Thermal convection in huddling emperor penguins
Dmitry Bratsun, Kirill Kostarev · 2025
Read Thermal convection in huddling emperor penguins by Dmitry Bratsun, Kirill Kostarev (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16586.txt.
Introduction
Dmitry Bratsun and Kirill Kostarev model how huddling emperor penguins share heat in a 2025 paper. These birds are the only penguins that winter in Antarctica, packing tight to survive the cold. Their model treats each bird as drawn along the warmth gradient of its neighbors. Small groups settle into a still huddle, matching field reports.
Past a size threshold, the huddle suddenly starts to swirl, they find. The shift is a second-order phase change into vortex motion. Birds cycle from the cold edge to the warm center and back. The authors call this thermal convection, like heat flow in a fluid, and match it to real huddle behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dmitry Bratsun, Kirill Kostarev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 16 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Thermal convection in huddling emperor penguins Dmitry Bratsun, Kirill Kostarev Abstract Emperor penguins are the only penguin species that winter in Antarctica. As is known, during cold weather, birds huddle together to share body heat. We developed a microscopic model in which penguins interact with each other through an effective potential that describes the birds’ intention to move along the gradient of the thermal field. The model describes the aggregation of penguins into a motionless huddle, as observed previously. More interestingly, we found that increasing the number of birds leads to a second-order phase transition, characterized by the excitation of a vortex motion in a huddle. The dynamic behavior ensures a more efficient redistribution of heat between penguins and, consequently, the survival of all birds in the flock. To study the instability mechanism, we developed a continuous model and applied both linear and weakly nonlinear analysis. Numerically, we studied the increasing complexity of vortex structures in a fluidized huddle with increasing its power. Finally, we demonstrate that the effect of sudden fluidization of a huddle, resulting in the spontaneous motion of penguins from the edge of the crowd to its center and back, is essentially thermal convection. The findings are juxtaposed against observations of emperor penguins. pacs 82.40.Ck, 47.20.Bp, 47.70.Fw, 82.33.Ln Thermal convection, the ordered motion of molecules of a non-uniformly heated liquid or gas induced by the buoyancy, occupies a special place in the history of physics. The study of this phenomenon led to the development of the theory of convective stability Rayleigh1916 , the first observations of spatial patterns Benard1900 , and the discovery of deterministic chaos Lorenz1963 . The concept was used to explain the formation of the Earth Nguyen2013 , ocean currents Holmes1931 , stellar astrophysics Behrend2001 , and RDC processes Bratsun2021 , among others. The standard explanation of natural convection onset within fluid mechanics is as follows: if a small parcel of a stratified fluid is accidentally displaced to a colder environment, it continues to move further away from its equilibrium position due to the Archimedes force Gershuni1976 , indicating that the basic stratification is unstable. Thus, convective instability is driven by the change in density of the fluid as it heats up and cools down. Prigogine provided a deeper interpretation of the phenomenon based on the synergetics ideas Prigogine1984 . Here, one observes a second-order phase transition, enabling the system to adopt a more efficient spatial configuration in response to an increase in the heat flux. But what would change if we go beyond physics and replace molecules with more complex elements? The phenomenon of bioconvection, the pattern-forming motions that occur in suspensions of swimming microorganisms, partially answers this question Hill2005 . The capacity of microorganisms to move autonomously during chemotaxis creates a force of buoyancy, causing an instability. Thus, bioconvection is not fundamentally different from thermal convection, though it occurs in an isothermal medium. From a biological perspective, the onset of spatial circulations of bacteria allows them to access a resource essential for the survival of the entire colony. In the case of higher animals, researchers find it troublesome to distinguish the circulations of animals from their social behavior. As is known, collective behavior can serve as a mechanism for energy conservation, playing a crucial role in the survival of some species Trenchard2016 . However, a simple explanation based on physical mechanisms is no longer sufficient since the primary trigger for such behavior is social adaptation rather than an unconditioned reflex Sumpter2010 . Nevertheless, we can point to one important exception, where higher animals demonstrate collective behavior that has even more similarities with the classical thermal convection than the bioconvection of microbes. It is the huddling behavior of emperor penguins ( Aptenodytes forsteri ) during wintering in Antarctica Williams1995 . Until recently, scientists had limited knowledge about the lifecycle of this species due to the difficulty of accessing its habitat. In the last century, the results of early observations during rare expeditions were summarized in Maho1977 , mentioning the collective strategy of these birds for survival. In 2005, the documentary film Marche2005 was released, stimulating further research. Among other things, the film demonstrated the spontaneous huddling of penguins when the ambient temperature drops sharply. In recent years, significant results have emerged from field observations, which also include quantitative measurements Ancel1997 ; Ancel2009 ; Ancel2015 ; Richter2018a ; Richter2018b ; Fretwell2021 . Air temperature and wind speed are two critical factors that influence the onset of huddling Richter2018b . One also suggested that there is a similarity between the huddling and a first-order phase transition, leading to a change in the aggregation state of the medium. Several papers have developed mathematical models to describe the behavior of penguins, with a particular focus on the huddling process Waters2012 ; Gerum2013 ; Dhiman2018 ; Gu2018 ; Harris2023 . More significant second-order phase transitions associated with self-organization have received insufficient attention from researchers. Meanwhile, in several episodes of Marche2005 and supplementary video materials Richter2018b , one could observe the impact of sudden fluidization of a dense huddle and the spontaneous excitation of global circulations of penguins within the flock. Biologists refer to this phenomenon as “social thermoregulation”, but, in our opinion, as in the case of bioconvection, the instability mechanism can be explained by purely physical reasons. In this Communication, we state for the first time that the spontaneous excitation of penguins’ circulations in a fluidized huddle is nothing other than a second-order phase transition in the form of the excitation of thermal convection. We develop mathematical models that provide both a microscopic and continuous description of the phenomenon observed in emperor penguins. Figure 1: (a) Typical frame taken from film Marche2005 demonstrating that a motionless huddle of penguins can experience spontaneous fluidisation and excitation of global circulations of birds on the scale of the entire flock; (b) The key assumption of our mathematical model: the intention of a penguin to move in the direction of a thermal gradient generates an efficient buoyancy in a huddle; (c) Individual-based model reproduces the assembling of 500 penguins into a dense huddle, in the center of which the temperature gradually reaches a comfortable value. The figure shows four consecutive frames of the time dynamics, indicating the instantaneous location of birds and the temperature distribution; (d) Bifurcation diagram showing the correlation function of penguin velocities averaged over an ensemble and realisations as a function of the number of participating birds. The inserts show the instantaneous velocity fields for some huddles; (e) With any wind speed, a two-vortex circulation of penguins replaces a motionless huddle. The figure shows the result of a direct numerical simulation for a huddle of 500 penguins. Microscopic modeling . – Figure 1a shows a frame taken from film Marche2005 demonstrating that an occasional huddle formed by penguins can be heterogeneous. Some birds are motionless, forming a quasi-crystalline structure ( solid state ), while others make poorly coordinated movements around this huddle ( gas ). One can also distinguish a part of the flock whose behavior is similar to that of an unstable fluid. One can observe the macroscopic two-vortex flow developed as a result of the instability. We suggest that penguin interactions are best described by Aristotelian