Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED”
Jerrold Franklin · 2025
Read Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED” by Jerrold Franklin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16689.txt.
Introduction
Jerrold Franklin rebuts a recent claim about magnetic fields in this 2025 comment paper. The target paper argued that a magnetic dipole forces big changes to Maxwell's equations and to the Poynting theorem on energy flow. Franklin says that claim rests on critical errors.
He shows the laws stay the same for a magnetic moment as for any other spread of charge and current. No change to the rule that magnetic field lines never end is needed. The comment is short and aimed at specialists. It defends the standard form of classic field theory against a proposed rewrite.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jerrold Franklin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 3 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16689
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comment on “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED”
Jerrold Franklin
Abstract
The paper “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem, Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED”, arXiv:2501.02022, by Peter J. Mohr, purports to show that Maxwell’s equation, ∇ ⋅ 𝐁 = 0 \mbox{\boldmath$\nabla\cdot$}{\bf B}=0 , and Poynting’s theorem require significant modications for the 𝐁 \bf B field of a magnetic dipole. We show here that, because of critical errors in the paper, these claims are false, and that Maxwell’s equation and the Poynting theorem are the same for a magnetic moment as for any other charge-current distribution.
The paper, “Magnetic moments in the Poynting theorem,
Maxwell equations, Dirac equation, and QED” (PJM), arXiv:2501.02022, by Peter J. Mohr, starts its discussion of the
\bf B
field of a magnetic dipole,
\bf m
, with its equation (14), for
r>0
,
\displaystyle{\bf B_{m}}
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}\left[\frac{3{\bf r(r\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}m)-m}}{r^{3}}\right],
(1)
taken from Jackson’s 3rd edition
[
1
]
.
It then states,“An equivalent way of expressing this for
r>0
is
\displaystyle{\bf B_{m}(r})
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}{\bf(m\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$})\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}}\left(\frac{1}{r}\right),
(2)
where the derivatives reproduce Eq. (14).”
Then, for some reason, PJM used this equation instead of its Eq. (14) to extend
\bf B_{m}
down to
r=0
, including a delta function at the origin by taking an angular average,
to get,
\displaystyle\int d\Omega_{r}{\bf B_{m}(r)}
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle\frac{-\mu_{0}}{3}{\bf m}\delta({\bf r}),
(3)
which is Eq. (16) of PJM.
No reason is given why this alternate procedure is used instead of a similar procedure used in
[
1
]
which gave
\displaystyle\int d\Omega_{r}{\bf B_{m}(r)}
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle\frac{+2\mu_{0}}{3}{\bf m}\delta({\bf r}).
(4)
The question of which of the two angular averages is correct is answered by the fact that Eq. (4) gives the right sign and magnitude for hyperfine structure of atomic states.
A more vital error, since either form for
\bf B_{m}
is the result of an angular average, is that the result can only be used in an angular average. This means that Eq. (17) of PJM,
\displaystyle\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla\cdot$}[{\bf B_{m}(r)}]
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle-\frac{\mu_{0}}{4\pi}{(\bf m\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}})\nabla^{2}\left(\frac{1}{r}\right)=-\frac{\mu_{0}}{3}{\bf m\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}\delta(r}),
(5)
is wrong because it must be replaced by the angular average,
\displaystyle\int d\Omega_{r}\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla\cdot$}[{\bf B_{m}(r)}]
\displaystyle=
\displaystyle-\frac{\mu_{0}}{3}\int d\Omega_{r}{\bf m\mbox{\boldmath$\cdot$}\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla$}}\delta({\bf r})=0.
(6)
It is not surprising that any correct usage gives
\bf\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla\cdot$}B_{m}=0
, since the starting point
in reference
[
1
]
(and all other EM textbooks) was
\bf B=\mbox{\boldmath$\nabla\times$}A
.
Starting with a non-vanishing divergence of
\bf B_{m}
because of not appropriately averaging over angle makes all the subsequent equations and conclusions of PJM wrong.