Knot exteriors with all compact surfaces of positive genus essentially embedded

João M. Nogueira · 2025

Read Knot exteriors with all compact surfaces of positive genus essentially embedded by João M. Nogueira (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17504.txt.

Introduction

João Nogueira constructs knots whose surrounding space is rich in hidden surfaces in a 2025 paper. A knot exterior is the space left when a thickened knot is cut out of the three-dimensional sphere. Surfaces inside can be essential, meaning they cannot be squashed away without tearing. Seifert surfaces of huge genus were already known to exist for some knots.

Nogueira proves infinitely many knot exteriors where surfaces of every positive genus appear as longitudinal essential surfaces. Any number of boundary loops is allowed as well. The result is an existence theorem in low-dimensional topology, showing how complicated the inner landscape of a knot's complement can be. It gives surface hunters a guarantee before they start looking.

Catalog record

CREATORJoão M. Nogueira
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17504

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Knot exteriors with all compact surfaces of positive genus essentially embedded Thanks: This work was partially supported by the Centre for Mathematics of the University of Coimbra - UIDB/00324/2020, funded by the Portuguese Government through FCT/MCTES. This work was also partially supported by the UT Austin — Portugal Colab. João M. Nogueira Abstract . It is well known that there exist knots with Seifert surfaces of arbitrarily high genus. In this paper, we show the existence of infinitely many knot exteriors where each of which has longitudinal essential surfaces of any positive genus and any number of boundary components. 1. Introduction Essential surfaces have played an important role in understanding 3-manifold topology since the second half of the last century. One particularly interesting property is the existence of essential surfaces of arbitrarily large Euler characteristics in some 3-manifolds. For knot exteriors in particular, it is well known since the work of Lyon [ 10 ] that a knot exterior can have closed essential surfaces and also Seifert surfaces of arbitrarily high genus. Many more examples of knot exteriors with these properties have been published throughout the years. For instance, besides the result of Lyon, several other collections of knots have been given for which there are Seifert surfaces of arbitrarily high genus as in work of Parris [ 17 ] (see also [ 22 ] ), Gustafson [ 7 ] , Ozawa and Tsutsumi [ 19 ] or Tsutsumi [ 20 ] . We will further show that a knot exterior can have a collection of longitudinal essential surfaces with arbitrarily large Euler characteristics not only due to large genus, as a collection of Seifert surfaces can have, but also from the number of boundary components. In fact, the collection of longitudinal essential surfaces can be with every number of boundary components and all positive genus. Theorem 1 . There are infinitely many knots in the 3-sphere, each of which has in its exterior a longitudinal essential surface of any positive genus and any number of boundary components. With respect to surfaces of genus zero, we know from the work of Gabai [ 6 ] when proving the Property R and the Poenaru conjectures, also related to the Cabling conjecture, that there are no longitudinal essential planar surfaces in knot exteriors besides the disk bounded by the unknot. However, it is known by work of Hatcher and Thurston, Proposition 1(3) of [ 8 ] , that there exists a collection of (non-meridional) essential surfaces with an arbitrarily large number of boundary components in some 2-bridge knot exteriors. As it is not clear in Proposition 1(3) of [ 8 ] whether the surfaces are orientable, the number of boundary components for orientable surfaces can only be claimed to be even, by taking the boundary of a regular neighborhood of a non-orientable surface if that is the case. Also, as it is well known, composite knots do not have genus one Seifert surfaces, and the boundary slope of a Seifert surface in the knot exterior is 0 (longitudinal). Hence we cannot have a statement as in this theorem for composite knots or for a different boundary slope. This theorem contrasts with other results in the literature. For instance, Wilson [ 22 ] proved that a small knot in S^{3} , i.e. without closed essential surfaces in its complement, cannot have an infinite number of Seifert surfaces. From work of Oertel in [ 16 ] , on a theorem of Jaco and Sedgwick, it is finite the number of compact essential surfaces of uniformly bounded genus (closed or with boundary) in knot exteriors without essential genus one surfaces (closed or with boundary). In [ 3 ] , in work related to the Kervaire conjecture, Eudave-Muñoz proved that any odd number can be realized as the number of boundary components of an essential orientable connected surface properly embedded in a knot exterior. However, not necessarily in the same knot exterior and the genus is not arbitrarily large for the same number of boundary components. Besides closed or longitudinal boundary slope, a similar result exists for meridional surfaces in knot exteriors. In fact, in [ 11 ] the author proved a prime knot exterior can have a collection of meridional essential surfaces with two boundary components and any positive genus. However, a collection of essential surfaces in a knot exterior can be of arbitrarily large Euler characteristics not only because of large genus but also from the number of boundary components. This was shown first by the author in [ 12 ] with a collection of essential planar surfaces with arbitrarily large number of boundary components, and, even further, in [ 13 ] and in [ 14 ] with a collection of essential surfaces with independently large genus and number of boundary components in a satellite knot exterior and hyperbolic knot exterior, respectively. The paper is organized as follows: In section 2 we define a class of satellite knots that we will use throughout the paper. In sections 3 and 4 we construct branched surfaces and use branched surface theory to prove that the surfaces they carry as in the statement of Theorem 1 are essential in the corresponding knot exterior. In section 5 , we extend Theorem 1 by showing that there are knot exteriors which have a collection of many disjoint non-parallel longitudinal surfaces of each topological class of compact surface. Throughout this paper all manifolds are orientable, all submanifolds are assumed to be in general position and we work in the smooth category. 2. Square double of a knot In this section, we will construct a branched surface in the square double exteriors of composite knots, which we use in the proof of Theorem 1 . First we consider the 2-string tangle T_{1}=(B_{1};s_{1}\cup s_{2}) as in Figure 1 (a) which we refer to as the square tangle, following nomenclature in the literature [ 18 ] . \labellist \hair 2pt \pinlabel T_{1} at 80 105 \pinlabel T_{2} at 288 105 \pinlabel (a) at 80 -10 \pinlabel (b) at 288 -10 \endlabellist Figure 1 . : In (a) we have a diagram of the square tangle, denoted T_{1} ; in (b) we have represented a tangle of two twisted parallel arcs following the pattern of a knot J , denoted T_{2} . Let T^{\prime}_{2} denote the n/1 rational tangle, where n is an integer, with T^{\prime}_{2}=(B_{2};p_{1}\cup p_{2}) . The arcs p_{1} and p_{2} co-bound a disk D in B_{2} with two arcs in \partial B_{2} , say a_{1} and a_{2} . Consider the operation on T^{\prime}_{2} where we assume the core of a regular neighborhood of D in B_{2} follows the pattern of a knot J . Hence, the image of the arcs p_{i},\,i=1,2 , in B_{2} , follow this pattern. That is, through the closure of p_{i} with an arc in \partial B_{2} we obtain the knot J . We denote the resulting tangle as T_{2}(n;J) , or only as T_{2} , and we assume that the arcs a_{i} , of \partial D\cap\partial B_{2} , are in the boundary circle of the diagram disk of T_{2} . (See Figure 1 (b)). Definition 1 . For each integer n , consider now the knot

Read the complete text