Soft Theorems and Dilaton Effective Theory
* · 2025
Read Soft Theorems and Dilaton Effective Theory by * (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16501.txt.
Introduction
Roman Zwicky derives a new model free double soft dilaton theorem, counting the space time dependence of the dilation commutator. The work also weighs gravity form factors as a probe of infrared conformality. It came out in twenty twenty-five.
The method restores positive mass for the pseudo Goldstone modes and pins a scaling bound on any single operator that gives the dilaton mass. In a second part, Zwicky asks how far QCD like gauge theories, in the chiral limit, fit this class. The quark pair operator meets the bound. Some results hold in a supersymmetric gauge theory, with an argued reach below its conformal window.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | * |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16501
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Soft Theorems and Dilaton Effective Theory * Abstract We derive a new model-independent double-soft dilaton theorem, taking into account the spacetime dependence of the dilation commutator [ i Q D , 𝒪 ( x ) ] = ( Δ 𝒪 + x ⋅ ∂ ) 𝒪 ( x ) [iQ_{D},{\cal O}(x)]=(\Delta_{\cal O}+x\cdot\partial){\cal O}(x) . The procedure restores positivity in the (pseudo)-Goldstone masses and sets the constraint Δ 𝒪 = d − 2 \Delta_{\cal O}=d-2\, for a single operator 𝒪 {\cal O} responsible for generating a dilaton mass.We discuss gravitational form factors as a tool to probe infrared conformality in field theories with particle content. In a second part we explore to what extent QCD-like gauge theories (in the chiral limit) could fit into this category. We find that the quark bilinear has scaling dimension Δ q ¯ q = d − 2 \Delta_{\bar{q}q}=d-2 , therefore satisfying the double-soft theorem. We show that some findings are realised in 𝒩 = 1 {\cal N}=1 supersymmetric gauge theories and argue that the extension below the conformal window makes sense in that case. Roman Zwicky 1 Introduction The dilaton in our context is the Goldstone boson due to spontaneous scale symmetry breaking. Originally introduced and developed to describe the strong interactions e.g. [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] , it has found numerous applications in particle physics and cosmology [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . Recent interest has been spurred by a light singlet J^{PC}=0^{++} state emerging in lattice simulations at finite quark mass. We begin by reviewing model-independent soft dilaton theorems in section 2 , verify them in dilaton effective theory in section 3 before discussing the possibility that gauge theories in the chirally broken phase, including QCD, are described by an infrared fixed point (IRFP) with a dilaton. For the latter, prominent features are the extraction of scaling dimensions and the impact on gravitational form factors. 2 Model-independent Soft Dilaton Theorem Soft theorems were part of the current algebra arsenal in the 1960’s and assume that a (pseudo) Goldstone (pG) is much lighter than the remaining particles (or hadrons) m_{pG}\ll m_{\text{had}} . In practice, this amounts to replacing the soft Goldstone by a symmetry transformation. 1 1 1 In the language of correlation function this corresponds to the reduction of a n -point to a ( n - 1 )-point function. For example, a scalar-vertex with zero momentum insertion can be replaced by mass-differentiation. Formulated in the concrete case of spontaneously broken scale invariance it reads \lim_{q\to 0}\langle D(q)\beta|{\cal O}(0)|\alpha\rangle=-\frac{1}{F_{D}}\langle\beta|i[Q_{D},{\cal O}(0)]|\alpha\rangle\;+\;\lim_{q\to 0}iq\cdot R\;+\;{\cal O}(m^{2}_{D}/m^{2}_{\text{had}})\;, (1) where R_{\mu}=-\frac{i}{F_{D}}\int d^{d}ze^{iq\cdot z}\langle\beta|TJ^{D}_{\mu}(z){\cal O}(0)|\alpha\rangle\;, (2) is the remainder which vanish unless |\alpha,\beta\rangle are degenerate with intermediate states and Q_{D}=\int d^{d-1}zJ_{0}^{D}(z) the dilatation charge. The quantity F_{D} is the dilaton decay constant and the order parameter of the spontaneous scale symmetry breaking. It is defined through the T_{\mu\nu} , the energy-momentum tensor 2 2 2 It is related to the Goldstone current by J_{D}^{\mu}=x_{\nu}T^{\mu\nu} such that \langle 0|J^{D}_{\mu}|D(q)\rangle=iq_{\mu}F_{D} . The version for pions of ( 1 ) for chiral symmetry breaking is obtained by replacing F_{D}\to F_{\pi} , \langle D|\to\langle\pi^{a}| and J^{D}_{\mu}\to J^{5a}_{\mu}=\bar{q}T^{a}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}q . \langle 0|T_{\mu\nu}|D(q)\rangle=\frac{F_{D}}{d-1}(m_{D}^{2}\eta_{\mu\nu}-q_{\mu}q_{\nu})\;, (3) with \eta_{\mu\nu} (the mostly minus) Minkowski metric. The novel element lies in the application of the dilatation commutator to a primary operator i[Q_{D},{\cal O}(x)]=\frac{1}{F_{D}}(\Delta_{{\cal O}}+x\cdot\partial){\cal O}(x)\;, (4) for which x\cdot\partial\equiv x_{\mu}\partial^{\mu} and \Delta_{\cal O} express the transformation of the argument and the operator respectively. In ( 4 ) \Delta_{\cal O}=d_{\cal O}+\gamma_{\cal O} is known as the scaling dimension which differs from the engineering dimension by the anomalous part. In order to appreciate this aspect we first proceed to repeat the textbook derivation of ( 1 ) which starts by applying the Lehmann-Symmanzik-Zimmermann (LSZ) procedure \langle D(q)\alpha|{\cal O}(0)|\beta\rangle=\frac{i}{Z_{D}}\lim_{q^{2}\to m_{D}^{2}}(m_{D}^{2}-q^{2})\int d^{d}ze^{iq\cdot z}\langle\alpha|T\partial\cdot J^{D}(z){\cal O}(0)|\beta\rangle\;, (5) where \langle D|\partial\cdot J^{D}|0\rangle=Z_{D} serves as the interpolating operator for the dilaton. Next one considers the standard Ward identity \partial^{\mu}\langle\alpha|TJ^{D}_{\mu}(z){\cal O}(0)|\beta\rangle=\delta(z_{0})\langle\alpha|[J^{D}_{0}(z),{\cal O}(0)]|\beta\rangle+\langle\alpha|T\partial\cdot J^{D}(z){\cal O}(0)|\beta\rangle\;, (6) where the first term on the right corresponds to the symmetry transformation of the operator {\cal O} and the second one parameterises possible explicit or anomalous symmetry breaking. In the case of the pion the latter corresponds to the partially conserved axial current proportional to the pion mass (explicit breaking). We then substitute ( 6 ) into ( 5 ). Up to this point everything is exact. The soft theorem assumption is that the matrix element in ( 5 ) changes smoothly as the Goldstone is made soft q\to 0 . Proceeding one obtains the soft theorem ( 1 ) \langle D(q)\alpha|{\cal O}(0)|\beta\rangle=\lim_{q\to 0}\langle D(q)\beta|{\cal O}(0)|\alpha\rangle|_{\mbox{\eqref{eq:soft2}}}+{\cal O}(m^{2}_{D}/m^{2}_{\text{had}})\;, (7) with the commutator part originating from the first term in ( 6 ) and the remainder from the left-hand side of the same equation. The order {\cal O}(m^{2}_{D}/m^{2}_{\text{had}}) is the minimal consequence of taking the soft limit. Note that Eq. ( 7 ) gives meaning to the statement of an “off-shell matrix element". We now proceed to apply the soft theorem using ( 4 ) to the two special cases of one and two soft dilatons: \langle D|{\cal O}|0\rangle and \langle D|{\cal O}|D\rangle . Single-soft theorem: evaluating \langle D|{\cal O}|0\rangle is straightforward as the x -dependence in ( 4 ) drops out, one gets, with \langle{\cal O}\rangle\equiv\langle 0|{\cal O}|0\rangle , \langle D|{\cal O}|0\rangle=-\frac{1}{F_{D}}\Delta_{{\cal O}}\langle{\cal O}\rangle\;. (8) Double-soft theorem: the evaluation of \langle D(q)|{\cal O}|D(q^{\prime})\rangle is more subtle and one has to proceed step by step. Similarly, we get \langle D(q)|{\cal O}(x)|D(0)\rangle=-\frac{1}{F_{D}}(\Delta_{{\cal O}}+x\cdot\partial)\langle D(q)|{\cal O}(x)|0\rangle\;, (9) but this time the derivative cannot be neglected since \langle D(q)|{\cal O}(x)|0\rangle\propto e^{iq\cdot x} is x -dependent. To understand what to do one has to remember that operators have to be smeared {\cal O}_{h}=\int d^{d}x{\cal O}(x)h(x) , by test function h\in{\cal S}(\mathbb{R}^{d}) in Schwartz space (sufficiently fast fall off at infinity, e.g. h(x)=r^{n}e^{-|c|r^{2}} ). Taking this into account one finds \langle D|{\cal O}_{h}|D\rangle=1/F_{D}^{2}(\Delta_{{\cal O}}-d)\Delta_{\cal O}\langle{\cal O}_{h}\rangle , integrating by parts, and removing the test function this leads to our main formal result for the double-soft dilaton matrix element \boxed{\langle D|{\cal O}|D\rangle=\frac{1}{F_{D}^{2}}(\Delta_{{\cal O}}-d)\Delta_{\cal O}\langle{\cal O}\rangle}\;. (10) Whereas the single-soft theorem is standard, the double-soft theorem ( 10 ) is a new result [ 7 ] to the best of our knowledge. The derivation given here is more detailed than in that reference. In order to further refine results we consider the following two fundamental formulae F_{D}m_{D}^{2}=\langle D(q)|T^{\rho}_{\;\;\rho}|0\rangle\;,\quad 2m_{D}^{2}=\langle D(q)|T^{\rho}_{\;\;\rho}|D(q)\rangle\;, (11) where the first one follows from ( 3 ) and the second one follows from P_{\mu}=\int d^{d-1}xT_{\mu 0} . We may obtain valuable results by assuming that a single irrelevant ( \Delta_{{\cal O}}\leq d ) operator {\cal O}\subset T^{\rho}_{\;\;\rho} is responsible for generating the mass via the matrix elements in ( 11 ). First we note that the vacuum expectation value must be lower than the perturbative vacuum and thus negative \langle{\cal O}\rangle<0 . Applying the single- and double-soft theorem to ( 11 ) one immediately gets m_{D}^{2}=-\frac{1}{F_{D}^{2}}\Delta_{\cal O}\langle{\cal O}\rangle\;,\quad m_{D}^{2}=\frac{1}{2F_{D}^{2}}(\Delta_{{\cal O}}-d)\Delta_{\cal O}\langle{\cal O}\rangle\;, (12) from which the following conclusions can be drawn A) The d -term in ( 12 ) assures m_{D}^{2}>0 since {\cal O} is irrelevant ( \Delta_{\cal O}\leq d ). B) The two equation in ( 12 ) hold simultaneously if and only if \Delta_{\cal O}=d-2 . C) Assuming