Good involutions of twisted conjugation subquandles and Alexander quandles
Lực Ta · 2025
Read Good involutions of twisted conjugation subquandles and Alexander quandles by Lực Ta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16772.txt.
Introduction
Ta describes good involutions of twisted conjugation subquandles and Alexander quandles in twenty twenty-five. Quandles are algebraic structures used to study knots. An involution is a symmetry that is its own inverse. A good one has traits that help it fit the rest of the structure. Ta gives an account of such maps for free quandles and for subquandles of twisted conjugation quandles. The account covers all Alexander quandles. He counts the good involutions of linear quandles. A computer search gives explicit maps up to order twenty-three.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lực Ta |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16772
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Good involutions of twisted conjugation subquandles and Alexander quandles Lực Ta Abstract . We completely describe good involutions of free quandles and subquandles of twisted conjugation quandles of groups, including all Alexander quandles. As an application, we enumerate good involutions of linear quandles, and we provide explicit mappings for those up to order 23 23 via a computer search. Along the way, we completely characterize connected, involutory Alexander quandles, which may be of independent interest. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 20N02; Secondary 20D45, 20K30, 57K12 1. Introduction Introduced by Kamada [ 23 ] in 2007, symmetric quandles are nonassociative algebraic structures used to study surface-links [ 23 ] [ 25 ] [ 42 ] [ 5 ] , handlebody-links [ 20 ] , 3 -manifolds [ 33 ] , compact surfaces with boundary in ribbon forms [ 35 ] , and framed virtual knots in thickened surfaces [ 16 ] . Defined as pairs (Q,\rho) where Q is a quandle and \rho is a function called a good involution of Q , symmetric quandles enjoy various (co)homology theories [ 23 ] [ 26 ] and connections to group theory [ 29 ] [ 20 ] . Symmetric quandles can be traced back to kei , which Takasaki [ 40 ] introduced in 1943 to study Riemannian symmetric spaces; quandles , which Joyce [ 22 ] and Matveev [ 30 ] independently introduced in 1982 to construct complete invariants of unframed links; and racks , which Fenn and Rourke [ 11 ] introduced in 1992 to construct complete invariants of framed links. See [ 9 ] [ 34 ] for references on the theory and [ 10 ] for a survey of the algebraic state of the art. Building upon the results in [ 37 ] , this paper concerns the following classification problems posed by Taniguchi [ 41 ] . Problem 1.1 . Find necessary and sufficient conditions for good involutions \rho of quandles to exist. Problem 1.2 . Given a quandle Q , determine all symmetric quandles of the form (Q,\rho) . Although various constructions of symmetric quandles exist [ 6 ] [ 5 ] [ 24 ] , few complete classification results in the vein of Problems 1.1 and 1.2 exist in the literature. In 2010, Kamada and Oshiro [ 23 ] addressed Problem 1.1 for kei and Problem 1.2 for dihedral quandles and trivial quandles. In 2023, Taniguchi [ 41 ] solved Problem 1.1 for generalized Alexander quandles and Problem 1.2 for connected generalized Alexander quandles. In 2025, the author [ 37 ] addressed Problems 1.1 and 1.2 for core quandles and subquandles of conjugation quandles. This paper answers Problems 1.1 and 1.2 for a large class of quandles called twisted conjugation quandles , which Andruskiewitsch and Graña [ 2 ] introduced in 2003 under the name twisted homogeneous crossed sets to study pointed Hopf algebras. Twisted conjugation quandles are of considerable interest to algebraists and knot theorists alike [ 1 ] [ 7 ] [ 3 ] [ 2 ] , in no small part because they generalize two already large classes of quandles called conjugation quandles and Alexander quandles . Conjugation quandles are used to generalize Wirtinger presentations of knot groups [ 22 ] [ 30 ] , and they enjoy many other connections across algebra [ 28 ] [ 12 ] [ 29 ] [ 38 ] and low-dimensional topology [ 8 ] [ 11 ] . In particular, good involutions of conjugation quandles are used to study noncommutative geometry applied to finite groups [ 29 ] , minimal triple point numbers of nonorientable surface-knots [ 5 ] , and coloring invariants of handlebody-knots [ 20 ] . Many common classes of quandles canonically embed into conjugation quandles; see [ 1 ] for a list. On the other hand, Alexander quandles provide a framework for studying modules over the ring of integral Laurent polynomials \mathbb{Z}[t^{\pm 1}] [ 32 ] [ 17 ] , and they provide linear-algebraic generalizations of Fox coloring invariants of knots [ 27 ] . 1.1. Main result Our most general result states that, given a subquandle X of a twisted conjugation quandle \Conj(G,\varphi) , every good involution \rho of X is completely determined by a unique function \zeta^{*} from the set \mathcal{O}(X,s) of connected components of (X,s) to a certain set S (cf. Remark 3.5 ) satisfying certain conditions. Theorem 1.3 (Theorem 3.4 ) . Let \varphi be an automorphism of a group G , and let (X,s) be a subquandle of the twisted conjugation quandle \Conj(G,\varphi) . Let \langle X\rangle denote the subgroup of G generated by X , and define the set S:=\{x\in\langle X\rangle\mid\varphi^{2}(y)=\varphi(x)yx^{-1}\text{ for all }y\in X\}. (See ( 3.2 ) for another description of S in the case that X contains the identity element of G .) Then for all functions \rho:X\to X , \rho is a good involution of (X,s) if and only if there exists a function \psi:X\to S such that \rho(x)=\psi(x)\varphi(x^{-1}),\qquad\psi s_{x}=\psi=\psi\rho for all x\in X . (Cf. Remark 3.5 and Theorem 4.2 .) Theorem 1.3 strengthens several similar results in the literature on symmetric quandles. Example 1.4 . Let \varphi:=\id_{G} be the identity map. Then S=Z(\langle X\rangle) , and \Conj(G,\id_{G})=(\Conj G)^{\mathrm{op}} is isomorphic to \Conj G via the inversion map g\mapsto g^{-1} . Therefore, Theorem 1.3 specializes to the statement of [ 37 ] *Thm. 1.3 with X replaced by X^{-1} . Since we use the latter theorem to prove Theorem 1.3 , the two results are actually equivalent. Example 1.5 . If G is abelian, then \Conj(G,\varphi) equals the Alexander quandle \Alex(G,\varphi) . Thus, Theorem 1.3 allows us to strengthen certain classification results of Taniguchi [ 41 ] in the abelian case; see Section 4 . In particular, unlike some of the results in [ 41 ] , Theorem 4.2 is not limited to connected Alexander quandles. We take advantage of this freedom to study good involutions of linear quandles ; see Section 5 . In particular, we recover a result of Kamada and Oshiro [ 23 ] *Thm. 3.2 for dihedral quandles . 1.2. Structure of the paper In Section 2 , we define good involutions of quandles. We provide several examples and preliminary results. In particular, we show that nontrivial free quandles have no good involutions (Example 2.27 ). This addresses Problems 1.1 and 1.2 for free quandles. In Section 3 , we prove Theorem 1.3 (Theorem 3.4 ) using a result for conjugation quandles from [ 37 ] . This addresses Problems 1.1 and 1.2 for twisted conjugation quandles. As an application, we obtain upper and lower bounds on the number of good involutions of certain subquandles of twisted conjugation quandles (Corollaries 3.6 – 3.8 and 3.10 ). In Section 4 , we completely describe good involutions of Alexander quandles (Theorem 4.2 ) by reducing to a special case of Theorem 1.3 . This addresses Problems 1.1 and 1.2 for Alexander quandles, extending the results of [ 41 ] in the abelian case without the assumption of connectedness. However, by adding this assumption, we strengthen another result of Taniguchi in the abelian case (Corollary 4.10 ). Along the way, we completely describe connected, involutory Alexander quandles (Theorem 4.8