Capturing Finite Target Dynamics: Phase-Delayed Analytic Modeling of Multi-Layer Penetration Events

Trenton Kirchdoerfer · 2025

Read Capturing Finite Target Dynamics: Phase-Delayed Analytic Modeling of Multi-Layer Penetration Events by Trenton Kirchdoerfer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16583.txt.

Introduction

Trenton Kirchdoerfer, writing alone in 2025, updates a fast model for rods punching through layered walls. The base model works well for thick targets. Thin walls break its accuracy, since nose and tail speeds are off. For stacks of thin walls, that error distorts how much the rod wears away.

Kirchdoerfer uses fine scale simulations to spot the gap. His fix adds wave travel inside the target to the model. No new fit parameters are added. Thin target results now match detailed simulation well. Thick target behavior stays sound. Tests on multi wall stacks also agree with simulation and lab data. The update keeps the model's speed while widening its range.

Catalog record

CREATORTrenton Kirchdoerfer
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16583

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Capturing Finite Target Dynamics: Phase-Delayed Analytic Modeling of Multi-Layer Penetration Events Trenton Kirchdoerfer Abstract The Walker-Anderson half-space penetration model has been successfully used for the rapid, efficient calculation of penetration of walls by rigid and eroding rods. These models align well with detailed simulations for thick targets; however, existing extensions for finite targets struggle to accurately capture nose-tail velocity profiles in thinner targets. For stack-ups of thin-walled targets, this deficiency results in mischaracterized rod-erosion relative to hydrocode or experimental predictions. In this work, we leverage insights from detailed hydro-code simulations to propose an updated modification to the Walker-Anderson model to correctly account for wave propagation within a given target. This addition improves results for thin targets while retaining good behavior for thick targets with zero additional model parameters. Our updated model exhibits strong agreement with detailed simulations for targets with multiple thin walls. 1 Introduction Within penetration mechanics, analytic models mechanics have a significant history of providing the ability to both summarize and efficiently predict effects within targets and projectiles [ 1 ] . These methods are at odds with the significant trends in fast-solving models for penetration mechanics that invoke machine learning strategies [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] that are themselves children of traditional curve/trend fits – albeit with greater potential to match complex behavior. However semi-analytic, mechanics-driven methods have not been reduced in their efficacy by time and can additionally provide intuition that generalized fits cannot easily supply. For eroding rod projectiles, Walker and Anderson [ 5 ] developed a robust framework of assumed flow field models built from intuitions they derived from detailed 2D hydro-code simulations for half-space impacts. This model was later augmented by a number of extensions to address finite domains [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] , alternate material types [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] , and even composite targets [ 12 ] . Within that corpus of extensions, this paper will seek to improve the modeling of finite monolithic targets, specfically focusing on thinner domains than was the focus of previous works. Principally, the efforts that updated the half-space to a finite domain act as corrections on the original infinite-depth model. The first model developed by Ravid [ 6 ] introduced a geometric bulge formation and failure criteria without modifying the original half-space balance equations. It was followed [ 7 ] with an extension to handle projectile recovery after target failure and was applied to multi-target impacts which inspire our own demonstrations later in the paper. A separate back-face model was also developed by Walker [ 8 ] , which also included bulging and failure [ 13 ] within the target but with a updated momentum balance that properly addressed the finite domain. Both models are remarkably effective at capturing finite target response, and a comparison of their performance against a hydro-code as shown in Figure 1 . This borrowed [ 7 ] scenario is made up of a 49.9 cm tungsten projectile of 1.65 cm diameter as it impacts a 30 cm thick steel target followed by a half-space witness plate 10 cm behind the finite target. Within the plot, we see the nose and tail velocity profiles of the two discussed models compared against a matched hydro-code result. Note that the plot styles are matching for nose and tail history traces as there is no ambiguity: nose velocity is lower and tail velocity is higher. The hollow dots indicate when the respective analytic models affect failure. Figure 1 : Previous models compared against hydro-code result, including both projectile nose and tail velocities; hollow circles indicate target failure. Lower and higher of a given style respectively represent nose and tail response of the projectile. In Figure 1 , we see that the Ravid model performs well, and we find it’s strain-failure cutoffs are relatively easy to tune for triggering the projectile recovery phase of the calculation. But despite those results, it is apparent is that the Walker back-face more correctly captures nose reacceleration via the more rigorous treatment of the momentum balance. As can be seen by the smooth transition after failure, this treatment results in the projectile recovery phase becoming largely insensitive to the specific failure strains. Between the two models then, it is apparent that Walker’s approach to the finite domain better captures the dynamics of a weakening target. However, as we examine impacts into thinner targets, the possibility for improvement becomes more apparent. To demonstrate we modify our earlier problem so that the same projectile impacts a single 4 cm target and plot the results in Figure 2(a) . (a) Nominal diameter projectile (1.65 cm) (b) Double diameter projectile (3.3 cm) Figure 2 : Model nose and tail velocities demonstrated against 4 cm target; hollow circles indicate target failure. In general we see that all significant model differences occur in the velocity drop of the projectile nose. Within that context, we see that prior to 15 \mathrm{\mu s} the Ravid model treatment of the target as infinite yields reasonable results, though after that time the model falters. Alternatively, we again see the Walker model matches the smooth character of the hydro-simulation projectile recovery, but now it is clear that the initiation of that recovery is premature. In this model Walker finite target effect becomes activated as soon as the plastic zone reaches the target backface. To explore this behavior further, we scale up the projectile diameter, and consequently the plastic zone, which exaggerates the effect shown in Figure 2(b) What we see in both Figure 2 plots is that an infinite target model-assumption is outperforming our more advanced finite target model in early time, when the finite target effects have not yet had time to propagate across the target domain. Incorporating that understanding into an updated model will then be the primary focus of this paper, with some effort expended to improve early time response as well. Given that our reference models are detailed hydro-simulation results, we can interrogate the target response to better understand how best to advance the model. Such advancements will be shown to improve our analytic model performance without heavy computational penalties. The structure of the paper is as follows: First, we review the original Walker-Anderson [ 5 ] model and identify parameters for both the model and reference simulations, which serve as the basis for subsequent comparisons. Next, we investigate improvements in impact initialization to enhance the early-time response for infinite targets. With these updates we then proceed to review the critical aspects of the Walker modified flow model [ 8 ] that affect a finite domain. We demonstrate that directly applying improved impact initialization to finite target models introduces challenges, highlighting the need to account for wave propagation effects. By post-processing hydro-code results, we examine the influence of non-linear wave propagation and show that linear bulk-wave propagation adequately captures the essential mechanics. This insight guides the implementation of a phase delay consistent with wave propagation in our model. Finally, we present detailed comparisons across targets of varying thicknesses and velocities, as well as multi-target impacts. The paper concludes with a summary of the findings and a discussion of remaining model inconsistencies. 2 The Model 2.1 Review of the

Read the complete text