Limitations to Chemotactic Concentration Sensing during C a 2 + Ca^{2+} Signaling
Swoyam Srirupa, Pradeep, Vaibhav Wasnik · 2025
Read Limitations to Chemotactic Concentration Sensing during C a 2 + Ca^{2+} Signaling by Swoyam Srirupa, Pradeep, Vaibhav Wasnik (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15438.txt.
Introduction
Swoyam Srirupa, Pradeep, and Vaibhav Wasnik show in a 2025 paper how well cells can sense chemical slopes while calcium signals buzz with noise. Living cells sense noisy biochemical signals that matter for survival, yet models that take in inside-cell signaling are few. The study looks at sensing of chemical pull through phosphorylation readouts in calcium signaling, a pathway found in most cells with a nucleus.
The team pairs chance-based computer runs with pen-and-paper calculations. Sensing stays robust when rates of reaction in the cell body vary, once those rates pass a set level. That toughness hints at an evolutionary gain: cells can tune other signaling tasks without giving up sensing accuracy. The work also shows, on paper, that Dictyostelium can sense very low levels of cyclic AMP, as experiments observe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Swoyam Srirupa, Pradeep, Vaibhav Wasnik |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 106 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15438
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Limitations to Chemotactic Concentration Sensing during C a 2 + Ca^{2+} Signaling Swoyam Srirupa, Pradeep, Vaibhav Wasnik Abstract Abstract. Living cells sense noisy biochemical signals crucial for survival, yet models incorporating intracellular signaling are limited. This study examines how cells sense chemotactic concentrations through phosphorylation readouts in C a 2 + Ca^{2+} signaling, which is ubiquitous in most eukaryotic cells. Using stochastic simulations and analytical calculations we find that concentration sensing remains robust to variations in cytoplasmic reaction rates once they exceed a certain value, suggesting a potential evolutionary advantage that allows cells to optimize other signaling tasks without compromising concentration sensing accuracy. Our analysis demonstrates theoretically that Dictyostelium is capable of sensing very low concentrations of cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) as is experimentally seen. Keywords: C a 2 + Ca^{2+} signaling 1. Introduction Living cells execute essential functions such as division, growth, differentiation Grandjean2004 , and apoptosis Nagata2018 . They also navigate chemical gradients through chemotaxis Berg1972 ; Haastert2007 ; Thar2003 ; Fuller2010 and engage in collective migration Siedlik2017 , crucial for embryonic development, wound healing, and cancer progression. These processes are guided by chemical signals like hormones, neurotransmitters, or other molecules. Accurate signal interpretation is vital, as errors can cause malfunctions, disease, or increased predation risk. Cells excel at decoding signals, as evidenced by numerous experimental studies. Rod cell photoreceptors detect single photons Hecht1942 ; Rieke1998 . E. coli sense 3.2 nM L-aspartate Mao2003 , about three molecules in the cell volume. Dictyostelium cells can detect a cAMP gradient with a concentration difference of 1-5\% across the cell diameter Haastert2007 . These observations raise fundamental theoretical questions: What are the physical limits of measurement in cellular systems? Has evolution optimized cellular machinery to perform measurements approaching these limits? Berg1977 first studied the theoretical constraints on concentration measurement, showing that the chemotaxis machinery in E. coli appears optimally designed. Endres2009Concentration investigated concentration sensing using maximum likelihood estimation on time series data of receptor occupancy. The impact of ligand-receptor kinetics Bialek2005 ; Kaizu2014 and receptor cooperativity Bialek2008 ; Skoge2011 ; Skoge2013 on concentration sensing has also been studied. Cells detect and respond to spatial chemical gradients Berg1972 ; Haastert2007 ; Fuller2010 . The impact of diffusion Endres2008 , ligand-receptor kinetics Endres2009Gradient , and receptor cooperativity Hu2010 in gradient sensing have been studied. However, these studies focus on measurement limits at the cell surface, neglecting intracellular signaling effects. Govern2012 demonstrated that non-uniform time averaging can surpass Berg-Purcell calculations. GovernDec2014 ; GovernNov2014 considered the problem of energy constraints. The accuracy of positional readout in calcium signaling was analyzed in Wasnik2019PRL ; Wasnik2019PRE , the influence of signaling cascades on concentration sensing in Biswal2024 , and the accuracy of glutamate readout in neuronal signaling in Biswal2023 . Here, we study how accurately cells can sense chemotactic concentrations through protein phosphorylation readouts in the cytoplasm once cellular processes, including ligand-receptor kinetics and biochemical reactions involved in signal transduction, reach a steady state. Our approach integrates simulations with theoretical analysis, focusing on nonlinear signaling networks, particularly calcium signaling pathways. Calcium ions ( Ca^{2+} ) act as secondary messengers, while extracellular ligands function as primary messengers. These pathways regulate numerous biological processes, including fertilization, secretion, contraction, cell-cycle progression, proliferation, apoptosis, and cognitive functions such as learning and memory Cullen2002 . Using stochastic simulations and approximate analytical solutions of coupled nonlinear rate equations by linearizing around the steady state, we show that concentration sensing remains robust against variations in cytoplasmic rate constants once they exceed a certain value, meaning the sensing error becomes insensitive to a particular cytoplasmic rate constant when it is sufficiently large compared to other rates in the system. 2. Theory Figure 1 : The figure illustrates calcium signaling pathways. In panel (a), the activation of the kinase is triggered by the attachment of four calcium ions. However, this process introduces more noise into the system. To simplify the analysis, we have considered a model where the kinase is activated by the binding of a single calcium ion, as shown in panel (b). Ca^{2+} signaling is initiated by the binding of ligands to membrane-bound receptors that are permeable to Ca^{2+} . For example, in neurons, the binding of neurotransmitters to cell surface receptors such as NMDA and AMPA receptors, which are permeable to Ca^{2+} , triggers the opening of calcium channels Pchitskaya2018 . The opening of these channels facilitates the influx of Ca^{2+} into the cytoplasm (see Fig. 1 ), leading to an increase in cytoplasmic Ca^{2+} concentration. Within the cell, Ca^{2+} binds to calmodulin (CaM), a calcium-binding protein. CaM is denoted by K in Fig. 1 . It contains four EF-hand motifs, each capable of binding a single Ca^{2+} ion. Upon occupancy of all four binding sites, it undergoes a conformational change that enables it to interact with and activate downstream targets, such as Ca^{2+} -CaM dependent kinases (e.g., CaMKII) clapham . Once activated, these kinases catalyze the phosphorylation of specific substrate proteins, thereby regulating vital cellular processes including muscle contraction, neurotransmitter release, and gene expression. Termination of Ca^{2+} signaling requires the reduction of cytoplasmic free calcium levels, typically achieved by active transport of Ca^{2+} out of the cytoplasm via pumps and exchangers. In our model, we consider a simplified version of this pathway in which Ca^{2+} binds to a calmodulin ( K ) and resulting calcium-calmodulin complex directly phosphorylate target protein, thus bypassing the intermediate role of Ca^{2+} -CaM dependent kinases. The mechanism, involving the sequential binding of four Ca^{2+} ions to the calmodulin, is illustrated in Fig. 1 (a). However, to reduce complexity, we assume that calmodulin activation occurs upon the binding of a single \mathrm{Ca}^{2+} ion. This leads to a simplified model as depicted in Fig. 1 (b). This simplification is made to estimate the lower bound of sensing accuracy. Including the full set of biochemical steps would increase the system’s complexity and introduce additional sources of noise, which may, in turn, elevate the sensing error. In the simplified model illustrated in Fig. 1 (b), the cell is exposed to a static extracellular ligand concentration c at time t=0 . Ligand molecules bind stochastically to cell surface receptors with a rate k_{+}c , and dissociate at a rate k_{-} . At t=0 , the intracellular Ca^{2+} concentration is assumed to be zero, and the concentration of unbound calmodulin ( K ) is denoted by C_{K0} . Upon ligand binding, a stochastic influx of Ca^{2+} is triggered. The influx rate is denoted by I_{Ca} , while the efflux rate (representing the leaving of \mathrm{Ca}^{2+} from the cytoplasm) is given by k_{l} . Within the cytoplasm, Ca^{2+} binds to K at a rate k_{k1} , forming a calmodulin-calcium complex (K\text{-}Ca) , and unbinds at a rate k_{d1} . The K\text{-}Ca complex catalyzes the phosphorylation of a target protein at a rate k_{p} , initiating a downstream cellular response. The phosphorylated protein is subsequently dephosphorylated by a protein phosphatase enzyme (not shown in Fig. 1 , assume it is in large quantity) at a rate k_{dp} , rendering it inactive and available for future phosphorylation. Let p(t) denote the probability that a receptor is occupied at time t , with p(0)=0 , meaning the receptor is initially unoccupied. This corresponds