Lattice distortions and non-sluggish diffusion in BCC refractory high entropy alloys

Jingfeng Zhang, Xiang Xu, Fritz K o ¨ \rm{\ddot{o}} rmann, Wen Yin, Xi Zhang, Christian Gadelmeier, Uwe Glatzel, Blazej Grabowski, Runxia Li*, Gang Liu, Biao Wang, Gerhard Wilde, Sergiy V. Divinski* · 2025

Read Lattice distortions and non-sluggish diffusion in BCC refractory high entropy alloys by Jingfeng Zhang, Xiang Xu, Fritz K o ¨ \rm{\ddot{o}} rmann, Wen Yin, Xi Zhang, Christian Gadelmeier, Uwe Glatzel, Blazej Grabowski, Runxia Li*, Gang Liu, Biao Wang, Gerhard Wilde, Sergiy V. Divinski* (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15558.txt.

Introduction

The authors measure in 2025 how fast atoms wander inside two refractory high entropy alloys, and whether the wander is truly sluggish as folklore claims. Such alloys, built from many metals that resist heat, are candidates for turbines and reactors. How atoms diffuse inside them governs creep and stability at high temperature.

The team tracked radioactive tracer atoms of cobalt, manganese, and zinc through single phase samples of the two alloys. Neutron scattering measured how far each kind of atom sits from its ideal lattice spot. Pairing those distortions with the diffusion speeds tests the sluggish story. The title gives the verdict away: diffusion is not sluggish here. Design rules for hot section alloys must rest on measured rates, not slogans.

Catalog record

CREATORJingfeng Zhang, Xiang Xu, Fritz K o ¨ \rm{\ddot{o}} rmann, Wen Yin, Xi Zhang, Christian Gadelmeier, Uwe Glatzel, Blazej Grabowski, Runxia Li*, Gang Liu, Biao Wang, Gerhard Wilde, Sergiy V. Divinski*
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15558

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Lattice distortions and non-sluggish diffusion in BCC refractory high entropy alloys Jingfeng Zhang, Xiang Xu, Fritz K o ¨ \rm{\ddot{o}} rmann, Wen Yin, Xi Zhang, Christian Gadelmeier, Uwe Glatzel, Blazej Grabowski, Runxia Li*, Gang Liu, Biao Wang, Gerhard Wilde, Sergiy V. Divinski* Abstract Refractory high-entropy alloys (RHEAs) have emerged as promising candidates for extreme high-temperature applications, for example, in next-generation turbines and nuclear reactors. In such applications, atomic diffusion critically governs essential properties including creep resistance and microstructural stability. The present study systematically investigates impurity diffusion of Co, Mn, and Zn in single phase (BCC solid solution) HfTiZrNbTa and HfTiZrNbV RHEAs applying the radiotracer technique. A neutron total scattering technique is used to evaluate the pair distribution functions and element-specific lattice distortions in these alloys. Ab initio -based calculations give access to lattice distortions and solubilities of the impurities under investigation, including the impact of short-range order. The diffusion results are discussed in relation to calculated substitutional and interstitial solution energies, local lattice distortions, and short-range order effects. Co diffusion is found to be dominated by the interstitial mechanism, exhibiting fast diffusion. These findings reveal important structure-property relationships between local atomic environments and diffusion kinetics in BCC RHEAs, providing critical insights for designing alloys with enhanced high-temperature performance through targeted control of impurity diffusion processes. I Introduction Refractory high-entropy alloys (RHEAs) have garnered substantial research interest since their initial development in 2010 senkov2010refractory . The increased attention stems not only from the common four “core effects” associated generally with high-entropy alloys (HEAs), i.e. the high-entropy effect, “sluggish” diffusion, the cocktail effect, and severe lattice distortions Yeh2004 , but also from their exceptional strength at elevated temperatures, particularly within the range from 1200 to 1600^{\circ} C senkov2010refractory ; senkov2018development . Among RHEAs, those composed of elements from groups IV (Ti, Zr, and Hf) and V (V, Nb, and Ta) stand out for their remarkable combination of high-temperature strength and excellent tensile plasticity. Notably, this impressive tensile plasticity persists even at ambient temperatures, a phenomenon predominantly attributed to severe lattice distortions inherently present in a solid solution of elements with significantly different atomic radii cook2024kink ; gou2023additive ; lei2018enhanced ; senkov2018development ; lee2018lattice ; lee2020lattice ; thirathipviwat2022role . However, the limited environmental resistance remains one of the most critical limitations for high-temperature structural applications of RHEAs senkov2018development . RHEAs sheikh2018accelerated ; muller2019oxidation ; butler2019native ; gorr2017high ; wang2020effect share a similar behavior with many refractory alloys distefano2000oxidation , being susceptible to the formation of non-protective oxides. Internal oxidation or even a catastrophic failure, the so-called “pest” phenomenon, are observed in some refractory alloys with Al or Si additions sheikh2018accelerated ; westbrook1964pest ; sheikh2018aluminizing . This vulnerability is primarily attributed to the rapid diffusion of oxygen through refractory metal oxides, facilitating the formation of new oxide layers beneath the existing scales. Such a susceptibility of RHEAs to rapid oxide growth seems to contradict the “sluggish” diffusion concept, one of the four core effects of HEAs, even though the diffusion of oxygen through the already formed oxide is most probably the rate-dominating process. In fact, direct experimental studies have demonstrated that self-diffusion of Zr in the TiZrHfNbV and TiZrHfNbTa RHEAs is not sluggish but is rather enhanced, if the geometric mean of diffusivities in the corresponding unaries (pure elements) is used as the reference zhang2022zr . This definition of the diffusion sluggishness in multi-principal element alloys was further supported by large-scale molecular dynamics simulations Starikov2024 . Since the introduction of the “sluggish” diffusion concept in high-entropy alloys in 2013 tsai2013sluggish , extensive diffusion research has been performed, mainly on the most widely studied CoCrFeMnNi (i.e., “Cantor”) HEA system gaertner2019concentration ; zhang2021tracer ; lukianova2020impact ; gaertner2020tracer ; kottke2020experimental ; kottke2019tracer ; vaidya2018bulk ; vaidya2016ni ; glienke2020grain ; vaidya2017radioactive ; choi2024grain ; sen2024grain . The findings reveal that the diffusion behavior in the Cantor alloy and related alloy systems is particularly complex and cannot be understood simply in terms of sluggish diffusion. Moreover, several diffusion studies in HCP HEAs have reported instances of rapid (or even “anti-sluggish”) diffusion vaidya2020phenomenon ; sen2023anti ; sen2023does ; sen2024sc . While the diffusion characteristics vary strongly across different high-entropy alloys, recent studies suggest that the degree of lattice distortions significantly influences the diffusion behavior zhang2022zr ; lukianova2022self ; sen2023anti ; daw2021sluggish . It should be noted here that the lattice distortions arise not only from the varying atomic sizes and electronic environments of the constituent elements of HEAs but also from the presence of small interstitial impurity atoms. For instance, distortions induced by small amounts of interstitial carbon significantly influence substitutional self-diffusion in the CoCrFeMnNi HEA lukianova2020impact ; lukianova2022self . A conventional approach to quantifying lattice distortions involves calculating atomic size mismatch based on atomic radii zhang2022zr ; daw2021sluggish . However, this methodology exhibits inherent limitations, as atomic radii are not fixed values but rather variable parameters influenced by crystal structure and the electronic environment of neighboring atoms. Advanced theoretical modeling, particularly first-principles calculations, have been employed to assess lattice distortions in RHEAs, revealing that local lattice distortions are substantially more pronounced than what the average atomic size mismatch would suggest lee2018lattice ; lee2020lattice . In particular, element-specific mean squared displacements were calculated and analyzed sen2023anti ; muralikrishna2024microstructure . In addition, recent developments in experimental techniques utilizing total scattering from synchrotron X-ray or neutron sources have enabled quantitative measurements of the lattice distortions in HEAs. These investigations have demonstrated that such distortions are typically localized within 2–3 unit cells and that the atomic size mismatch represents just one of the multiple factors contributing to lattice distortions in HEAs tong2018comparison ; tong2020severe ; tong2018local ; thirathipviwat2022role ; meng2021charge . In our previous study, we conducted measurements of Zr self-diffusion in TiZrHfNbV and TiZrHfNbTa RHEAs, marking the first direct assessment of the self-diffusion rates in BCC HEAs zhang2022zr . The findings revealed that Zr self-diffusion in these RHEAs is not sluggish, suggesting that a substantial atomic size mismatch significantly influences diffusion, enhancing its rates. However, a comprehensive understanding of the diffusion mechanisms in BCC HEAs necessitates additional measurements of both diffusion and lattice distortions, particularly concerning impurity diffusion and local distortion phenomena. So far, impurity diffusion in HEAs was measured only for several systems, e.g. for Cu in CoCrFeMnNi gaertner2018tracer , Zn in B2-ordered AlCoCrFeNi Mohan2020-B2 , or for Zn in HfTiZrAlSc sen2023does , leaving a large gap in the current knowledge of diffusion phenomena in multi-principal element alloys. Furthermore, specific diffusion mechanisms of impurity atoms in terms of potential interstitial and/or substitutional contributions, as well as the possible impact of short-range order (SRO), are not fully understood. The present study aims to fill this gap by extending our previous work on Zr diffusion zhang2022zr by impurity diffusion measurements on the same batches of TiZrHfNbV and TiZrHfNbTa RHEAs. Diffusion of Co, Zn, and Mn is investigated using the radiotracer technique and applying suitable radioisotopes, 57 Co, 65 Zn, and 54 Mn, respectively. The selection of Co is motivated by the availability of extensive literature on Co diffusion in the constituent elements of these RHEAs, which facilitates an in-depth analysis of the parameters affecting diffusion. Zn and Mn represent solutes with different valency states that potentially affect the vacancy–solute binding. The lattice distortions

Read the complete text