Empirical Analysis of the Model-Free Valuation Approach: Hedging Gaps, Conservatism, and Trading Opportunities
Zixing Chen 1 , Yihan Qi 1 , Shanlan Que 1 , Julian Sester 1 , Xiao Zhang 1 · 2025
Read Empirical Analysis of the Model-Free Valuation Approach: Hedging Gaps, Conservatism, and Trading Opportunities by Zixing Chen 1 , Yihan Qi 1 , Shanlan Que 1 , Julian Sester 1 , Xiao Zhang 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16595.txt.
Introduction
Zixing Chen and co-authors test how safe a price method that shuns models can be for stock options, in a paper from 2025. The method hedges with a worst case shield that needs no guess about how prices move. The team set that shield next to real payoffs for option prices on large US stocks from 2018 to 2022.
The gap between shield and payoff proves to be just a shade wider than the gaps of standard models that do guess a price law. In plain terms the shield is barely more strict than shop norms. That small cost buys a hard floor on loss by path. The authors build a trade plan on the gap and show it can earn in real markets with its floor intact.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zixing Chen 1 , Yihan Qi 1 , Shanlan Que 1 , Julian Sester 1 , Xiao Zhang 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16595
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Empirical Analysis of the Model-Free Valuation Approach: Hedging Gaps, Conservatism, and Trading Opportunities Zixing Chen 1 , Yihan Qi 1 , Shanlan Que 1 , Julian Sester 1 , Xiao Zhang 1 Abstract . In this paper we study the quality of model-free valuation approaches for financial derivatives by systematically evaluating the difference between model-free super-hedging strategies and the realized payoff of financial derivatives using historical option prices from several constituents of the S & \& P 500 500 between 2018 2018 and 2022 2022 . Our study allows in particular to describe the realized gap between payoff and model-free hedging strategy empirically so that we can quantify to which degree model-free approaches are overly conservative. Our results imply that the model-free hedging approach is only marginally more conservative than industry-standard models such as the Heston-model while being model-free at the same time. This finding, its statistical description and the model-independence of the hedging approach enable us to construct an explicit trading strategy which, as we demonstrate, can be profitably applied in financial markets, and additionally possesses the desirable feature with an explicit control of its downside risk due to its model-free construction preventing losses pathwise. Keywords: Model-free price bounds, Hedging, Linear programming, Profitable Trading August 10, 2026 1 National University of Singapore, Department of Mathematics, 21 Lower Kent Ridge Road, 119077. 1. Introduction Building on the foundational works Beiglböck et al. 2013 ; Beiglböck and Juillet 2016 ; Henry-Labordère et al. 2016 , which establish the connection between solutions of the martingale optimal transport problem, model-free price bounds for financial derivatives and associated hedging strategies, the literature on model-free approaches and their application to derivative valuation has grown rapidly and still continues to grow. See, for instance, Ansari et al. 2024 ; Cheridito et al. 2017 ; Chiu and Cont 2023 ; Davis 2016 ; Dolinsky and Soner 2014 ; de Gennaro Aquino and Bernard 2020 ; Fahim and Huang 2016 ; Hobson and Neuberger 2012 ; Hobson and Klimmek 2015 ; Eckstein et al. 2021 ; Lux and Papapantoleon 2017 , among many others. Using only available market data of liquidly traded put- and call options, the aforementioned model-free approaches compute price bounds for less liquidly traded (so called exotic) options solely under the paradigm of no arbitrage and of consistency with observed liquid option prices but, importantly, without using any assumptions on the stochastic dynamics of the underlying assets. The resultant price bounds are then calculated as extreme prices among all calibrated arbitrage-free models, and therefore can be understood to be model-free and to respect the so called Knightian uncertainty ( Knight 1921 ), i.e., the unquantifiable risk of having chosen a wrong model. While appealing from a risk management perspective, not imposing model assumptions theoretically comes at the application-prohibitive cost of resultant model-free price bounds by construction being larger than the price in any calibrated model that is also consistent with liquid option prices and arbitrage-free, making the approach less appealing from a practitioner’s perspective, see also the discussions in Eckstein and Kupper 2021 ; Lütkebohmert and Sester 2019 ; Dolinsky and Neufeld 2018 . To the best of our knowledge there exists however little to no research providing empirical evidence for the actual conservativeness of model-free approaches, i.e., research answering the question how much the corresponding prices bounds are too wide in real financial markets, and whether they indeed prevent applicability. According to the duality theory developed in Beiglböck et al. 2013 ; Beiglböck and Juillet 2016 ; Henry-Labordère et al. 2016 , to study the quality of model-free upper price bounds, one can equivalently study prices of model-free super-replication strategies (or sub-replication strategies for lower price bounds). Namely, if the gap between the realized payoff of a price bound-attaining model-free super-replication strategy and the realized derivative payoff is (too) large, this indicates that the strategy’s price and hence its initial cash endowment was too large as well and could be reduced to obtain a less conservative strategy with payoff closer to the derivative’s actual payoff. Relying on the above outlined idea, the present paper aims at closing an existing research gap by studying systematically the difference between model-free hedging strategies (corresponding to model-free price bounds) and realized payoffs of exotic derivatives. For our empirical study, we use historical option prices written on seven of the largest assets by market capitalization of the S \& P 500 between 2018 and 2022 . This paper is the first to empirically quantify the realized hedging performance and conservatism of model-free super-hedging strategies using real market data. Our findings challenge the prevailing common belief that model-free methods are impractically conservative, at least if the involved assets and sufficiently many call- and put options are liquidly traded in the market, as it is the case for our study. Our analysis shows that model-free hedging strategies lead to a hedging performance lacking not much behind the ones of industry-standard models such as the Black-Scholes-, Heston- and Dupire’s local volatility model. As, in contrast to the aforementioned industry-standard models, model-free super hedging strategies do not rely on a specific probabilistic model of the underlying security, they always lead to larger payoffs than the derivative given any realization of the security. We use this robustness property to propose a trading strategy that makes use of both our statistical description of the payoff gap and the model-free construction of the hedging strategy. Trading for this strategy is triggered whenever observed market quotes for the derivative are close enough to its model-free price bounds where the degree of proximity determines the probability of a positive payoff which can be exactly described according to our statistical analysis. The strategy is robust in the sense that up to the initial investment no additional money can be lost due to its model-free construction, consequently leading to a low-risk trading strategy with an easy-to-understand risk profile. The remainder of this paper is as follows. In Section 2 we provide an overview on the used data, Section 3 describes in detail the employed mathematical approach to compute the super-hedging strategies based on linear programming. Section 4 presents the results of our analysis when being applied to data, and Section 5 discusses and analyzes a trading strategy that is based on our statistical findings. 2. Data and technology 2.1. Data For our study, we use data received from Wharton Research Data Services . The data comprises bid and ask prices of traded put- and call options in the time between Jan 1 2018 and Dec 31 2022. The considered underlying securities on which the options are written are the stocks of Amazon.com Inc, JP Morgan Chase & Co., Johnson & Johnson, Procter & Gamble Co., Walmart Inc, VISA Inc, and Tesla Inc. 2.2. Code For the sake of transparency and replicability, we provide the used Python-code in an accompanying github-repository 1 1 1 The repository can be found under https://github.com/QIYIHAN/Empirical-Price-Bounds . . Unfortunately, legal constraints prevent us from providing the historical option price data in the github repository. 3. Methodology Our methodology consists mainly of three steps. In the first step we pre-process the data, second we compute model-free price bounds and corresponding hedging strategies via linear programming, and third