EECT: an Eccentricity Evolution Consistency Test to distinguish eccentric gravitational-wave signals from eccentricity mimickers
Sajad A. Bhat, Avinash Tiwari, Md Arif Shaikh, Shasvath J. Kapadia · 2025
Read EECT: an Eccentricity Evolution Consistency Test to distinguish eccentric gravitational-wave signals from eccentricity mimickers by Sajad A. Bhat, Avinash Tiwari, Md Arif Shaikh, Shasvath J. Kapadia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14850.txt.
Introduction
A gravitational-wave chirp from merging black holes on oval orbits can be faked by other physics, so claims of ovalness need a guard. Sajad Bhat and co-authors propose a consistency test in a 2025 paper that checks the signal against itself.
True ovalness shrinks in a fixed way as the waves climb in pitch, following general relativity. A mimicking effect may match the ovalness at one pitch but will drift off the predicted path at others. Their test compares the ovalness read at low pitch, evolved upward by theory, against the values actually read higher up. In simulated detector networks, mimickers failed the test at solid confidence while true oval systems passed. The check needs no catalogue of rival explanations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sajad A. Bhat, Avinash Tiwari, Md Arif Shaikh, Shasvath J. Kapadia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 47 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14850
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
EECT: an Eccentricity Evolution Consistency Test to distinguish eccentric gravitational-wave signals from eccentricity mimickers Sajad A. Bhat, Avinash Tiwari, Md Arif Shaikh, Shasvath J. Kapadia Abstract Eccentric compact binary coalescences (CBCs) are expected to be observed in current and future gravitational-wave (GW) detector networks. Such detections are especially valuable as they can provide insights on the environments that nurture CBCs. However, it has been recently pointed out that a number of other physical and beyond-GR effects, could imitate, or be mimicked by, eccentric CBCs. The standard approach to ascertain that a detected CBC is eccentric is to employ Bayesian model selection, where the eccentric CBC hypothesis is compared against other hypotheses. Such an approach is not only computationally intensive and time-consuming, but could also be misleading if none of the models under consideration represent the true model. In this work, we propose a conceptually simple but powerful method to directly confirm or reject the eccentric hypothesis, without needing to compare the hypothesis with the plethora of other possible hypotheses. The key idea is that while spurious non-zero values of eccentricity, at some reference frequency, could be acquired when a non-eccentric CBC with additional physical/beyond-GR effects is recovered with an eccentric CBC waveform model, the evolution of eccentricity with frequency will in general not be mimicked. We accordingly formulate an eccentricity evolution consistency test (EECT). The method compares the eccentricity recovered at some low frequency value (e.g, 10 10 Hz), evolved to higher frequencies assuming GR, with eccentricities recovered at those same higher frequencies. Discrepancy between the two eccentricities at any reference frequency would violate EECT and indicate the presence of a mimicker. As a proof of concept, assuming a few eccentric CBC systems, quasi-circular CBCs with additional physics mimicking eccentricity, and an O4-like three-detector-network configuration, we demonstrate that our proposed method is indeed able to reject mimickers at ≥ 68 % \geq 68\% confidence, while ensuring that truly eccentric CBCs satisfy EECT. I Introduction Stellar mass compact binary coalescences (CBCs) are one class of sources that could produce detectable gravitational waves (GWs). Templated searches for these sources in detector data from LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA’s (LVK’s) Aasi et al. 2015 ; Acernese et al. 2015 ; Akutsu et al. 2021 first three observing runs (O1, O2, O3) have unearthed \sim 90 confirmed detections Abbott et al. 2019a ; Abbott et al. 2021a ; Abbott et al. 2023 . Most of these pertain to binary black hole (BBH) mergers Abbott et al. 2023 , although binary neutron star (BNS) Abbott et al. 2017 ; Abbott et al. 2020 and neutron star black hole (NSBH) mergers Abbott et al. 2021b have also been observed. Identifying the formation channels that produced LVK’s CBCs is a high-profile endeavor of considerable interest Abbott et al. 2021c . What is becoming increasingly clear is that a single formation channel almost certainly cannot explain the provenance of all of LVK’s CBCs Zevin et al. 2021 . Nevertheless, most of the proposed merger environments that allow CBCs to merge within Hubble time can be broadly categorised into two classes: CBCs could either have evolved in isolation in the galactic field, or have been dynamically assembled in dense stellar environments Mapelli 2020 . Ascertaining a CBC’s formation channel, on a single event basis, is in general difficult. This is because there is no incontrovertible evidence provided by the CBC signal that indicates its formation channel. 1 1 1 A possible exception to this is if the motion of the CBC’s center of mass imprints itself on the GW waveform (see, e.g., Vijaykumar et al. 2023 ; Tiwari et al. 2023 ), which could be extracted to constrain the gravitational potential of the CBC’s environment. However, statistical arguments have been made suggesting that the values of the masses, and the magnitudes and orientations of the spins of the components of the CBCs, could be used to acquire hints of their merger environment (see, e.g., Vajpeyi et al. 2022 ). Another intrinsic parameter that could provide additional clues of the CBCs’ formation channel is residual orbital eccentricity at a chosen reference frequency (see, e.g., Gondán and Kocsis 2021 ). GWs carry away energy and angular momentum from an inspiralling compact binary. This circularises the binary Peters and Mathews 1963 , and any residual eccentricity of the orbit at the time when the GWs enter the frequency band of current ground based detectors is expected to be negligibly small. However, certain formation channels pertaining to CBCs merging in dense stellar environments could provide detectable residual eccentricities Mapelli 2020 . Dynamical encounters in such environments could harden the binary sufficiently rapidly so that the GWs cannot exhaust orbital eccentricity entirely, leaving a residual amount at band-entry. Furthermore, binary-single encounters in AGN disks Samsing et al. 2022 ; Tagawa et al. 2021 , and Kozai-Lidov Kozai 1962 ; Lidov 1962 ; Naoz 2016 ; Antonini et al. 2017 mechanism due to the presence of a third body, could also boost eccentricity. Detecting eccentric CBCs promises to shed light on their formation, environment and evolution. It is therefore of considerable interest to confidently determine if a CBC is truly eccentric, or an eccentricity mimicker. Indeed, several works have shown that certain physical and beyond-GR effects could masquerade as, or be mimicked by, eccentricity. For example, Refs. Shaikh et al. 2024 ; Bhat et al. 2023 ; Saini et al. 2022 ; Saini et al. 2024 ; Narayan et al. 2023 have shown that tests of general relativity (GR) with quasi-circular waveforms applied to eccentric CBC signals could result in spurious violations of GR. On the other hand, an eccentric CBC could mimick one with finite line-of-sight acceleration Tiwari et al. 2025 , as will be shown later; precession Romero-Shaw et al. 2023a ; and one that is microlensed et al. 2025 . The prevalent approach to distinguish an eccentric CBC from one that mimicks it is to use Bayesian model selection. Large scale Bayesian parameter estimation (PE) is performed on stretches of data containing known CBCs. These PE exercises are carried out under different hypotheses, and ratios of evidences (Bayes factors) pertaining to pairs of hypotheses are evaluated to determine the model that best fits the data. Such an approach suffers from two problems. The first is that the model, from the set of models considered, that best fits the data, will be the true model only if the set contains the true model. The second is computational time and expense, given the large number of possible physical and beyond-GR effects that could modulate a CBC with respect to a quasi-circular one. Evaluating Bayes factors for all possible pairs becomes increasingly unfeasible with increasing models in the set. In this work, we propose an eccentricity evolution consistency test (EECT) that could directly ascertain, or reject, the eccentricity hypothesis, without needing to invoke alternative models and evaluate Bayes factors. The crux of the method rests on the following expectation. While some physical/beyond-GR effects in quasi-circular CBCs, recovered with eccentric models that do not account for these effects, produce spurious non-zero eccentricity at a chosen reference frequency, they will not in general conform to the expected frequency evolution of eccentricity. With this in mind, we first recover eccentricity (and other