What makes an entity salient in discourse?
Amir Zeldes, Jessica Lin · 2025
Read What makes an entity salient in discourse? by Amir Zeldes, Jessica Lin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16464.txt.
Introduction
Amir Zeldes and Jessica Lin ask what makes a person, thing, or place stand out in a text, in this 2025 paper. Some entities stay central while others fade at once, and the signals behind that difference are poorly understood. The authors measure salience in a graded way, by how worthy an entity is of mention in several summaries of the same text.
They test whether factors that predict prominence inside one sentence also work across a whole discourse. Across twenty-four genres of spoken and written English, they weigh grammar role, definiteness, entity type, position, and recurrence. Sentence-level signals carried over, but bent under entity-level factors like frequency and spread. No single factor ruled; structure and meaning features proved sturdier than word-form ones, and genre shifted the weights. The authors present salience as a joint product of local cues and global presence.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amir Zeldes, Jessica Lin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16464
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What makes an entity salient in discourse? Amir Zeldes, Jessica Lin Abstract Entities in discourse vary broadly in salience: main participants, objects and locations are noticeable and memorable, while tangential ones are less important and quickly forgotten, raising questions about how humans signal and infer relative salience. Using a graded operationalization of salience based on summary-worthiness in multiple summaries of a discourse, this paper explores data from 24 spoken and written genres of English to extract a multifactorial complex of overt and implicit linguistic cues, such as recurring subjecthood or definiteness, discourse relations and hierarchy across utterances, as well as pragmatic functional inferences based on genre and communicative intent. Tackling the question ‘how is the degree of salience expressed for each and every entity mentioned?’ our results show that while previous approaches to salience all correlate with our salience scores to some extent, no single generalization is without exceptions, and the phenomenon cuts across all levels of linguistic representation. 1 Introduction It is a truism that not all parts of a text are created equal: some parts are more central to the main message and other more tangential, some facts or participants mentioned are more memorable than others, and if we had to boil down a text to just a short summary, we would be more inclined to cut out some content while retaining what we feel is most important or salient in the text. While this proposition is probably uncontroversial, operationalizing any of the parts needed for studying it in detail certainly is: what are the ‘parts’ or a text, who are ‘the participants’, what does it mean to be memorable or salient and how would we reduce a text to its most important content in a consistent way? And if we could resolve all these issues, what could we learn about what drives salience in discourse? The goal of this paper is to answer the last question by first tackling these definitional challenges, and then examining a large amount of data on salience in different types of text. To foreshadow some of the directions we will pursue, this study will focus on entity terms, i.e. referring expressions, as possible ‘participants’ in a text (including humans, inanimate objects and even abstract notions), use hierarchically nested discourse units in the tradition of Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST, Mann and Thompson 1988 ) as minimal ‘parts’, and adopt a Computational Linguistics methodology using graded summary-worthiness as a metric for salience, which we will correlate with a range of properties that entity mentions can possess. Much previous work on salience, centrality or importance has identified a list of candidate properties that co-vary with salience (see Fillmore 1977 for an early overview): salient entities are often expressed as grammatical subjects ( Tomlin and Myachykov 2019 ) , tend to refer to animate, or more specifically human participants ( Prat-Sala and Branigan 2000 ) , are more often realized as pronouns ( Kaiser 2005 ) or other definite or information structurally given expressions ( Chiarcos 2011 ) , appear earlier in sentences ( Whiteley 2024 ) , and may be less predictable or evoke higher levels of surprisal ( Zarcone et al. 2016 ) . For example, a sentence like 1 might be typical in a story about some kids, while the more unusual sounding 1 would fit better if the time and place i.e. ‘the park’ and ‘5 p.m.’ are salient topics in the discourse, for example because they relate to an alibi question. \ex . The kids played with a ball in a park next to some trees until 5 p.m. \ex . In the park, 5 p.m. was the time when some kids played ball next to some trees. These examples make it plausible that the aforementioned factors can matter and shape how language in context is expressed: to align with the salience of a time expression like ‘5 p.m.’ we might choose to express it early in the sentence, make it the grammatical subject, etc. However beyond these intuitions, many of the postulated univariate correlations between salience and animacy, subjecthood, definiteness, discourse structure and more, have relied primarily on either non-quantifiable introspective approaches, or on experimental evidence using artificial stimuli and definitions of salience that cannot be applied consistently to language ‘in the wild’. The smaller subset of corpus studies in this area have often suffered from less robust and sometimes circular definitions of salience based on textual criteria that correlate with the linguistic variables of interest, and have never explored language across a broad range of text types. In this paper we aim to close these gaps by providing a clearly defined operationalization of salience that is explicitly extra-textual and applicable to any kind of text type , which is crucial since many of the factors connected with salience in previous studies actually vary broadly with genre. We take a corpus-based approach rooted in definitions of salience as it is understood in Computational and Psycholinguistics literature, seeking to identify the most important, meaningful and memorable parts of given language data, in ways that generalize to a broad range of written and spoken text types in English. The main contributions of this paper are: – We propose a graded, extra-textual operationalization of salience grounded in summary-worthiness, which enables fine-grained modeling of entity prominence across a broad range of genres. – We present the first comprehensive analysis of entity salience using richly annotated corpus data spanning both written and spoken English, including referential structure, discourse structure, and morphosyntactic features. – We develop and evaluate interpretable regression models and other predictive machine learning models that identify the most robust indicators of salience and generalize well to out-of-domain text types. To guide our investigation, we ask the following research questions: 1. What linguistic and discourse-level properties shape the graded salience of discourse entities? 2. How do these properties interact across genres? 3. To what extent can corpus-based models of salience generalize across diverse discourse types, and what do their errors reveal about the nature of the phenomenon in context when they fail? 2 Defining salience 2.1 Non-computational approaches Boswijk and Coler 2020 offer a meta-review of salience definitions in Linguistics, divided into papers in Sociolinguistics, Second Language Acquisition (SLA), Cognitive Linguistics and Semantics, which diverge somewhat from the sense of salience we target here, and will therefore be summarized only briefly. In Sociolinguistics, salience has referred primarily to social indexation of linguistic features that attain the status of Labovian markers (i.e. features overtly indexing sociolinguistic properties that listeners are aware of), as opposed to variationist indicators, which non-linguist listeners are unaware of ( Labov 2007 ) , and more generally to the notion of Markedness ( Rácz 2013 ) , i.e. forms that deviate from default choices to signal social categories. By contrast, distinguishes between bottom-up and top-down salience. Bottom-up salience arises from intrinsic properties of an item, such as perceptual prominence or distinctiveness that make it stand out, often due to low predictability (i.e., it is surprising in context). Top-down salience, on the other hand, is driven by external contextual factors that increase an item’s expectedness, such as the perceiver’s goals, task relevance, or recent experience ( Zarcone et al. 2016 ) .