Robustness of Solutions of the Quantum Kinetic Equations in the Presence of Matter Density Fluctuations
and Mariam Gogilashvili · 2025
Read Robustness of Solutions of the Quantum Kinetic Equations in the Presence of Matter Density Fluctuations by and Mariam Gogilashvili (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15747.txt.
Introduction
Shashank Shalgar and Mariam Gogilashvili study how neutrinos change flavor in dense matter in this 2025 paper. Neutrinos are tiny particles that can switch type as they travel, and stars hold huge numbers of them. The team solves a set of quantum kinetic equations that track this change, and asks whether bumps in matter density can upset the results.
The authors ran the equations at three grid sizes and found the answers nearly the same even on the coarse grid. They then added random bumps to the density, both steady and changing in time, and watched the flavor mix. The bumps caused no real instability and only small shifts in particle counts and energy spread. The finding suggests that density noise of this kind can be set aside in round, even models of neutrino flow.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | and Mariam Gogilashvili |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15747
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Robustness of Solutions of the Quantum Kinetic Equations in the Presence of Matter Density Fluctuations and Mariam Gogilashvili Abstract We investigate the role of fluctuations in the matter density on neutrino flavor evolution by studying their effects on the collision terms in the spherically symmetric quantum kinetics equations (QKEs). We solve the QKEs with varying radial resolution ( r bins = 150 , 1500 , 15000 r_{\mathrm{bins}}=150\,,1500\,,15000 ) to assess numerical convergence in angular distributions, number densities, and energy spectra for four neutrino flavors ( ν e \nu_{e} , ν ¯ e \bar{\nu}_{e} , ν x \nu_{x} , ν ¯ x \bar{\nu}_{x} ). Our results demonstrate that the solutions are numerically converged already at the coarsest resolution, with higher resolutions yielding almost identical outcomes. We introduce random perturbations to each radial bin, thus adding perturbations with a length scale that is related to the radial resolution. We study both time-independent and time-dependent perturbations to the matter density that affect the collision term and analyze their effects on neutrino flavor evolution. We find that such fluctuations do not induce any significant instabilities or qualitative changes in flavor evolution. Angular structure remains robust, and flavor-dependent number densities and energy spectra show only minor deviations compared to the unperturbed case. These findings suggest that matter perturbations have a negligible effect on neutrino flavor evolution in spherically symmetric settings. 1 Introduction Core-collapse supernovae (CCSNe) are among the most energetic events in the universe, powered largely by the intense neutrino flux emitted during stellar collapse and the subsequent cooling of the proto-neutron star. Neutrinos carry away the vast majority of the gravitational binding energy and play a central role in the dynamics of the explosion and in setting the conditions for nucleosynthesis [ 1 , 2 ] . Despite decades of research [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 ] , the exact role of neutrinos in powering the explosion remains an open question, particularly when it comes to the effects of flavor evolution [ 10 , 11 ] . In regions of high neutrino density, the coherent forward scattering of neutrinos due to other neutrinos in the medium cannot be ignored [ 12 , 13 , 11 ] . Although the neutrino number density is the largest in the core of the proto-neutron star, the existence of flavor instabilities also depends on the angular distributions and favorable lepton numbers. In the regions of neutrino decoupling, conditions are the most favorable for flavor instability due to neutrino self-interactions that can lead to collective effects. These interactions render the flavor evolution problem inherently non-linear, giving rise to a variety of instabilities and oscillation modes. The behavior of neutrinos under these conditions is governed by the quantum kinetic equations (QKEs), which encapsulate both coherent flavor oscillations and inelastic scattering processes [ 14 ] . A defining feature of flavor evolution in dense media is the emergence of collective effects [ 15 ] . Depending on the dominant physical scale, different regimes can arise—slow collective oscillations that depend on the vacuum mixing parameters [ 11 , 15 ] , fast flavor conversions (FFC) driven by electron lepton number (ELN) angular crossings [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] , and collisional flavor instabilities (CFI) [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] arising from interactions with the dense medium. These effects are deeply sensitive to local conditions, such as the angular structure of neutrino emission and the degree of anisotropy. While the impact of neutrino heating has been incorporated in state-of-the-art CCSN simulations [ 25 , 26 ] , flavor-changing processes are often ignored or simplified by assuming flavor conservation. Such simplifications could miss important feedback, since changes in the flavor composition alter neutrino energy and angular spectra, affecting both shock revival and the neutron-to-proton ratio relevant for nucleosynthesis [ 27 , 19 ] . Accurately incorporating neutrino flavor evolution in multi-dimensional CCSN simulations presents a major computational challenge. Typically, the numerical solutions of QKEs require orders of magnitude more computational resources compared to the simplified classical transport schemes, such as M1 or the neutrino leakage scheme, or even the full Boltzmann solution. It should be noted that the neutrino transport is one of the most expensive parts of the hydrodynamical simulations of CCSN. Incorporating solutions of QKEs in multi-dimensional simulations is not yet feasible. Nevertheless, progress can be made by solving the QKEs in simplified frameworks or localized regions within simulations [ 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 ] . Such approaches allow us to probe the qualitative behavior, investigate the conditions under which various flavor instabilities arise, and assess their effects on neutrino spectra. More importantly, these studies can reveal whether flavor equilibration, where different neutrino species approach similar angular or spectral distributions, is a generic outcome of flavor evolution. However, such simulations do not take into account the feedback of neutrino flavor evolution on the hydrodynamic evolution. Including this feedback is a very challenging task and one of the major goals for the future. In this work, we focus on neutrino flavor evolution in spherical symmetry and investigate the robustness of quantum kinetic equation solutions to matter fluctuations during the accretion phase of a core-collapse supernova. Using post-bounce profiles from one-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations of an 18.6M_{\odot} progenitor [ 35 ] , we introduce both time-independent and time-dependent matter fluctuations to assess their impact on flavor evolution. This result is in agreement with the conclusions of a previous study that looked at the effect of perturbations by adding fluctuations to the neutrino gas itself in an ad hoc manner [ 36 ] . Our results show that the solutions to the QKEs remain remarkably stable and insensitive to such fluctuations. Furthermore, we performed a resolution study using radial grids with 150, 1500, and 15000 bins, and found excellent agreement across all three cases, demonstrating that even relatively coarse radial resolution captures the essential flavor dynamics. The paper is structured as follows: in Section 2 , we discuss the spherically symmetric physical model. Then in Section 2.2 we study matter fluctuations and the sensitivity of the QKEs to these fluctuations. In particular, we first discuss time-independent fluctuations in Section 2.2.1 . Then, time-dependent fluctuations in Section 2.2.2 . We show the results and robustness of the solutions of the QKEs in Section 4 . In Section 3 we describe the simulation setup. In Section 3.1 , we present the numerical convergence of the solutions of QKEs for three different radial resolutions. Finally, in Section 5 we discuss and summarize the main results and future prospects. 2 Physical Model 2.1 Spherically Symmetric Approximation To model neutrino flavor evolution in core-collapse supernovae, we follow [ 37 ] and solve QKEs under the assumption of spherical symmetry. We consider four neutrino flavors: \nu_{e} , \bar{\nu}_{e} , \nu_{x} , \bar{\nu}_{x} , where \nu_{x} and \bar{\nu}_{x} represent characteristic heavy neutrino and antineutrino respectively. The neutrino ensemble is described by 2\times 2 Hermitian density matrices, \rho and \bar{\rho} , which are the function of radius r , polar angle \theta , neutrino energy E , and time t . The diagonal elements of the