Investigating red packet fraud in Android applications: Insights from user reviews

Yu Cheng, Xiaofang Qi, Yanhui Li · 2025

Read Investigating red packet fraud in Android applications: Insights from user reviews by Yu Cheng, Xiaofang Qi, Yanhui Li (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16941.txt.

Introduction

Yu Cheng, Xiaofang Qi, and Yanhui Li investigate fraud involving red packet cash gifts inside Android apps, in work from 2025. Red packets are a popular feature in Chinese apps, but users increasingly report being cheated by fake or unreachable rewards. The team mined app store reviews at scale to map the problem.

They first built a tool that finds apps offering red packets. They then collected over 360,000 reviews from 334 such apps across four stores and filtered them to red packet complaints. A fine-tuned language model flagged the negative reviews, and semantic analysis sorted the fraud into six categories. Fraud proved widespread, harming user experience and app reputations. The authors show developers use red packets as bait to drive task completion and profit.

Catalog record

CREATORYu Cheng, Xiaofang Qi, Yanhui Li
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16941

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Investigating red packet fraud in Android applications: Insights from user reviews Yu Cheng, Xiaofang Qi, Yanhui Li Abstract With the popularization of smartphones, red packets have been widely used in mobile apps. However, the issues of fraud associated with them have also become increasingly prominent. As reported in user reviews from mobile app markets, many users have complained about experiencing red packet fraud and being persistently troubled by fraudulent red packets. To uncover this phenomenon, we conduct the first investigation into an extensive collection of user reviews on apps with red packets. In this paper, we first propose a novel automated approach, ReckDetector, for effectively identifying apps with red packets from app markets. We then collect over 360,000 real user reviews from 334 apps with red packets available on Google Play and three popular alternative Android app markets. We preprocess the user reviews to extract those related to red packets and fine-tune a pre-trained BERT model to identify negative reviews. Finally, based on semantic analysis, we have summarized six distinct categories of red packet fraud issues reported by users. Through our study, we found that red packet fraud is highly prevalent, significantly impacting user experience and damaging the reputation of apps. Moreover, red packets have been widely exploited by unscrupulous app developers as a deceptive incentive mechanism to entice users into completing their designated tasks, thereby maximizing their profits. keywords Fraud, Red Packet, User Review, Android, Mobile App 1 Introduction Mobile applications (apps) have become an essential part of our daily lives. In recent years, red packets, the traditional Chinese gifts of money enclosed in red envelopes, have been digitized in mobile apps ( TechCrunch 2016 ) . People can use apps such as WeChat ( Wikipedia 2025c ) and Alipay ( Wikipedia 2025a ) to send and receive red packets to each other. With the growing popularity of digital red packets, an increasing number of app developers distribute red packets containing cash or coupons within their apps to attract users to download and use the apps, which has led to the widespread presence of red packets across a wide variety of apps. However, as reported by the media ( Paper 2024 ) , some unscrupulous app developers exploit red packets as a deceptive incentive mechanism to defraud users for profit. For example, users are lured into completing a series of tasks, such as watching video advertisements (ads) or inviting new users to download the app, but ultimately fail to receive the corresponding red packet rewards as promised. From user reviews involving red packets on app markets, we have also found numerous complaints from users who report falling victim to red packet fraud and being troubled by fraudulent red packets. This phenomenon seriously affects the user experience, undermines users interests, and has a significant negative impact on the reputation of both the app itself and the app market. It is very necessary to expose the phenomenon of red packet fraud in the mobile app ecosystem. Unfortunately, existing studies have not investigated the issues of red packet fraud that users frequently report on app markets. The only study on red packet fraud focuses on the use of fake red packets as bait to spread malicious content ( Cheng et al. 2025 ) , such as malicious apps or malicious redirects. This study proposed an automated approach for detecting red packet fraud that propagates malicious content by analyzing the landing pages of red packets after they are clicked. However, this method cannot be utilized to investigate the fraudulent issues that users complain about in their reviews, which primarily concern the amounts of red packets and misleading promotional claims. As such, there is an urgent need for new methods to systematically explore these issues. In app markets, all users are free to post their reviews on the apps they use, including praise, complaints, and suggestions. These user reviews provide critical information for app developers to improve their apps, and as a result, user reviews are widely utilized in research focused on app development, evolution, and maintenance ( Liu et al. 2023 ; Haggag et al. 2022 ; Li et al. 2020 ; Hu et al. 2021a ; Le et al. 2023 ) . To the best of our knowledge, no prior work in our research community has analyzed user reviews related to red packets. In this paper, we conduct the first empirical study and analysis of an extensive collection of user reviews on apps with red packets from popular Android app markets. There are two key challenges in investigating the issues of red packet fraud from user reviews. The first challenge is how to collect user reviews related to red packets from the vast amount of user reviews in app markets. Since app markets host millions of mobile apps, most of which do not incorporate red packets, the review sections of most apps are unlikely to contain user reviews related to red packets. How to efficiently collect relevant user reviews poses a challenge. The second challenge is how to automatically identify red packet fraud issues from user reviews related to red packets. Given that a user review related to the red packet may discuss multiple features or aspects of an app rather than solely describing the red packet itself, it is necessary to filter out unrelated noise. Furthermore, accurately categorizing red packet fraud issues and summarizing the content described in each category presents a significant challenge. In this paper, we design and implement an automated system consisting of three main steps to address the two challenges. We first propose a novel approach, ReckDetector, to effectively identify apps with red packets from app markets. Then, we employ web crawling techniques and relevant APIs to automatically collect real user reviews from apps with red packets on Google Play ( Google 2025b ) and three popular Chinese Android app markets, including Tencent Market ( Tencent 2025 ) , Huawei Market ( Huawei 2025 ) , and Xiaomi Market ( Xiaomi 2025 ) . Through keyword filtering and review segmentation, we extract the review content that only describes red packets (red packet reviews for short) from all user reviews. Subsequently, we fine-tune a pre-trained language model to identify negative reviews from red packet reviews. Finally, based on semantic analysis, these negative reviews about red packets are summarized into six distinct categories of red packet fraud issues reported by users. The contributions of our work are as follows: • We propose a novel automated approach, ReckDetector, for effectively identifying apps with red packets. We implement a prototype tool of ReckDetector, which is publicly available at https://github.com/AppFraud/ReckDetector . Experiments on the dataset of hundreds of real-world apps demonstrate that ReckDetector achieves higher performance than the state-of-the-art tool ReckDroid in identifying red packets. • We conduct the first analysis of user reviews related to red packets by leveraging natural language processing and machine learning techniques, uncovering six categories of red packet fraud issues from real user reviews in app markets. • Through our study, we found that red packet fraud is highly prevalent, significantly impacting user experience and damaging the reputation of apps. Moreover, red packets have been widely exploited by unscrupulous app developers as a deceptive incentive mechanism to

Read the complete text