Humanizing Machines: Rethinking LLM Anthropomorphism Through a Multi-Level Framework of Design

Yunze Xiao, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng, Jiarui Liu, Mona DiabCarnegie Mellon University {yunzex,huixiann,jiaruil5,mdiab}@andrew.cmu.edu · 2025

Read Humanizing Machines: Rethinking LLM Anthropomorphism Through a Multi-Level Framework of Design by Yunze Xiao, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng, Jiarui Liu, Mona DiabCarnegie Mellon University {yunzex,huixiann,jiaruil5,mdiab}@andrew.cmu.edu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17573.txt.

Introduction

Yunze Xiao, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng, Jiarui Liu, and Mona Diab say that to make language models seem like men and women is a design pick. The work came out in 2025. It should be seen as a knob that can be tuned, not just a risk. Models show more and more traits like ours in view, speech, acts, and thought. That makes chats feel smooth and plain. It also calls up too much trust and false shows.

Past work lists those risks for the most part. It gives scant help with design picks. The team sets out a tiered frame drawn from more than one field. In it, the human-like feel of a model grows from cues that staff build in. It grows from the sense that users make of those cues too. Design and sense meet at each tier of the good, from face words to seeming thought.

Catalog record

CREATORYunze Xiao, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng, Jiarui Liu, Mona DiabCarnegie Mellon University {yunzex,huixiann,jiaruil5,mdiab}@andrew.cmu.edu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE51 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17573

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Humanizing Machines: Rethinking LLM Anthropomorphism Through a Multi-Level Framework of Design Yunze Xiao, Lynnette Hui Xian Ng, Jiarui Liu, Mona DiabCarnegie Mellon University {yunzex,huixiann,jiaruil5,mdiab}@andrew.cmu.edu Abstract Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly exhibit anthropomorphism characteristics – human-like qualities portrayed across their outlook, language, behavior, and reasoning functions. Such characteristics enable more intuitive and engaging human-AI interactions. However, current research on anthropomorphism remains predominantly risk-focused, emphasizing over-trust and user deception while offering limited design guidance. We argue that anthropomorphism should instead be treated as a concept of design that can be intentionally tuned to support user goals. Drawing from multiple disciplines, we propose that the anthropomorphism of an LLM-based artifact should reflect the interaction between artifact designers and interpreters. This interaction is facilitated by cues embedded in the artifact by the designers and the (cognitive) responses of the interpreters to the cues. Cues are categorized into four dimensions: perceptive, linguistic, behavioral , and cognitive . By analyzing the manifestation and effectiveness of each cue, we provide a unified taxonomy with actionable levers for practitioners. Consequently, we advocate for function-oriented evaluations of anthropomorphic design. 1 Introduction Anthropomorphism is a purposeful design strategy that unlocks richer, more intuitive collaboration between humans and Artificial Intelligent (AI) systems. Developers equip large language models (LLMs) with relatable personalities Wang et al. 2024c ; tse Huang et al. 2024b , emotional expressiveness Huang et al. 2024a , and context-sensitive social reasoning Nighojkar et al. 2025 . These human-like cues allow users to converse with a system in familiar terms. This design principle builds user trust by reducing the cognitive effort required to interact with the system. Multi-modal extensions amplify this effect and create seamless and engaging interactions: speech synthesis models convey nuanced emotion Zhou et al. 2022 , embodied agents navigate physical space Xie et al. 2025 , and vision-based models interpret social scenes Mathur et al. 2025 . These human-like agents have shown tangible benefits to our society: providing realistic training environments for education Ma et al. 2024 , improving adherence and empathy for virtual healthcare consultations Wen et al. 2024 , strengthening therapeutic alliances in psychiatry Wang et al. 2024a , or making legal reasoning tools accessible to non - experts Huang et al. 2023 . In each scenario, carefully calibrated anthropomorphic cues bridge complex AI capabilities and human goals, enabling technology that feels / appears to be supportive, transparent, and responsive. However, current work on anthropomorphism in LLM design is framed predominantly through a risk-centric lens. This lens emphasizes user misconceptions about model capabilities Tejeda et al. 2025 , misplaced trust in dialog systems Zhou et al. 2025 , and the danger of over-reliance on emotions Akbulut et al. 2024 . This context has cultivated a cautious and often skeptical stance towards anthropomorphism within the community, often citing incidents where users disclosed personal financial information to chatbots they perceived as trustworthy humans Mireshghallah et al. 2024 , or cases where AI assistants reinforced harmful stereotypes through personality-driven responses Liu et al. 2024a . While these concerns are legitimate, recent research on anthropomorphism has been largely shaped by its perceived harms and discouraged a deeper exploration of its functional or context-sensitive benefits Olteanu et al. 2025 . This dominant discourse leaves little room for feature-driven inquiry into when, how, and for whom anthropomorphic elements might enhance usability, trust calibration, or engagement in NLP applications. Figure 1: Illustrative definition of Anthropomorphism To address this gap, we propose a new definition of anthropomorphism which is grounded in how today’s LLM-centered systems occupy the liminal space between utilitarian tools and social actors and moves beyond the defensive, risk-centric paradigm. Instead of treating anthropomorphism solely as a linguistic attribution of human-like characteristics to non-human entities Cheng et al. 2025 ; Cheng et al. 2024 ; DeVrio et al. 2025a , we contend that anthropomorphism should be treated as a multidimensional reciprocal interaction process. Designers intentionally embed human-like cues into AI systems. Interpreters are users who, in turn, project their agency and mental states onto this system. This multimodal reconceptualization of anthropomorphism expands the research agenda, enabling scholars to systematically investigate the scenarios in which anthropomorphic design cues are beneficial. This conceptualization is critical because LLMs increasingly mediate experiences across sensitive and subjective domains, in which the trust and engagement of interpreters profoundly shape outcomes. The nuanced understanding of anthropomorphism is based on the interaction between user and model and focuses on the effectiveness of system design. This approach reduces mis-characterizations of system effects through over-reliance of cautionary narratives, and the deployment of human-like systems without adequate design foresight. Our definition thus provides a coherent frame for auditing human-imitative AI across varied modalities, bringing a new perspective to harness anthropomorphism responsibly and effectively. Our contribution is threefold: 1. We propose a new definition of anthropomorphism for today’s NLP systems. LLMs are more than just tools; they are also social partners. The usage of LLMs depends on how designers build them and how interpreters respond and interact; 2. We advocate for a shift from the prevailing risk-centric evaluations of anthropomorphism towards an effectiveness-focused approach. We analyze existing studies for actionable insights into anthropomorphic design decisions; 3. We present a feature-driven design framework based on the reactions of interpreters to human-like features built into LLM systems by designers. 2 What is Anthropomorphism? Anthropomorphism has long been a fundamental phenomenon in the study of human–machine interaction. As early as 1950, Turing’s Imitation Game Turing 1950 framed the ability of machines to mimic human behavior as a measure of intelligence. In 1966, Weizenbaum introduced the "ELIZA effect", in which simple linguistic cues can elicit deep emotional responses from interpreters Weizenbaum 1966 . In 1970, the Japanese roboticist Mori introduced the concept of the Uncanny Valley and showed that increasing the realism of robots can cause unease to human interpreters when the artificial agents do not completely resemble humans Mori et al. 2012 . Adjacent fields to NLP such as Human-Computer Interaction and Information Sciences have developed rich accounts of anthropomorphism as a socio-technical phenomenon shaped by design intentions, interpreter expectations, and context Frazer 2022 ; Damholdt et al. 2023 . These well-established traditions provide guidance towards a context-aware understanding of anthropomorphism, one that can inform both the design and the evaluation of human-like language technologies. Contemporary NLP debates often treat anthropomorphism either as a narrow linguistic phenomenon or as a hazard requiring mitigation, frequently foregrounding the risks of over-trust, deception, or disinformation while sidelining potential design benefits. Much of the literature has emphasized preventing misleading cues or curbing anthropomorphic projections Peter et al. 2025 To restore this missing depth and anchor our multi-level framework in conceptual rigor, we first synthesize peer-reviewed definitions of anthropomorphism drawn from Robotics, Human-AI Interaction (HAI), and Natural Language Processing (NLP). This synthesis is not merely classificatory; it underpins our argument that anthropomorphism should be understood as a context-sensitive interaction between designers, systems, and interpreters rather than as a fixed set of traits. The NLP field currently lacks a comparable design-oriented taxonomy for anthropomorphism. Current frames of anthropomorphism are heavily risk-oriented, elaborating on trust and safety issues that may arise with heavily anthropomorphic systems. Our literature synthesis in Section A serves as an implicit comparative analysis, demonstrating how our framework integrates and

Read the complete text