Energy conditions for regular black holes in EFT of gravity
Ziyue Zhu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Yang Liu, Anna Tokareva · 2025
Read Energy conditions for regular black holes in EFT of gravity by Ziyue Zhu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Yang Liu, Anna Tokareva (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15745.txt.
Introduction
Ziyue Zhu and co-authors ask whether black holes without a crushing center can exist in this 2025 paper. Einstein's gravity works only below extreme energies, so it needs extra correction terms at the wildest scales. Ordinary black holes hide a singularity where all theories break.
With matter present and the corrections counted, the team tests so-called regular black holes, which look normal outside but stay smooth inside. Energy conditions, the rules matter should obey, are their yardstick. They show what matter spread could support such an object under cubic and quartic corrections. The work probes whether nature allows black holes without the impossible point.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ziyue Zhu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Yang Liu, Anna Tokareva |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15745
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Energy conditions for regular black holes in EFT of gravity Ziyue Zhu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Yang Liu, Anna Tokareva Abstract As Einstein’s gravity is a non-renormalizable theory, it can be a good description of physics only at the scales of energy or spacetime curvature below the Planck mass. Moreover, it requires the presence of an infinite tower of higher-derivative corrections, as required in the framework of effective field theory (EFT). Black holes, known to be vacuum solutions in Einstein’s gravity, necessarily have singularities in the center, where both Einstein’s gravity and low-energy EFT expansions break down. In this work, we address the question of whether, in the presence of matter, regular solutions looking like black holes from outside do exist. We show that the matter distribution supporting the regular black hole solution in the presence of Riemann tensor cube and Riemann tensor to the fourth power EFT corrections satisfies positivity of energy (also called weak energy condition, WEC) and null energy condition (NEC) everywhere outside the horizon. Unlike the case of singular solutions, the EFT description is also valid in the interior of such an object, given that the maximal curvature is bounded and does not exceed the cut-off scale. We found that in a wide range of parameters, WEC is satisfied inside the horizon, but NEC is violated inside the horizon in all cases. I Introduction Black holes (BH) are perhaps the most puzzling objects found upon studying Einstein’s General Relativity (GR) Wald 1984 . Schwarzschild metric Schwarzschild 1916 is the very first celebrated solution to GR equations of motion describing a BH — a static compact centrally symmetric massive object with an event horizon in an empty space. This metric has neatly described the Mercury perihelion displacement but has also brought to life the problem of a BH singularity. By singularity, we mean a point or a region in the space-time where a metric or a curvature is either singular or non-differentiable a required number of times Kerr 2023 . Indeed, the Riemann tensor and the corresponding scalar invariants evaluated on the Schwarzschild metric are singular at the center of a BH. The appearance of singularities can naturally be related to the fact that GR, while being perfect for describing IR gravity effects, is not UV complete and thus fails at high energies. It is therefore a wishful expectation that a complete gravity theory avoids singularities, including the BH ones Koshelev and Tokareva 2025 . Constructing a non-perturbative gravity theory appears to be an extremely difficult problem that has captured huge efforts of many top-notch scientists for a century without a satisfactory outcome yet. However, this problem can be attacked via a bottom-up approach in the framework of an effective field theory (EFT) of gravity. EFT of gravity can be constructed by adding to the original Lagrangian of GR new terms containing higher curvature corrections. They appear as counterterms required to cancel loop divergences in GR, however, as GR is non-renormalizable, one needs an infinite number of them. A Riemann curvature factor is equivalent to a two-derivative operator, and thus higher curvature terms can probe higher energy regimes. One can straightforwardly add terms cubic and quartic in the Riemann tensor Ruhdorfer et al. 2020 . 1 1 1 Note that quadratic in curvature terms can be removed by a field redefinition. An interesting question about how vacuum BH solutions of GR get modified within the EFT approach has been widely studied Boyce and Santos 2025 ; Melville 2024 ; Cano et al. 2020 ; Saraswat 2017 ; Chen et al. 2025 ; Barbosa et al. 2025 ; Kats et al. 2007 . This, unfortunately, does not give an immediate insight into how a singularity problem can be resolved. The EFT corrections to the BH solutions are typically also singular; however, EFT breaks down near the singularity, so a complete theory of gravity is required in order to answer the question about the presence of a singularity in the center of a black hole. The other possible path is to start by guessing about possible regular BH solutions. Several interesting proposals of regular BH-s have been developed Bardeen 1968 ; Frolov et al. 1990 ; Dymnikova 1992 ; Ayon-Beato and Garcia 1998 ; Bonanno and Reuter 2000 ; Bronnikov 2001 ; Hayward 2006 ; Saini and Stojkovic 2014 ; Alencar et al. 2023 ; Ansoldi 2008 ; Aguayo et al. 2025 (see Lan et al. 2023a for a review). Such solutions were mainly constructed in a framework of GR. They are not vacuum solutions, and an extra matter content needs to be added. In general, regular BH-s prompt a very important question of how their interior is organized. The Hawking-Penrose theorems Penrose 1965 ; Hawking 1972 suggest that the presence of an event horizon leads to a singularity. To circumvent this statement, one has to modify the BH interior, for example, by allowing for an inner horizon. This, in turn, may lead to other problems, including the so-called mass inflation Visser 2024 ; Gao and Sake 2025 ; Brown et al. 2011 which is, in general, not easy to avoid. Moreover, adding extra matter requires checking that various reasonable energy conditions Zaslavskii 2010 ; Neves and Saa 2014 ; Lan et al. 2023b are satisfied. In the present paper, we combine the idea of the EFT of gravity and the construction of regular BH-s. Namely, we are going to embed regular BH candidate metrics in the EFT of gravity models. In particular, we consider cubic and quartic in Riemann tensor terms. We do not include parity-violating terms. Since the candidate metrics are not exact vacuum solutions, extra matter is required to validate these solutions. The idea of this work is to establish conditions on EFT coefficients such that matter-energy conditions are satisfied. These conditions may depend on how the interior of a BH is regularized, and thus different regular solutions have to be considered. Having a vacuum solution without extra matter is a nice goal that is beyond the scope of the present paper. The complexity of the field equations does not allow for constructing such solutions beyond the perturbative approach, which is commonly used in the EFT of gravity and is known to provide only singular solutions. The latter are not complete, as they predict the breakdown of EFT near the center of the black hole. The main goal of this paper is to construct a regular solution with finite maximal curvature that can be fully described within the regime of validity of EFT. We check whether this is possible with matter satisfying at least the weak energy condition both inside and outside the outer horizon of a refular BH. The paper is organized as follows. In Section II we introduce the model to be examined in the rest of the paper. In Section III we study constraints on suggested regular BH solutions coming from EFT considerations. In Section IV we study constraints originating from the viability of the matter content needed to support BH configurations in question. In Section V we put concluding remarks and formulate problems for future study directions. Appendix contains explicit expressions used for producing plots presented in the main text. II The setup