The (C)omprehensive (A)rchitecture (P)attern (I)ntegration method: Navigating the sea of technology
Sebastian Copei, Oliver Hohlfeld, Jens Kosiol · 2025
Read The (C)omprehensive (A)rchitecture (P)attern (I)ntegration method: Navigating the sea of technology by Sebastian Copei, Oliver Hohlfeld, Jens Kosiol (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-16341.txt.
Introduction
Sebastian Copei, Oliver Hohlfeld, and Jens Kosiol built a guide in 2025 to help software teams pick system designs amid a flood of tools. No one person can track every trend, and wrong early choices are costly in big projects. Their method, CAPI, asks questions in a branching tree and suggests design patterns, not products.
Since each pattern rules whole tool families in or out, the choice space shrinks fast. The team refined the guide in small studies with students, then tested it with industry users. They found that tool picking today runs mostly on trial and error. Users judged the guide helpful across the board. It also rebuilt the working setups of the firms that took part, a sign its advice matches sound practice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sebastian Copei, Oliver Hohlfeld, Jens Kosiol |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-16341
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The (C)omprehensive (A)rchitecture (P)attern (I)ntegration method: Navigating the sea of technology Sebastian Copei, Oliver Hohlfeld, Jens Kosiol Abstract The technological landscape changes daily, making it nearly impossible for a single person to be aware of all trends or available tools that may or may not be suitable for their software project. This makes tool selection and architectural design decisions a complex problem, especially for large-scale software systems. To tackle this issue, we introduce CAPI, the Comprehensive Architecture Pattern Integration method that uses a diagnostic decision tree to suggest architectural patterns depending on user needs. By suggesting patterns instead of tools, the overall complexity for further decisions is lower as there are fewer architectural patterns than tools due to the abstract nature of patterns. Moreover, since tools implement patterns, each non-proposed pattern reduces the number of tools to choose from, reducing complexity. We iteratively developed CAPI, evaluating its understandability and usability in small studies with academic participants. When satisfied with the outcome, we performed a user-study with industry representatives to investigate the state-of-the-art in technology selection and the effectiveness of our proposed method. We find that technology selection is largely performed via trial and error, that CAPI is uniformly perceived as helpful, and that CAPI is able to reproduce the productive architectural environments of our participants. 1 Introduction The trend towards developing software as a (web) service promotes the creation of (large-scale) distributed systems, thereby increasing the complexity of software architectures. Due to the complexity and scale of these systems, they are often implemented as microservice architecture and by using agile methods and DevOps organizational practices, such as CI pipelines, that enable teams to organize efficiently. To facilitate the development of these systems, a wide range of software frameworks has emerged (e.g., as illustrated in the Cloud Native Landscape atlas). These frameworks address the implementation of individual design patterns, such as API gateways, databases, and message brokers, to help simplify the developers’ work in building their systems. Despite the chosen software development methods, previous work highlights significant challenges and barriers in developing large-scale systems. Commonly cited issues include a lack of collaboration and communication, insufficient skills and knowledge, and ineffective criticism practices [ 9 , 6 , 10 ] . Additionally, as we will show in this paper, developers face challenges in selecting software frameworks. This issue primarily arises from the overwhelming number of frameworks that implement similar design patterns (e.g., message brokers) and the rapidly evolving software landscape. In this paper, we tackle the challenge of navigating the complex landscape of software development by simplifying the process for developers to choose design patterns for large-scale software as a service projects. Rather than recommending tools that frequently change, our approach focuses on selecting the fundamental architectural design patterns that these tools implement. This results in a more manageable set of tools, making it easier for developers to make selections in a subsequent step. These design patterns are foundational for building scalable software architectures, and making an informed choice is a crucial aspect of software architecture design. Therefore, selecting the appropriate architectural design pattern is a critical step in the software architecture process. To assist in this selection, this paper introduces the Comprehensive Architecture Pattern Integration (CAPI) method, driven by a decision tree. To better address the needs of developers and architects, we will i) survey their requirements and ii) assess our CAPI method through interviews with industry practitioners. This way, we aim to answer the following research questions: RQ1 How do practitioners select software architectures for their projects? RQ2 What problems do the practitioners face during this process? RQ3 How does the CAPI method help industry practitioners select better software architectural designs more easily? We evaluate the CAPI method in interviews with industry practitioners and show that it addresses a need. Our contributions are as follows. • We show that there is lack of approaches that guide the selection of software architectural designs in modern software projects. • We contribute the CAPI method, which enables software architects to select the appropriate architectural design pattern for realizing a given software. The CAPI method is realized as a decision tree with questions that guide the design pattern selection process. The CAPI method covers the current architecture designs, with a focus on microservices as the emerging implementation approach. • We evaluate the CAPI method with industry practitioners and show that it solves a technology selection problem that industry practitioners face. Our interviews highlight that our method is perceived as a useful approach in situations where software design patterns need to be selected. Structure In Section 2 , we describe the related work. In Section 3 , we introduce the CAPI method. In Section 4 , we review our qualitative study, and in Section 5 , we discuss the results. Finally, Section 6 summarizes our work and briefly describes our next steps. 2 Related Work Architectural design selection. Regarding architecture selection, there is a range of studies that investigate the relation between architectural patterns and quality attributes of the resulting system [ 7 , 12 , 5 , 8 , 13 ] ; Haoues et al. [ 5 ] even derive a decision model where a foundational architectural design decision is suggested depending on quality attributes one wants to focus on. However, their systems addresses the foundational style of architecture to be used in a system (model-driven architecture, component-based architecture, service-oriented architecture, event-driven architecture, aspect-oriented architecture), whereas we are interested in helping users to decide which of the plethora of patterns to use that have been suggested in connection with modern, often cloud-based development. In particular for component-based architectures, approaches exist to automatically optimize an architectural design, given as a Palladio component model [ 11 , 1 ] . Razzaq extracts patterns for microservice development from the literature and maps these to common problems in IoT development they can help to solve [ 14 ] . Decision support systems (DSS) for technology selection have also been developed in other contexts, e.g., for database technologies [ 15 ] . Finally, in the paper most similar to ours, Farshidi and Jansen develop a DSS that supports the decision-making process for pattern-driven software architecture [ 4 ] . Whereas our method relies on a decision tree fueled by diagnostic questions, the DSS mentioned in the publication uses a list of definable requirements prioritized by the Must have, Should have, Could have, and Won’t have (MoSCoW) technique to determine fitting patterns. The authors use an inference engine to generate a list of patterns that fulfill the requirements. Similar to our approach, the authors extract the patterns used in their method from a literature review. In total, the authors used 29 patterns with 40 features. From this set, the inference engine can list fitting patterns depending on the features that will fulfill a requirement. Our method uses a set of 47 patterns and creates a result set due to a decision tree instead of an inference engine. In comparison, the DSS and our method share four patterns, meaning there are 25 patterns we are not including and 44 they do not include. We explain these deviations with the methodology of the literature reviews performed beforehand. Nevertheless, from this deviation, we