Detecting Extraterrestrial Civilizations That Employ an Earth-level Deep Space Network

Pinchen Fan, Jason T. Wright, T. Joseph W. Lazio · 2025

Read Detecting Extraterrestrial Civilizations That Employ an Earth-level Deep Space Network by Pinchen Fan, Jason T. Wright, T. Joseph W. Lazio (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15425.txt.

Introduction

Pinchen Fan, Jason Wright, and Joseph Lazio work out where to listen for aliens who run a deep space network like ours, in a 2025 paper. Humanity's loudest steady signals are the uplinks we beam at our own probes. Twenty years of NASA Deep Space Network logs show those beams cluster along the planets' plane and toward other worlds. An observer watching an Earth-Mars line-up would very likely have caught one.

The Earth transit zone sees twenty times the usual duty cycle, and a Mars conjunction boosted interception odds enormously over random timing. The authors advise aiming searches at edge-on planetary systems and at their conjunctions.

Catalog record

CREATORPinchen Fan, Jason T. Wright, T. Joseph W. Lazio
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15425

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Detecting Extraterrestrial Civilizations That Employ an Earth-level Deep Space Network Pinchen Fan, Jason T. Wright, T. Joseph W. Lazio Abstract A major aspect of the search for extraterrestrial intelligence (SETI) involves searching for electromagnetic transmissions from extraterrestrial sources, often using our own transmissions as a guide. Previous studies have suggested that humanity’s most consistently detectable technosignatures were transmissions from our deep-space networks and interplanetary radar. In this study, we analyze NASA Deep Space Network logs to explore what strategies for selecting SETI targets and scheduling observations would enhance the chances of detecting such networks. Analyzing Deep Space Network uplink transmission logs over the last 20 yr, we find that these emissions were predominantly directed along the ecliptic plane, towards or directly away from the Sun, and towards other planets. The average duty cycle within the Earth Transit Zone is 20 times higher than that across all ecliptic latitudes. In the case of Mars, we find a species that is able to observe the Solar System for radio emission during an Earth-Mars conjunction in the past 20 yr would have had a 77% chance of observing during one of our transmissions, a 4 × 10 5 4\times 10^{5} -fold increase over intercepting our Deep Space Network transmission versus a random observer at a random time. These findings quantify how SETI searches might benefit from prioritizing edge-on exoplanet systems and aligning observation windows with exoplanetary conjunctions or planet-planet occultations because they significantly improve the likelihood of intercepting transmissions from any civilizations employing deep-space networks similar to our own. I Introduction The search for extraterrestrial life is arguably one of the most captivating and profound topics in astronomy and astrophysics. The search for signs of past or extant life, regardless of an organism’s complexity or intelligence, is conducted through biosignatures, such as \text{O}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{2}}} , \text{O}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{3}}} , \text{NH}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{3}}} , and \text{CH}{\vphantom{\text{X}}}_{\smash[t]{\text{4}}} ( Schwieterman et al. 2018 ) , which are signs of biological activity. Meanwhile, the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) relies on technology as a proxy for intelligence and looks for signs of past or present technology (technosignatures) as evidence of current or historic intelligent life. Technosignatures also provide a potentially more unambiguous and detectable approach than biosignatures ( Wright et al. 2022 ) . Furthermore, a successful SETI search would not only offer the first proof of life outside Earth but also demonstrate the existence of a technological species detectable across interstellar distances. This would significantly deepen our understanding of the prevalence, complexity, and intelligence of life in the Universe, much more than what could be achieved by biosignature detection. Two of the nine axes of merit for technosignature searches ( Sheikh 2020 ) favor technosignatures that are already produced by humanity (the “Extrapolation” axis) and are observable with current technology (the “Detectability” axis). As such, previous studies have proposed various kinds of radio technosignatures emitted by humankind, assessed their detectability, and have often described the search for these technosignatures as searching for “Earth-level civilizations” ( Ashtari 2023 ; Derrick & Isaacson 2023 ; Saide et al. 2023 ) . More recently, Sheikh et al. 2025 provided the most comprehensive calculations to date of the detectability of human-generated technosignatures in 2024. The study found that the two most detectable technosignatures emitted by humankind in 2024 were “intermittent, celestially targeted radio transmissions” and “persistent, celestially targeted radio transmissions” ( Sheikh et al. 2025 ) . Intermittent, celestially-targeted radio transmissions include intentional transmissions such as the Arecibo message ( NAIC Staff 1975 ) or planetary radar. However, these transmissions are highly sporadic in timing and directionality. By contrast, persistent, celestially-targeted radio transmissions include much more frequent transmissions between ground stations and deep-space spacecraft, such as those from the NASA Deep Space Network (DSN) . Previous research has proposed eavesdropping on interplanetary electromagnetic transmissions from edge-on exoplanet systems ( Siemion et al. 2013 ) . There have been a few surveys that search for electromagnetic transmissions during exoplanet conjunctions ( Traas et al. 2021 ; Sheikh et al. 2023 ) and planet-planet conjunctions ( Tusay et al. 2024 ) . Past research has also proposed searching for extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI) ’s deep-space communication systems as an SETI strategy ( Ashtari 2023 ) . Studies have cataloged stars located along the paths of five interplanetary probes, suggesting that these stars might have previously been illuminated by transmissions from our DSN ( Derrick & Isaacson 2023 ) . These searches reasonably assumed that such strategies could help boost the probability of a successful SETI search. Here, we will quantify this intuition. In this paper, we analyze archival DSN transmission logs. Our goal is to characterize the timing and directionality of NASA’s DSN broadcasts and identify any patterns in their detectability from outside the solar system, which could be shared by analogous networks used by an ETI . By understanding the patterns in our own deep-space networks, we aim to develop effective strategies for identifying analogous extraterrestrial networks using our current technology. In Sec. II , we describe how we collected DSN transmission logs and correlated each transmission with the appropriate spacecraft ephemerides. In Sec. III , we discuss how we generated detailed transmission maps and examine the patterns of the transmissions in terms of timing and directionality. In Sec. IV , we evaluate the implications of these findings for future SETI searches. II Analyzing Transmissions from the Deep Space Network II.1 The Deep Space Network The DSN consists of three sites, Goldstone in California, Madrid in Spain, and Canberra in Australia, each equipped with a 70-meter antenna and multiple (currently three to five) 34-meter antennas ( NASA 2022 ) . All antennas can transmit in the ‘‘X band” (approximately 7.190 GHz) 1 1 1 This frequency is in the C band according to the IEEE definitions ( IEEE 2020 ) , but the DSN refers to this as “X-band”. , while many antennas can transmit in the S band (approximately 2.110 GHz), and three antennas can transmit in the Ka band (approximately 34 GHz) ( NASA 2025 ) . Due to the limited number of antennas and low transmitting power ( <1 kW), Ka-band transmissions are excluded from our analysis. For the 70-meter antennas, the half-power beamwidths of S-band and X-band transmissions are about 0 .\kern-3.75pt\arcdeg\kern-1.25pt 128 and 0 .\kern-3.75pt\arcdeg\kern-1.25pt 038, respectively ( DSN Document Number 810-005, 101 in NASA 2025 ). For the 34-meter antennas, the half-power beamwidths of S-band and X-band transmissions are about 0 .\kern-3.75pt\arcdeg\kern-1.25pt 258 and 0 .\kern-3.75pt\arcdeg\kern-1.25pt 0777, respectively ( NASA 2025 , DSN Document Number 810-005, 103 in) . Typically, the antennas transmit up to 20 kW , with some antennas currently capable of transmitting up to 80 kW in X-band. The distance d at which a DSN transmission can be detected by a distant observer is given by the radiometer equation ( Enriquez et al. 2017 ) : d=\sqrt{\frac{G_{\mathrm{TX}}P_{\mathrm{TX}}}{4\pi(\mathrm{S/N}_{\mathrm{min}})(\mathrm{SEFD})}\sqrt{\frac{\tau_{\mbox{obs}}}{\Delta\nu}}}, (1) where G_{\mathrm{TX}} is the transmitting antenna’s gain, P_{\mathrm{TX}} is the transmission power, \mathrm{S/N}_{\mathrm{min}} is the signal-to-noise ratio threshold for detection, \mathrm{SEFD} is the system equivalent flux density (SEFD) of the detector, \tau_{\mbox{obs}} is the observation duration, and \Delta\nu is the channel bandwidth of the observation, assumed wider than or equal to the transmission bandwidth. For a typical DSN transmission, assume

Read the complete text