Spurion Analysis for Non-Invertible Selection Rules from Near-Group Fusions
Motoo Suzuki, Ling-Xiao Xu, Hao Y. Zhang · 2025
Read Spurion Analysis for Non-Invertible Selection Rules from Near-Group Fusions by Motoo Suzuki, Ling-Xiao Xu, Hao Y. Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14970.txt.
Introduction
Motoo Suzuki and co-authors extend spurion analysis in a 2025 paper on selection rules in particle theory. Some rules come from fusion algebras that cannot be inverted. Near-group cases build on a finite abelian group plus one extra non-invertible piece. Well known cases include Fibonacci and Ising rules.
The team set up a clean scheme to label coupling constants in this frame. Labels let users track couplings as simple parts join into full amplitudes. The scheme shows why exact tree-level rules break once loop effects enter. A limit case lifts the algebra to a product group, which gives a matching second view of the same rules.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Motoo Suzuki, Ling-Xiao Xu, Hao Y. Zhang |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14970
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spurion Analysis for Non-Invertible Selection Rules from Near-Group Fusions Motoo Suzuki, Ling-Xiao Xu, Hao Y. Zhang Abstract We generalize the framework of spurion analysis to a class of selection rules arising from non-invertible fusion algebras in perturbation theory. As a first step toward systematic applications to particle physics, we analyze the near-group fusion algebras, defined by fusion rules built from a finite Abelian group G G extended by a single non-invertible element. Notable examples include the Fibonacci and Ising fusion rules. We introduce a systematic scheme for labeling coupling constants at the level of the non-invertible fusion algebra, enabling consistent tracking of couplings when constructing composite amplitudes from simpler building blocks. Our labeling provides a clear interpretation of why the tree-level exact non-invertible selection rules are violated through radiative corrections, a unique phenomenon essential to “loop-induced groupification”. We also identify the limit where the near-group fusion algebra is lifted to a G × ℤ 2 G\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} group, which provides an alternative scheme of spurion analysis consistent with the original one based on the near-group algebra. Meanwhile, we highlight the distinctions between the selection rules imposed by the near-group fusion algebra and those from breaking the G × ℤ 2 G\times\mathbb{Z}_{2} group. I Introduction Symmetry serves as a powerful organizing principle in quantum field theories (QFTs). Over the past decade, the concept of global symmetries has been significantly generalized following the seminal work Gaiotto et al. 2015 , which stimulated extensive cross-disciplinary research across high-energy physics, condensed matter physics, and mathematics, leading to a rich exchange of ideas and results. (For reviews from various perspectives, see e.g. Cordova et al. 2022 ; McGreevy 2023 ; Gomes 2023 ; Schafer-Nameki 2024 ; Brennan and Hong 2023 ; Luo et al. 2024 ; Shao 2023 ; Costa et al. 2024 ; Iqbal 2024 ; Davighi 2025 .) Among these generalizations, non-invertible symmetries Bhardwaj and Tachikawa 2018 ; Chang et al. 2019 have emerged as a particularly striking development, highlighting that symmetry actions do not have to obey the group law. Motivated by the developments of non-invertible symmetries, a class of selection rules from commutative non-invertible fusion algebras has been applied to study scattering amplitudes in perturbative (3+1) -dimensional QFTs, offering a potentially powerful framework for exploring physics beyond the Standard Model (SM). For clarity, we refer to them as non-invertible selection rules (NISRs). It was recently 1 1 1 Non-group selection rules were studied long ago, however. See e.g. Font et al. 1988 ; Kobayashi 1995 for early seminal works. shown in Kaidi et al. 2024 (see also Heckman et al. 2024 ) that NISRs are exact only at tree level, but are increasingly violated at higher loop orders, eventually reducing to a finite group. The whole procedure is called loop-induced groupification of the NISRs. Building on this observation, several NISRs have already been incorporated into particle physics models, primarily focusing on Yukawa texture zeros Kobayashi and Otsuka 2024 ; Kobayashi et al. 2024 ; Funakoshi et al. 2024 ; Kobayashi et al. 2025a ; Liang and Yanagida 2025 ; Kobayashi et al. 2025b ; Kobayashi et al. 2025c , minimal extensions of the SM Suzuki and Xu 2025 , models of radiative fermion masses Kobayashi et al. 2025d ; Nomura and Okada 2025 ; Nomura and Popov 2025 ; Chen et al. 2025 ; Okada and Shigekami 2025 , and discrete matter symmetries in supersymmetric models Kobayashi et al. 2025e . See also Dong et al. 2025 on constructing NISRs from discrete gauging (e.g., orbifolding). From a particle physics perspective, it is natural to understand the violation of symmetries (or selection rules) using spurion analysis , which involves promoting the coupling constants into (non-propagating) background fields that carry charges under the relevant symmetries. Those background fields are called spurions . Compared to ordinary (invertible) Abelian symmetry groups, the phenomenon of “loop-induced groupification” of NISRs, as we explained above, appears counterintuitive at first glance. As is well-known, selection rules from ordinary Abelian groups that hold at tree level remain exact to all loop orders in perturbation theory. Indeed, when the Abelian group is exact at the tree level, all the tree couplings in the classical Lagrangian are labeled by the identity; hence, any other coupling labeled by a nontrivial group element cannot be generated through radiative corrections at any loop order in perturbation theory. Inspired by such reasoning, it is natural to label all the tree couplings by the identity element of the non-invertible fusion algebra when it is exact at the tree level. However, to formally preserve the NISRs at loop order, one must use the nontrivial elements to label the couplings that are radiatively generated while explicitly breaking the NISRs. From the naive perspective of spurion analysis, this seems contradictory: how can the couplings labeled by nontrivial elements arise from the fusion of those all labeled by the identity? This apparent contradiction suggests that the framework of spurion analysis needs to be generalized when applied to NISRs. Motivated by the examples studied in Suzuki and Xu 2025 , we systematically generalize the spurion analysis to a class of NISRs arising from near-group fusion algebras Evans and Gannon 2012 in this paper. 2 2 2 Ref. Evans and Gannon 2012 considers near-group fusion categories , which supplement the fusion algebras by the additional data of the associators (i.e., F-symbols). Such data may be physically useful when resolving a 4-point vertex into a pair of 3-point vertices in different ways. We leave a study for future work. A near-group fusion algebra contains the elements \{g_{i}\} of a finite Abelian group G extended by another non-invertible element \rho , whose fusion rules are given by \displaystyle g_{i}\rho \displaystyle= \displaystyle\rho g_{i}=\rho\;, (1) \displaystyle\rho^{2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle n^{\prime}\rho+\sum_{\text{all}\ g_{i}\in G}g_{i}\;. (2) In addition, the elements \{g_{i}\} obey the ordinary group law of G . From Eq. ( 2 ), the element \rho is said to be self-conjugate, i.e., the fusion product of \rho with itself contains the identity element. However, \rho does not have an inverse, i.e. \rho^{2}\neq\mathbbm{1} where \mathbbm{1} is the identity. This is the hallmark of non-invertibility. Following Evans and Gannon 2012 , we denote the above non-invertible algebra as the type of G+n^{\prime} with n^{\prime}\in\mathbb{Z}_{\geq 0} . For example, the Fibonacci fusion rules can be denoted as the \{\mathbbm{1}\}+1 type, and the Ising fusion rules can be denoted as the \mathbb{Z}_{2}+0 type; for example, see Suzuki and Xu 2025 for some minimal particle physics models faithfully realizing these NISRs. We now outline a procedure for performing the spurion analysis in the case of the non-invertible G+n^{\prime} fusion algebra. We first need to promote coupling constants into background fields, and then label them using the elements in the fusion algebra. The consistent labeling should allow us to achieve the following goals: • To systematically keep track of the couplings in all the scattering processes, both at tree and loop levels in perturbation theory. • To reconcile the “loop-induced groupification” Kaidi et al. 2024 of NISRs with the conventional wisdom of spurion analysis. These two goals are related, and they are realized by assigning nontrivial elements of the fusion algebra Suzuki and Xu 2025 to coupling constants at tree level, even when the NISRs are not