Demonstration of an integral method for estimating wall shear stress in complex high-speed flows

Mateus A. R. Braga, Robyn L. Macdonald · 2025

Read Demonstration of an integral method for estimating wall shear stress in complex high-speed flows by Mateus A. R. Braga, Robyn L. Macdonald (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-15024.txt.

Introduction

Braga and Macdonald show a sum way to gauge wall drag in fast, bent flows. Rough, blunt forms in high-speed flight pose a hard drag count case. True wall drag reads have stayed hard to pin on such forms. Their sum builds on the mean flow push form for streams. One add-up pass in the wall-cross line does the core work. That pass wipes out stream-wise ties in the end form.

Eight test cases show each term's weight in the sum. Each case also shows the miss span of the drag read. Miss spans ran at 5 percent or less in all cases. Most cases ran far less than that cap in the tests. The sum held for rough and curved walls in the set. A start-point shift keeps it sound on rough faces.

Catalog record

CREATORMateus A. R. Braga, Robyn L. Macdonald
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-15024

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Demonstration of an integral method for estimating wall shear stress in complex high-speed flows Preprint: APS/123-QED Mateus A. R. Braga, Robyn L. Macdonald Abstract Turbulent flows over blunt bodies with distributed roughness present a class of problems relevant to hypersonic atmospheric entry systems. However, accurate predictions of shear stress on such bodies remains elusive. This work presents a simple integral formulation to infer wall shear stress based on the Favre-averaged streamwise momentum equation, integrated once in the wall-normal direction. The proposed integral formulation eliminates streamwise dependence, relying only on data and gradients extracted in the wall normal direction. Eight demonstration cases were selected to show the contributions of the various terms of the integral equation, the associated error in the estimate, and outline practical considerations when estimating the wall shear stress for complex flow conditions. In all cases, the error in the predicted shear stress compared to a more traditional approach was no more than 5%, with many cases having much lower error. Notably, the method was found to be viable even for surfaces in the transitionally rough and fully rough regimes by appropriate selection of a virtual origin, as well as flows over curved surfaces or with pressure gradients. Finally, the method produces acceptable estimates of shear stress even in the extreme condition when over 40% of the near-wall boundary layer data is absent. In brief, the present integral method is general and applicable to flows with curvature, surface roughness, and pressure gradients. I Introduction Accurately estimating the wall shear stress is paramount for the analysis and characterization of wall-bounded fluid flows. A multitude of techniques exist in the literature to compute the wall shear stress, yet no one method is adequate for every condition. One such challenging condition is hypersonic flow with distributed surface roughness. In general, atmospheric entry systems make use of blunt body geometries and ablative thermal protection systems which introduce distributed or patterned roughness to the surface. This work formalizes a simple integral formulation to compute the wall shear stress from the Favre-averaged streamwise momentum equation. The approach is general enough to be applicable regardless of streamwise gradients and surface roughness. Experimental measurement techniques exist to measure the drag force per unit area exerted by a fluid on a surface. Techniques include floating-element force balance sensors, oil-film interferometry, Preston tubes, and Stanton Tubes to name a few. An overview of experimental shear stress measurement techniques can be found in Vinuesa and ¨ O rl ¨ u 2017 . Correlations are also common; a recent example from Dixit et al. Dixit et al. 2024 showed a generalized scaling framework and predictive model for wall friction in turbulent flow based on a variety of datasets, including compressible flow simulations. However, there were no rough-walled cases in the data fit and only two cases above Mach 1 (one supersonic and one hypersonic). Moreover, correlations are generally limited to conditions similar to those used to construct the fit and should be used with caution outside such conditions. Although there are benefits and limitations to the direct measurement techniques and generalized scalings, they will not be discussed further, and the focus of this work is on inferred shear stress estimates when wall-normal velocity, density, and pressure profiles are available, obtained experimentally or through computer simulation. To highlight the need for the wall shear stress estimation approach employed in this work, a brief description of some of the most common methods to infer the wall shear stress is provided. By definition, the shear stress \tau_{w} is the manifestation of the loss of streamwise momentum in the fluid due to the presence of the surface. For Newtonian fluids over smooth walls, the shear stress at a wall is \tau_{w}=\mu\frac{\partial u}{\partial y} , where \tau_{w} is the wall shear stress, \mu is the fluid dynamic viscosity, u is the streamwise velocity, and y is the wall-normal coordinate. In cases where the velocity profile in the viscous sublayer is known, the shear stress may be computed directly from the aforementioned definition. In the presence of surface roughness, the form drag becomes significant Perry et al. 1969 , and the estimate of the shear stress should also consider the net effect of the surface pressure distribution. The pressure contribution may be computed from the surface integral \frac{1}{A}\int_{S}p_{w}\hat{n}\cdot\hat{e}_{x}dS , where A is the projected planform area, p_{w} is the surface pressure, \hat{n} is the wall-normal unit vector, and \hat{e}_{x} is the streamwise unit vector. Unfortunately, accurate measurements of the near-wall velocity can be difficult to obtain, either through the limitations of experimental measurement techniques or in the presence of surface roughness. Similarly, full surface pressure distributions with resolution adequate for integration are often limited to scale-resolving simulations like direct numerical simulation (DNS) or wall-resolved large eddy simulation (WRLES). For fully developed channel flow, a preferred method is to compute the pressure drop across the channel and relate it to the local tangential force (per area) exerted by the fluid Pope 2000 ; Kuwata 2022 . This method is applicable to flows with or without roughness in incompressible or compressible regimes. For wall-bounded turbulent flows, another method that infers the shear stress solely from the mean velocity profile is the Clauser fit technique Clauser 1954 which seeks a value of the friction velocity, u_{\tau} , such that the inner scaled mean velocity profile fits the overlap region’s logarithmic law (log-law) u^{+}=(1/\kappa)\ln\left(y^{+}\right)+C . The friction velocity is selected based on the best agreement between the log-law and the inner-scaled mean velocity for y^{+}>50 Vinuesa and ¨ O rl ¨ u 2017 . Classically, the inner-scaled mean velocity is given by u^{+}=\overline{u}/u_{\tau} , where the dimensional mean velocity is \overline{u} , the inner-scaled wall-normal coordinate is y^{+}=(yu_{\tau})/\nu , the dimensional wall-normal coordinate is y , and the kinematic viscosity is \nu . For compressible flow, Van Driest Van Driest 1951 or Trettel and Larsson Trettel and Larsson 2016 transformations should be used. The Clauser fit is a common technique and only requires one wall-normal velocity profile at the location of interest. This method has been shown to work for a variety of surface conditions such as fully-developed, zero-pressure-gradient (ZPG) smooth-wall or rough-wall boundary layers Clauser 1954 ; Kong et al. 2024 ; Rowin et al. 2024 . However, in cases where the universal log-law does not hold, such as with strong pressure gradients, this method becomes inaccurate Dixit and Ramesh 2009 ; Butt and Egbers 2018 Another well established method of determining the wall shear is to derive an expression for the wall shear stress (or skin friction coefficient) from a form of the momentum integral equation. This has been well studied for incompressible flows Johansson and Castillo 2002 ; Fukagata et al. 2002 ; Brzek et al. 2007 ; Mehdi and White 2011 ; Mehdi et al. 2014 ; Deck et al. 2014 ; Yoon et al. 2016 ; Renard and Deck 2016 ; Volino and Schultz 2018 ; Ricco and Skote 2022 ; Elnahhas and Johnson 2022 ; Li et al. 2023 . Much of the effort has gone into various formulations that permit accurate estimates of the wall shear stress or skin friction coefficient without the need for streamwise gradients or near-wall data which may be

Read the complete text