A Scalable Framework for the Management of STPA Requirements: a Case Study on eVTOL Operations

Shufeng Chen, Halima El Badaoui, Mariat James Elizebeth, Takuya Nakashima, Siddartha Khastgir, Paul Jennings · 2025

Read A Scalable Framework for the Management of STPA Requirements: a Case Study on eVTOL Operations by Shufeng Chen, Halima El Badaoui, Mariat James Elizebeth, Takuya Nakashima, Siddartha Khastgir, Paul Jennings (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16708.txt.

Introduction

Shufeng Chen and co-authors present a framework for managing the flood of safety requirements from a systems analysis method in a 2025 paper. The method, called STPA, can find thousands of requirements that older techniques miss. Without a way to rank them, teams in fast-moving projects cannot act on them all.

Their framework scores each requirement on build time, cost, type, and how much regulation already covers it. Simulated random sampling steadies the rankings and cuts personal bias. A software chain maps the ranked list so choices stay traceable. The team validated the method on electric vertical take-off aircraft operations with the UK Civil Aviation Authority. The results fed a national publication on risks and safety measures for that new industry.

Catalog record

CREATORShufeng Chen, Halima El Badaoui, Mariat James Elizebeth, Takuya Nakashima, Siddartha Khastgir, Paul Jennings
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16708

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Scalable Framework for the Management of STPA Requirements: a Case Study on eVTOL Operations Shufeng Chen, Halima El Badaoui, Mariat James Elizebeth, Takuya Nakashima, Siddartha Khastgir, Paul Jennings Abstract System-Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) is a recommended method for analysing complex systems, capable of identifying thousands of safety requirements often missed by traditional techniques such as Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Fault Tree Analysis (FTA). However, the absence of a structured framework for managing and prioritising these requirements presents challenges, particularly in fast-paced development environments. This paper introduces a scalable framework for prioritising STPA-derived requirements. The framework integrates outputs from each STPA step and incorporates expert evaluations based on four key factors: implementation time, cost, requirement type, and regulatory coverage. To reduce subjectivity, Monte-Carlo Simulation (MCS) is employed to calculate and stabilise requirement rankings. An automation toolchain supports the framework, enabling dynamic mapping of prioritised requirements in a scaling matrix. This visualisation aids decision-making and ensures traceability across development phases. The framework is applicable from early conceptualisation to more advanced stages, enhancing its utility in iterative system development. The framework was validated through a real-world case study focused on Electric Vertical Take-off and Landing (eVTOL) operations, conducted in collaboration with the UK Civil Aviation Authority. The findings contributed directly to CAP3141, a Civil Aviation Publication that identifies systemic operational risks and safety mitigations for regulators, operators, and vertiports. The prioritisation process supported decision-making by helping stakeholders identify and manage high-impact requirements efficiently. This work contributes a practical solution for managing STPA outputs, bridging gaps in requirement prioritisation and supporting safety-critical development in emerging technologies. \nonumnote Abbreviations: Glossary . 1 Introduction With the increasing complexity of both technical and socio-technical systems, many new safety analysis methods have been developed to ensure that the safety-critical requirements due to the emergent properties of the systems are not overlooked. System-Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) is a system-thinking-based method that originated from MIT. It is part of the System-Theoretic Accident Model and Processes (STAMP) and has been used in various studies across different Sadeghi and Goerlandt 2023 . Including aviation Allison et al. 2017 , Schmid and Stanton 2018 , medical sector Wong et al. 2020 ; Yamaguchi and Thomas 2019 ; Chen et al. 2021 , maritime Yang et al. 2020 ; Ventikos et al. 2020 ; Nakashima et al. 2025 , automotive Zhou et al. 2019 ; Khastgir et al. 2021 ; Khastgir et al. 2017 ; Chen et al. 2020 , railway safety management Tonk and Boussif 2024 ; Riccardi et al. 2025 ; Chen et al. 2025 , and the safety analysis in the area of Large Language Models (LLM) Qi et al. 2025 . Especially in the aviation domain, STPA was highly recognized as a recommended methodology in the report Thomas et al. 2024 . It has been recognised as a recommended method to identify requirements that may not be identified by other traditional methods like Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) James Elizebeth et al. 2023 . STPA can be applied at the very early stage of the system development when available information about the system is very limited. As a deductive method, it starts with the stakeholders’ engagement to identify any unacceptable losses that must be prevented (i.e., step 1). Control Structure(s) that represent the graphical interactions of the system stakeholders, in the form of nested control loops, are then created (i.e., step 2). Based on the Control Structure(s), each CA is then analysed to understand how they might manifest into Unsafe Control Actions (UCAs) (i.e., step 3). Each UCA is then further analysed, together with the analyses of the relevant control loops, to identify their possible Causal Factors (CF) and requirements to either prevent or detect these CFs (i.e., step 4). For a complex system like the autonomous vehicle ecosystem or helicopter operation, STPA identifies up to a few thousand requirements. Although STPA has been recognized as a recommended method for complex system safety analysis, the lack of frameworks to manage and prioritise these requirements presents unique challenges, especially when applying STPA in a fast-paced development cycle. Requirement prioritisation is the process of determining the relative importance or urgency of requirements to guide decision-making during the development of the system. It helps stakeholders identify what to implement first, ensuring that the most valuable features are delivered early and that resources are allocated effectively. There have been many methods for requirement prioritisation developed to optimise the requirement engineering process. These include MoSCoW Kravchenko et al. 2022 , (Analytic Hierarchy Process ) AHP Kriswardhana et al. 2025 , Cumulative Voting Cagliero et al. 2021 , and Kano Model Slevitch 2025 , etc. However, the limitations, such as subjectivity-oriented, lack of scalability, communication of results, and change management, still exist in these methods, making them less applicable when managing the requirements of a complex system Kıvanç et al. 2025 . Having identified these limitations of the existing requirement prioritisation techniques, in this paper, the authors aim to address the following research questions: 1.1 Research Gaps 1. RQ1: How can the requirements identified from the STPA be effectively implemented for safe system operation? 2. RQ2: How can we objectively prioritise all the requirements identified by STPA? 3. RQ3: How can the prioritised requirements be better communicated with the stakeholders? 1.2 Paper Contribution In this paper, a new framework to optimise the prioritisation of STPA requirements is presented. The framework was designed in a way that parameterises and utilizes the outputs from the previous steps of STPA. Our previous work regarding the framework for prioritisation of UCAs was introduced El Badaoui et al. 2025 . For simplicity, we call it the P_{UCA} Framework in this paper. As a continued development, another framework focusing on the prioritisation of requirements is introduced. It is called the P_{REQ} Framework in this paper. The P_{REQ} Framework is the main contribution of this paper. It utilizes the priorities of UCAs, which are the output of the P_{UCA} Framework. This makes the framework applicable at the early stage of the development when STPA is started, rather than waiting until all the requirements have been identified at a later stage of the development. Besides the priorities of UCAs, the requirement ranking process also considers inputs from domain experts, which are then calculated using Monte-Carlo Simulation (MCS) to minimise the subjectivity of the ranking. The calculation is supported by an automation toolchain, and the results can be automatically mapped in a dynamic scaling matrix. This allows the framework to be scalable to high-level systems at the initial conceptualisation of the development and then to more complex systems as the development progresses. The matrix provides a clear visualisation of the ranked sets of requirements to help with further decision-making. The framework was applied to a real project aiming at improving the safe operations of Electric Vertical Take-off and Landing (eVTOL), which is a new development domain that requires continuous identification, prioritisation, and management of requirements. The proposed prioritisation framework has significantly contributed to the decision-making processes throughout the development. 2 Literature Review Prioritisation of requirements has been extensively studied across numerous publications, largely because handling thousands of outputs can strain resource allocation and impede decision-making

Read the complete text