Gravitational Waves and Cosmological Observables from First-Order Phase Transitions: Thermal Corrections at Low Temperature

Katharena Christy, James B. Dent, Sumit Ghosh, Jason Kumar, and J. O’Thello Ward · 2025

Read Gravitational Waves and Cosmological Observables from First-Order Phase Transitions: Thermal Corrections at Low Temperature by Katharena Christy, James B. Dent, Sumit Ghosh, Jason Kumar, and J. O’Thello Ward (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15918.txt.

Introduction

Christy, Dent, Ghosh, Kumar, and Ward study thermal corrections at low temperature in phase transitions of the early cosmos, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. First-order transitions in the early universe send out gravitational waves. Heavy particles can shift the effective potential in subtle ways when it is cold. Their focus is the thin-wall regime, where the vacuum structure stays as it was.

In this limit, all such corrections are modeled by one new parameter. Shifts in the values that mark the transition follow from that single quantity. Gravitational wave signals and other things we can observe shift in step. The shortcut covers tangled forms of correction in one even way. Builders of models gain a quick tool for a first estimate.

Catalog record

CREATORKatharena Christy, James B. Dent, Sumit Ghosh, Jason Kumar, and J. O’Thello Ward
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15918

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gravitational Waves and Cosmological Observables from First-Order Phase Transitions: Thermal Corrections at Low Temperature Katharena Christy, James B. Dent, Sumit Ghosh, Jason Kumar, and J. O’Thello Ward Abstract We consider the impact on cosmological first-order phase transitions (FOPTs) of low-temperature thermal corrections to the effective potential. These are corrections from degrees of freedom whose field-dependent masses are much smaller than the nucleation temperature in the true vacuum, though they may be much larger than the nucleation temperature in the false vacuum. Although the general form of these corrections to the thermal effective potential can be quite complicated, we argue that the net effect of all such corrections can be well-modeled with a single new parameter. We determine the shift in the parameters of the FOPT in terms of this new parameter, and the impact on gravitational wave signals and cosmological observables. 1 Introduction Cosmological first-order phase transitions (FOPTs) in the early Universe can be a source of gravitational waves Kosowsky:1992rz ; Kosowsky:1992vn ; Apreda:2001us ; Grojean:2006bp ; Huber:2008hg ; Weir:2017wfa ; Caprini:2015zlo ; Mazumdar:2018dfl ; Hindmarsh:2020hop ; Caldwell:2022qsj ; Athron:2023xlk ; Croon:2023zay ; Caprini:2024hue ; Croon:2024mde . The amplitude and frequency of this signal, if observed, can provide information about fundamental physics parameters of the underlying Lagrangian. A variety of gravitational wave observatories are operating, or in development, which can potentially observe such signals, and provide a window into fundamental physics in the early Universe, beyond the Standard Model (BSM) KAGRA:2021duu ; LISA:2024hlh ; NANOGrav:2023gor ; EPTA:2023fyk ; Antoniadis:2022pcn ; Xu:2023wog ; Abac:2025saz ; Evans:2023euw ; Sesana:2019vho ; Komori:2025pjx ; Corbin:2005ny ; Weltman:2018zrl ; Garcia-Bellido:2021zgu ; Bertoldi:2021rqk ; MAGIS-100:2021etm ; Ackley:2020atn . In addition, FOPTs can alter cosmological observables in a manner which can also be probed by astrophysical observatories, for example by releasing dark radiation in the form of latent heat. However, a key requirement for these types of studies is understanding the effect of thermal corrections to the effective potential. It is these thermal corrections which lead to a universe which is in a false vacuum at early times, when the temperature is high, but transitions to the true vacuum with subsequent cosmological evolution to the current epoch. There is a large body of work focused on the detailed technical considerations underlying the thermal corrections to any particular fundamental Lagrangian Laine:2016hma ; Croon:2020cgk ; Postma:2020toi ; Gould:2021dzl ; Schicho:2021gca ; Guo:2021qcq ; Gould:2021oba ; Schicho:2022wty ; Lofgren:2023sep ; Gould:2023ovu ; Lewicki:2024xan ; Chala:2024xll ; Chakrabortty:2024wto ; Navarrete:2025yxy ; Ekstedt:2024etx . But we adopt a different approach here, by considering the general form of thermal corrections which arise from a broad class of fundamental Lagrangians. By parameterizing the form of these thermal corrections, we can generally relate the effective potential thermal corrections to the thermal properties of the first-order phase transition, and in turn to the gravitational wave signal. This will yield a type of ‘dictionary’ relating thermal corrections arising from any type of new physics to changes in the frequency and amplitude of the gravitational wave signal arising at the phase transition. In previous work Dent:2022bcd , a few of the present authors considered the scenario of a quartic scalar potential with high-temperature thermal corrections arising from degrees of freedom whose effective mass is small compared to the temperature. However, there will generally be another class of thermal corrections arising from heavy degrees of freedom. Although these low-temperature thermal corrections are generally Boltzmann-suppressed, there may be many heavy degrees of freedom which are integrated out, yielding a nontrivial contribution to the thermal effective potential. Moreover, although these corrections may be Boltzmann-suppressed in the true vacuum, they may not be Boltzmann-suppressed in the false vacuum, thus yielding a nontrivial impact on the phase transition. Since one cannot calculate the exact thermal corrections without knowing exactly what heavy degrees of freedom are integrated out, our goal will be to parameterize the form of the low-temperature thermal corrections, and to determine how they generally alter the gravitational wave signal and other cosmological observables arising from the phase transition. Indeed, we will find that the corrections to the thermal parameters of the phase transition can be simply parameterized in terms of the uncorrected thermal parameters and a single additional parameter controlling the size of the low-temperature corrections. The plan of this paper is as follows. In Section 2 , we describe the general form of the thermal corrections in the low temperature limit, and obtain a simple parameterization. In Section 3 , we obtain an analytic approximation describing the effect of these corrections on the thermal parameters of the first order phase transition. In Section 4 , we validate this analytic approximation with a numerical analysis, using the CosmoTransitions package Wainwright:2011kj . We conclude in Section 5 . 2 Low-Temperature Thermal Corrections to the Effective Potential We will examine the case of a single scalar field \phi whose perturbative potential is of the form \displaystyle V(\phi,T)=V_{0}(\phi,0)+V_{CW}(\phi,0)+V_{T}(\phi,T) (1) where V_{0}(\phi,0 ) is the zero-temperature tree-level potential, V_{CW}(\phi,0) is the one-loop zero-temperature potential of the Coleman-Weinberg form, and V_{T}(\phi,T) is the thermal part of the one-loop potential. For concreteness, we will focus on the case in which the tree-level zero-temperature potential is quartic, with a \phi\rightarrow-\phi symmetry: \displaystyle V_{0}(\phi,0) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\Lambda^{4}\left[-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\phi}{v}\right)^{2}+\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{\phi}{v}\right)^{4}\right], (2) where the global minimum of the zero-temperature potential is \phi=\pm v . For simplicity, we will assume that the zero-temperature Coleman-Weinberg potential V_{CW}(\phi,0) does not qualitatively affect the vacuum structure, and can be ignored. But we emphasize that our general results will not depend on these assumptions. We would like to construct thermal corrections to the effective potential that accurately capture the physics of both the high-temperature and low-temperature regimes. Consider a degree of freedom, \eta (bosonic or fermionic), which will be integrated out. The expression for the corresponding contribution to the thermal effective potential for \phi is given by (see, for example, Quiros:1999jp ; Croon:2020cgk ) \displaystyle V_{T}(\phi,T)=-T\int\frac{d^{3}p}{(2\pi)^{3}}\ln(1\pm n_{B,F}(E_{p},T)), (3) where the plus (minus) sign above is used for a boson (fermion), n_{B,F}(E_{p},T)=\left[\exp(E_{p}/T)\mp 1\right]^{-1} , E_{p}=\sqrt{p^{2}+m^{2}(\phi)} , and m(\phi) is the field-dependent effective mass of \eta (for example, if \eta is a real boson, then m^{2}(\phi)=\partial^{2}{\cal L}/\partial\eta^{2} evaluated at \eta=0 .). The contribution to the thermal effective potential from a single degree of freedom can be approximated in the high-temperature limit x\equiv m(\phi)/T\ll 1 as Morrissey:2012db \displaystyle\Delta V_{B}(\phi,T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{T^{4}}{2\pi^{2}}\left[-\frac{\pi^{4}}{45}+\frac{\pi^{2}}{12}x^{2}-\frac{\pi}{6}x^{3}-\frac{1}{32}x^{4}\ln(x^{2}/a_{b})+....\right], \displaystyle\Delta V_{F}(\phi,T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\frac{T^{4}}{2\pi^{2}}\left[-\frac{7\pi^{4}}{360}+\frac{\pi^{2}}{24}x^{2}+\frac{1}{32}x^{4}\ln(x^{2}/a_{f})+....\right], (4) ( \ln(a_{b})\sim 5.4076 , \ln(a_{f})\sim 2.6351 ) and can be given in the low-temperature limit ( x\gg 1 ) as Morrissey:2012db \displaystyle\Delta V_{B,F}(\phi,T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\pm\left(\frac{x}{2\pi}\right)^{3/2}e^{-x}\left(1+\frac{15}{8x}+{\cal O}(x^{-2})\right). (5) In typical examples, one finds that the field-dependent contributions to the mass are \propto\phi , since the fields which contribute typically are massless in the symmetry-preserving vacuum. In the high- T limit, then, the dominant thermal corrections to the effective potential are proportional to \phi^{2}T^{2} and \phi^{3}T . The term proportional to T^{4} is \phi -independent, and can be ignored because it does not affect the phase transition. The log term has only a logarithmic dependence on temperature, and can be combined with the zero-temperature Coleman-Weinberg potential Quiros:1999jp ; Croon:2018erz . Adding these high-temperature thermal corrections, we can write the thermal effective potential as Croon:2018erz \displaystyle V_{high}(\phi,T) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\Lambda^{4}\left[\left(-\frac{1}{2}+c\left(\frac{T}{v}\right)^{2}\right)\left(\frac{\phi}{v}\right)^{2}+b\frac{T}{v}\left(\frac{\phi}{v}\right)^{3}+\frac{1}{4}\left(\frac{\phi}{v}\right)^{4}\right], (6) where the coefficients b<0 and c depend on the

Read the complete text