Extrinsic Characterisations of Immersions

Bogdan D. Suceavă · 2025

Read Extrinsic Characterisations of Immersions by Bogdan D. Suceavă (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16841.txt.

Introduction

Bogdan Suceavă traces in 2025 the history of measuring how surfaces deform in space. Early curvature ideas grew through many hands before the modern frame set in. A mid-century theorem then let any curved space sit inside a flat larger one.

Relations between inner and outer measures of such placements stayed scarce. Gauss's equation forms a narrow gate for new links. A nineteen ninety three paper opened fresh paths past that gate. The essay asks whether new side conditions can widen the yield. Later inequalities research frames the modern hunt for such links.

Catalog record

CREATORBogdan D. Suceavă
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE41 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16841

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extrinsic Characterisations of Immersions Bogdan D. Suceavă Abstract . In 1763, Leonhard Euler wrote that one cannot define a good curvature measure for surfaces: “la question sur la courbure des surfaces n’est pas susceptible d’une réponse simple, mais elle exige à la fois une infinité de déterminations.” The quest for the right measure for curvature was settled by C.F. Gauss in 1825, and Sophie Germain introduced the mean curvature in 1831 (her memoir written in 1816 included also the average of principal curvature as a shape invariant). We outline the history of the idea of deformation of space, which lead to the concept of curvature invariants, as we understand them today, including contributions of E. Bacaloglu and F. Casorati, among others. We pursue the following question: what is the best way to quantify the deformation of space? This important question could be viewed in a new paradigm after 1956, when John F. Nash, Jr. proved that a Riemannian manifold can be immersed isometrically into an Euclidean ambient space of dimension sufficiently large. This important theorem allowed to view the representation of space from its exterior, from an outside perspective. In 1968, S.-S. Chern pointed out that a key technical element in applying Nash’s Theorem effectively is finding useful relationships between intrinsic and extrinsic quantities characterising immersions. And such relations seem to be rather few, at least few enough to present us with a technical challenge in applying Nash’s Theorem. One technical difficulty is presented by the passing through the narrow gateway provided by Gauss’ equation, and that’s why in order to obtain some new results it might be useful to include additional natural conditions. A turning point in the history of the question we pursue was an enlightening paper written by B.-Y. Chen in 1993, which paved the way for a deeper understanding of the meaning of the Riemannian inequalities between intrinsic and extrinsic quantities. Our present discussion invites a reflection on whether we could hope to characterise submanifolds by using mainly extrinsic quantities. After looking at several recent examples of such results, we conclude our paper with the following Problem. Are there any other extrinsic relations that determine the topology or the geometry of an embedded geometric object? How do we define them? How much insight do they provide, when we look at the geometric object “from the outside”? Mathematics Subject Classification (2020): 53A05, 53A55, 53B20, 53B25, 53C21, 53C42, 01A65. Key words: curvature, mean curvature, Chen invariants To appear in Romanian Journal of Mathematics and Computer Science available online at https://rjm-cs.utcb.ro An Invited Address at RIGA 2025 Delivered in Bucharest on May 24, 2025 Proceedings of the International Conference Riemannian Geometry and Applications ‐ RIGA 2025 Bucharest, Romania, May 23-25, 2025 Dedication: This work is dedicated to the memory of Professor Solomon Marcus (1925–2016), who pointed out that the history of curvature is incomplete without including E. Bacaloglu’s work. In 2025 the UNESCO Commission in Romania celebrates the Solomon Marcus centenary. 1. The Question of Space and its Deformations The present paper represents the written version of one of the four Invited Addresses at the Riemannian Geometry and Its Applications (RIGA) 2025 conference. The talk was presented on May 24, 2025. While the author is profoundly grateful to the organisers for their invitation, this work aims to reach out towards an interesting idea much indebted to the advances ushered in by John F. Nash, Jr.’s Embedding Theorem and its consequences (for its importance see e.g. [ 14 ] ). We felt this was the best opportunity to present a more thorough overview of our research direction, starting with the profound philosophical motivation of the theme. We have been much encouraged towards such a perspective by an inspiring paper, Leopold Verstraelen’s work [ 44 ] , an author whose views shaped much of our current interests. Our present perspective was preceded by yet another Invited Addres, delivered in the fall of 2022, for a national conference in philosophy in Romania, which can be read in the work [ 40 ] . Quite unexpectedly, the definition of curvature appears for the first time at the middle of the 14th century, in the works of Nicole Oresme [ 26 ] , see also [ 35 ] 1 1 1 The author of the present paper found out about Oresme’s works from Bang-Yen Chen’s work [ 13 ] , and also from several private conversations about the origin of the concept of curvature that took place at Michigan State University about the time the survey [ 13 ] was published. The atmosphere surrounding the Differential Geometry Seminar at Michigan State University in those years is recalled in the book [ 38 ] , and the careful reading of [ 26 ] lead among other works to [ 35 , 43 ] . . It is quite remarkable to point out that Oresme’s reasons to introduce his concept of curvitas (as it makes perfect sense within the context of his doctrine ) are not related to the mathematical motivations that later authors pursued to investigate deformations of shape, and together with it the modern concept of curvature. It is an idea born in Western Europe in the intellectual context of the Rediscovery of Aristotle [ 33 ] , a fertile context different from the scientific revolution from the 17th century [ 43 ] , when the later mathematical discoveries took place. The paradigms were so different that it really requires a different type of mathematical reading. The assertion we propose is that Oresme introduced the idea of investigating shape (a thought encoded in his works under the far-enveloping word “configurations”) at the same time with introducing the idea of curvature as deformation of shape, which makes the so-called (by its author) doctrine of configurations a striking contribution to the medieval thinking, analogue in this aspect with Riemann’s fundamental contribution from 1854 [ 31 ] . Namely, Oresme considers: (1) a representation of the idea of space; together with (2) its deformation. This is how there is an analogy between Oresme’s doctrine and Riemann’s seminal construction of the concept of manifold, together with its sectional curvature [ 31 ] . If there is any other source where the concept of curvature is discussed prior to 1351, it did not reach us and it is not known to us. It would actually be a very interesting question for historians if anyone would ever discover any contribution about the idea of deformation of space prior to Oresme’s thoughts. We cannot separate any discussion of Oresme’s doctrine of configurations from the problem of representing space. The origin of the theme, however, has in Western philosophy older roots than the Aristotle’s tradition, where Oresme found his inspiration (as far as his testimonial records). Bertrand Russell reflects in [ 34 ] , p.146 et al., on the following key fragment, from Plato’s Timaeus : “There is one kind of being which is always the same, uncreated and indestructible, never receiving anything into itself from without, not itself going out to any other, but invisible and imperceptible by any sense, and of which the contemplation is granted to intelligence only. And there is another nature of the same name with it,

Read the complete text