Are the Circular Polarizations of Observed Gravitational-Waves Even-Handed?
Elena Emtsova, Ofek Birnholtz · 2025
Read Are the Circular Polarizations of Observed Gravitational-Waves Even-Handed? by Elena Emtsova, Ofek Birnholtz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-17103.txt.
Introduction
Elena Emtsova and Ofek Birnholtz present a 2025 paper that asks whether gravitational waves favor one twist over the other. Waves from merging black holes can spiral in a right-handed or left-handed way. A lasting imbalance between the two would challenge a basic symmetry of gravity, so the test matters.
Using public data from the three-detector network, the pair picked fifteen mergers whose sky spots were pinned down well. Seven leaned right-handed and eight leaned left-handed, a split well within chance. Their math check found no strong sign of imbalance. Hundreds to thousands more events would be needed to spot a small tilt, which future runs may supply.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elena Emtsova, Ofek Birnholtz |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-17103
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Are the Circular Polarizations of Observed Gravitational-Waves Even-Handed? Elena Emtsova, Ofek Birnholtz Abstract We study whether gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black hole (BBH) mergers show a difference between right- and left-handed circular polarizations. Such a difference could point to a violation of parity symmetry in gravity. We analyze publicly available data from the collaboration of the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) detectors, focusing on events with accurate sky localization using all three detectors. This allows us to separate the circular polarization modes and measure their amplitudes. Out of 15 well-localized events, 7 show a dominant right-handed mode and 8 a left-handed one. This small difference is consistent with statistical fluctuations. A Bayesian analysis shows that the probability p R p_{R} of a right-handed signal follows a Beta(8,9) distribution, with no strong evidence for asymmetry. We also estimate how many future events would be needed to detect a small asymmetry like p R = 7 / 15 p_{R}=7/15 with high confidence. To reach 2 σ \sigma or 3 σ \sigma significance, about 900 to 2000 well-localized events would be required. These numbers could be reached in upcoming observation runs. Our results support parity symmetry for now, but future data may allow us to test it more precisely. I Introduction The observations of gravitational waves (GWs) LIGO2016 ; LIGOScientific:2016vbw ; LIGOScientific:2016sjg ; O1:BBH ; GWTC1 ; GWTC2 ; GWTC3 by the network of gravitational wave detectors IGWN LIGO aLIGO , Virgo VIRGO and KAGRA KAGRA ; KAGRA2 - collectively LVK - now allow for the first time to search for possible circular polarization symmetry breaking in General Relativity, hinting at deviations from it or corrections to it. The concept of symmetry breaking plays a pivotal role in many areas of physics, from the weak interactions in the Standard Model to cosmological models explaining matter-antimatter asymmetry. In the Standard Model, weak interactions violate parity symmetry, meaning they distinguish between left- and right-handed chiral states. This was first discovered in 1956 by Chien-Shiung Wu’s experiment, which demonstrated that beta decay is asymmetric under mirror reflection Wu1957 . A gravitational analogue of the Wu experiment—where the sign of the net circular polarization (Stokes V) is tied to the projection of the recoil (kick) onto the final spin—has been formulated explicitly Ng:2023jjt ; Leong:2025raf ; CalderonBustillo:2024akj for related propagation-based parity tests. Similar symmetry-breaking mechanisms might manifest in gravitational interactions, particularly through parity-violating extensions to General Relativity, such as Chern-Simons gravity Alexander2009 or ghost-free massive gravity deRham2010 . Recent studies have explored various aspects of gravitational wave (GW) data analysis and waveform modeling. The LVK collaboration has provided comprehensive catalogs of GW events, offering posterior samples and parameter estimations for numerous binary mergers O1:BBH ; GWTC1 ; GWTC2 ; GWTC3 . These datasets have been instrumental in advancing our understanding of compact binary coalescences. A growing body of work has explored possible deviations from General Relativity through polarization and anisotropy studies of gravitational waves. Several studies have tested the isotropy of gravitational-wave sources and their properties: Isi:2023dlk examined spatial distribution and angular momentum alignment of binary black holes using dipolar models and found consistency with isotropy in O3 data, while Vitale:2022pmu confirmed the randomness of orbital orientations in GWTC-3, and Essick:2022slj placed the most stringent constraints to date on anisotropies in the sky distribution of mergers, though without a conclusive preference for isotropy. Theoretical motivations for such studies include parity-violating extensions of GR, reviewed in Qiao:2022mln , where left-right polarization asymmetries in gravitational waves could arise from new physics, such as Chern-Simons gravity. These ideas are tested observationally in Okounkova:2021xjv ; Ng:2023jjt , where amplitude birefringence is constrained in GWTC-2 and GWTC-3 data respectively, and in Haegel:2022ymk ; ONeal-Ault:2023lxi , which use the Standard-Model Extension framework to search for Lorentz- and CPT-violating birefringent and dispersive effects in GW propagation. See also Yamada:2020zvt for a parametrized test of parity-violating gravity with the events of GWTC-1. In addition, CalderonBustillo:2024akj measured a net circular polarization observable across 47 black-hole mergers and find that the average across events is consistent with zero; they identify only one event (GW200129) with strong evidence for asymmetry, while the rest show only mild evidence. From a quantum field theory perspective, Agullo:2017pyg shows that curved spacetime can itself induce polarization rotation in electromagnetic radiation via quantum anomalies. Finally, a multimessenger strategy introduced by Lagos:2024boe leverages electromagnetic observations of binary neutron star mergers to constrain polarization birefringence during gravitational wave propagation, offering a promising future direction with next-generation detectors. Gravitational waves are generated by accelerating masses with a changing quadrupole moment, such as merging black holes, neutron stars, or asymmetric supernova explosions. Since GWs are transverse traceless tensor waves Maggiore:2007ulw , they have two fundamental polarization states. These can be expressed in either the linear polarization basis ( h_{+},h_{\times} ), commonly used in ground-based detectors like LIGO, or the circular polarization basis ( h_{\leftturn},h_{\rightturn} ), which is more natural for describing waves emitted by rotating systems like binary inspirals. The mathematical definitions of these polarization bases, and their relation, are given in Section III . If all gravitational interactions respect parity symmetry, and if there is no parity preference in the distribution of positions and angular momentum of stellar mass black holes in the universe, then there should be no preferred handedness in observed LVK signals. We note that while in Isi:2023dlk the directional isotropy of the detected GW mergers is shown, we cannot be sure that such an isotropy will be conserved in larger scales. Recent studies have revealed a statistically significant asymmetry in the spin directions of spiral galaxies across the sky. Analysis of datasets from SDSS, HSC-SSP, and JWST indicates a dipole pattern in the distribution of galaxy handedness, suggesting a preferred cosmological axis. Shamir2012 ; Shamir2024HSC report that right- and left-handed spiral galaxies are unevenly distributed, with the asymmetry strengthening at higher redshifts. These results challenge the cosmological principle of isotropy and suggest either observational biases or new physics. Also, several theories predict parity-violating modifications, which would introduce an imbalance between h_{\rightturn} and h_{\leftturn} . Such an effect could be caused by interactions with axion-like fields Adshead2013 or chiral gravitational waves in the early universe Lue1999 . Observationally, testing this effect requires high-precision measurements of gravitational wave signals from binary black hole (BBH) mergers. The LVK network provides an excellent opportunity to probe such parity-violating effects. The presence of circular polarization asymmetry can be detected by comparing the statistical distributions of polarization modes over many BBH events Romano2017 . A significant detection of circular polarization asymmetry would have profound implications for fundamental physics, potentially pointing to new interactions in gravity that go beyond General Relativity. Future observing runs of the LVK collaboration, with increasing sensitivity and event rates, will enable more stringent tests of this hypothesis. The next-generation detectors, such as the Einstein Telescope and Cosmic Explorer, will allow the study of gravitational waves with unprecedented precision Punturo2010 Reitze2019 . If deviations from parity symmetry are found, it could revolutionize our understanding of gravity and hint at deeper connections between gravity and quantum field theory. In the remainder of this article, we present the structure and findings of our analysis in detail. In Section II , we summarize the observed LVK events and define the