary medium has become more critical than ever. A key factor in determining whether an eruptive event will impact Earth or a spacecraft is its direction of propagation. Recent statistical studies have shown that CMEs frequently exhibit some degree of deflection from their source region, rather than propagating strictly radially ( Majumdar et al 2020 ; Majumdar et al 2023 , see e.g.,) . These deflections can be significant ( Isavnin et al 2014 ; Sieyra et al 2020 , e.g.,) , sometimes resulting in false space weather alerts (see e.g., Möstl et al 2015 ; Mays et al 2015 , for an analysis of the 2014 January 7 event) . It is well established that the magnetic fields surrounding the source region play a critical role in governing CME deflection. This influence has been extensively studied through both observational ( Kilpua et al 2009 ; Kay et al 2017 ; Cécere et al 2020 ; Sahade et al 2023 , e.g.,) and numerical ( Sahade et al 2020 ; Sahade et al 2021 ; Sahade et al 2022 ; Ben-Nun et al 2023 , e.g.,) approaches. A recent review by Cécere et al 2023 summarizes the current understanding of the key factors contributing to early-stage CME deflections. Building on numerical simulations of magnetic flux rope (MFR) deflections in various magnetic environments, and comparisons with observational case studies ( Sahade 2023 ) , a new method has been proposed to estimate CME deflections ( Sahade et al 2025 ) . This method introduces the ‘topological path,’ defined as a curve connecting the apexes of closed and open magnetic field lines above the source region. This path approximates the expected CME trajectory, assuming it is guided (“channeled”) by the surrounding magnetic field. The study also defines the ‘gradient path,’ which follows the direction of minimal magnetic energy from the source region, estimating the deflections driven by the magnetic energy gradient. Sahade et al 2025 applied these methods to eight prominence-CME events, demonstrating that the topological path provides a promising tool for estimating propagation direction in both radially directed and strongly deflected events. A key advantage of these methods is that they rely only on the location of the source region and the overlying magnetic field, making them suitable for forecasting purposes. The present study introduces an improved framework to quantify the role and mechanism of the ambient magnetic field in guiding CME trajectories. We revisit an event previously analyzed by Sieyra et al 2020 , using newly developed tracking tools ( Sahade et al 2023 ; Sahade et al 2025 ) . This prominence-CME event was simultaneously observed from multiple vantage points of view and exhibited a large deflection ( >20^{\circ} ) during its early evolution. The CME propagated toward the heliospheric current sheet (HCS) showing alignment with the gradient of the magnetic energy. This event provides an ideal test case for evaluating the diagnostic potential of the gradient and topological path concepts. Crucially, we show that although the CME trajectory aligns with the magnetic energy gradient, the physical mechanism driving the early deflection is more likely governed by the magnetic field topology. Our work offers a new perspective on CME guidance mechanisms and contributes to improving predictive models for space weather forecasting. In Section 2 , we describe the enhanced tracking techniques and introduce the refined analysis of magnetic paths that support this interpretation. Results and conclusions are presented in Sections 3 and 4 , respectively. 2 Methodology 2.1 Data and tracking From the events analyzed by Sieyra et al 2020 , we selected the 2010 December 16 event due to its excellent observational coverage throughout its evolution, which allowed us to track the eruption up to approximately 8\,R_{\odot} from multiple viewpoints. The erupting prominence-CME was observed simultaneously from Earth by the Solar Dynamics Observatory ( Pesnell et al 2012 , SDO;) and the Large Angle and Spectrometric Coronagraph Experiment ( Brueckner et al 1995 , LASCO;) , as well as by the twin spacecraft of the Solar TErrestrial RElations Observatory ( Kaiser et al 2008 , STEREO;) —STEREO-Ahead (STA) and STEREO-Behind (STB)— which were positioned near quadrature during this period. In addition, the location of the source region enabled the use of high-quality photospheric magnetograms from the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager ( Scherrer et al 2012 , HMI;) . These updated magnetograms provide more reliable boundary conditions for reconstructing the ambient magnetic field surrounding the source region. To model the global structure of the coronal field, we employed the Potential Field Source Surface (PFSS) model ( Schrijver and De Rosa 2003 ) , which estimates the magnetic field configuration up to 2.5,R_{\odot} . Figure 1: Upper panel: Running difference of the white-light images from STA, LASCO and STB perspectives of the 2010 December 16 CME at 10:36 UT. Middle panel: GCS wireframe (green lines) projected over the coronograph images showed in upper panel. Lower panel: non-radial GCS wireframe (cyan lines) projected on STA, LASCO and STB FOV. To characterize the evolution of the prominence material, we use the tie-pointing (TP) reconstruction technique ( Inhester 2006 ; Mierla et al 2008 ; Mierla et al 2009 , see e.g.,) applied to EUV images from SDO/AIA and wavelet-enhanced images ( Stenborg et al 2008 ) from the Extreme-Ultraviolet Imager ( Howard et al 2008 , STEREO/EUVI;) . TP is a stereoscopic method that determines the three-dimensional position of an object (in this case, a plasma parcel) based on its projection in a pair of images. The key challenge lies in identifying the same feature in both images, i.e. matching a feature in image 1 and its corresponding projection

Read the complete text