A bi-effect model of muon deflections in air showers
Si-Zhe Wu, Chao Zhang, Ruo-Yu Liu, Xi-Shui Tian, Zhuo Li · 2025
Read A bi-effect model of muon deflections in air showers by Si-Zhe Wu, Chao Zhang, Ruo-Yu Liu, Xi-Shui Tian, Zhuo Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17475.txt.
Introduction
Si-Zhe Wu and four co-authors modeled in 2025 how Earth's magnetic field bends the paths of muons in cosmic ray air showers. Tilted showers spread particles across the ground, and readings had hinted the field matters more than expected. The team combined magnetic bending with air-density effects into one two-part model.
A simple formula then matches the bending seen in full simulations. Model settings link back to the incoming particle's traits and to the observatory's site. Better bending math sharpens how ground arrays rebuild each shower's origin and how detectors should be laid out.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Si-Zhe Wu, Chao Zhang, Ruo-Yu Liu, Xi-Shui Tian, Zhuo Li |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17475
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A bi-effect model of muon deflections in air showers Preprint: APS/123-QED Si-Zhe Wu, Chao Zhang, Ruo-Yu Liu, Xi-Shui Tian, Zhuo Li Abstract Recent progress has shown that the geomagnetic field exerts a more significant impact than expected on the behavior of charged secondary particles in inclined air showers. In this study, we for the first time combine it with atmospheric effects to construct a bi-effect model, aiming to investigate the lateral distribution of particles on the ground plane. Despite the complex physical interactions during the development of air showers, a simple formula can describe the overall deflection of μ ± \mu^{\pm} and accurately fit the deflection in simulated air showers, thereby validating the hypotheses about these effects in this study. Furthermore, we have obtained the relationship between model parameters and primary particle information for different experimental sites. This new model is highly successful and is promising to provide new insights for improving detector layout design and air shower reconstruction. I Introduction Cosmic rays (CRs) are high-energy particles originating from outer space. They serve as probes to study extreme environments in astrophysics and particle physics at energies beyond those achievable by human-made colliders. Many important questions are expected to be answered through the study of cosmic rays. In particular, the origin and nature of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) remain mysterious Bhattacharjee and Sigl 2000 ; Alves Batista et al. 2019 . Extensive air showers — massive cascades of secondary particles — are triggered when cosmic rays collide with atomic nuclei in the atmosphere and can be observed via large detector arrays. Observatories such as the Pierre Auger Observatory, LHAASO, and TA are working to collect data, and several hypotheses are being tested to provide reasonable explanations Aab et al. 2017 ; Addazi et al. 2022 ; Abu-Zayyad et al. 2013 ; Aab et al. 2016 . The secondary particles of air showers consist of a rich mixture of hadrons, electromagnetic particles, muons, and neutrinos. These particles propagate through Earth’s atmosphere during the development of air showers. Among them, the electromagnetic components ( e^{\pm},\gamma ) and muons ( \mu^{\pm} ) play a crucial role in detection. Although electromagnetic particles carry most of the energy deposited in the atmosphere, they undergo more intense interactions and are thus more absorbed. Especially, in inclined air showers, electromagnetic particles are much harder to reach the ground compared to vertical air showers. Muons are produced from the decay of charged pions. They interact weakly with atomic nuclei in the atmosphere and can persist until the final stage of air shower development. As a result, they have low energy loss and a long lifetime, enabling them to penetrate the atmosphere and reach the ground, underground, or deep water. The technology for detecting muons is quite mature; their distribution and energy spectrum can be accurately measured using surface detectors, making muon detection an important method for cosmic ray research Aab et al. 2021a . On one hand, muon detection can serve as a probe to study hadronic interactions in air showers, distinguish between heavy and light primary nuclei, and reconstruct the energy of cosmic rays. On the other hand, many muon-related challenges remain unsolved, such as the model-data discrepancy in muon number measurements — the so-called “muon puzzle” Pierog 2018 ; Pierog and Werner 2025 ; the precise determination of mass composition using muon data Knurenko and Petrov 2020 ; Mayotte 2025 ; and the separation of muon signals from electromagnetic particles in detectors Aab et al. 2021b . Additionally, muon flux is significantly influenced by environmental factors such as detector altitude and solar modulation Bae and Chatzidakis 2022a . In previous studies, atmospheric effects have been considered to investigate particle distributions. A universality model has been established to accurately describe the longitudinal, lateral, and temporal distributions of particles, which could be applied to study mass composition Stadelmaier et al. 2024 . This model has been applied to real experimental data Stadelmaier 2025 . However, most previous studies are limited to zenith angles not exceeding 60 ∘ . Recent progress in radio emission mechanisms suggests a new radiation effect induced by the movement of charged particles in a relatively high geomagnetic field strength within inclined air showers Chiche et al. 2024 , indicating that the charged secondary particles should also be more influenced by the magnetic field than expected. However, this effect has not been investigated in air shower detection, except for the balloon-based EUSO-SPB2 Mission Fuehne and Heibges 2023 . This paper aims to study the behaviors of muons reaching ground level by combining atmospheric and geomagnetic effects. Additionally, to make this model generic, both vertical and inclined air showers have been taken into consideration. To simplify the analysis, the averaged coordinates of muons on the ground plane are used to represent the muons’ behaviors. II The bi-effect model Coordinate system — This study employs the Cartesian coordinate system defined in CORSIKA Heck and the others 1998 , where the origin is set to the intersection point of the air shower axis with the ground plane. The x -axis points to the magnetic north, the y -axis to the west, and the z -axis upward. A schematic diagram is shown in FIG. 1 . By counting the deflection of each particle on the ground, the overall deflections of particle number and energy are defined respectively as follows: \begin{matrix}\Delta{\vec{r}_{N}}=\frac{\sum_{i}\Delta{\vec{r}_{i}}}{n}&,&\Delta{\vec{r}_{E}}=\frac{\sum_{i}E_{i}\Delta{\vec{r}_{i}}}{\sum_{i}E_{i}}\end{matrix} (1) where \Delta{\vec{r}} denotes the distance to the origin, E_{i} denotes the energy of each particle. Figure 1: Coordinate system. The point where the shower axis intersects the observation plane is defined as the origin O . \vec{e_{p}} represents the unit vector in the cosmic ray direction. The unit vectors ( \vec{b} , \vec{a} , \vec{n} ) and ( \vec{c} , \vec{b} , \vec{e_{p}} ) form right-handed coordinate systems for the ground plane and shower plane, respectively. Model hypotheses — The energy loss of muons is proportional to the amount of matter they encounter in the atmosphere. The energy loss rate of muons due to ionization is relatively constant at 2 MeV/ g\cdot cm^{-2} Barazandeh et al. 2016 . Meanwhile, as charged particles, muons have their trajectories deflected by the Lorentz force in the geomagnetic field. In particular, muons in inclined air showers propagate for a longer time than those in vertical air showers. When both the deflection caused by the magnetic field and atmospheric absorption are taken into account, two core hypotheses can be used to construct the physical model: 1. Independence Hypothesis: We assume that the magnetic deflection ( \Delta\vec{r}_{mag} ) caused by the Lorentz force and the atmospheric absorption-induced displacement ( \Delta{\vec{r}_{atm}} ) are independent. This relationship is expressed as: \Delta{\vec{r}}=\Delta{\vec{r}_{mag}}+\Delta{\vec{r}_{atm}} . 2. Magnetic Linearity Hypothesis: Charged particles undergo Larmor motion in the geomagnetic field. When the change in the direction of particle motion is minimal, we approximate the direction of the Lorentz force as constant; under this condition, Larmor motion is approximated as projectile motion. The deflection of muons in the shower plane \Delta{\vec{l}} is proportional to the Lorentz force, which is expressed as: \Delta{\vec{l}_{mag}}=c_{mag}\ \vec{e}_{p}\times\vec{B} where \vec{B} denotes the magnetic field at the observation site, and the parameter c_{mag} is a constant independent of both the azimuth angle of the primary particle and the magnetic