An explicit construction of the Weyl module as a quotient of symmetric tensors by dual Garnir relations

Eoghan McDowell · 2025

Read An explicit construction of the Weyl module as a quotient of symmetric tensors by dual Garnir relations by Eoghan McDowell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14788.txt.

Introduction

McDowell presents a 2025 algebra paper giving a direct construction of the Weyl module, a standard building block for the Schur algebra. The mirror modules, called costandard, already enjoy tidy recipes as quotients of exterior powers or parts of symmetric powers. Weyl modules lacked a matching recipe. McDowell builds them as symmetric tensors cut down by new relations.

The relations dualize the classic Garnir relations in a non-obvious way. The construction stretches beyond one setting: it describes functors on the representation category of any group. Representation theorists gain a hands-on grip on objects usually reached only by duality. Proofs run through the tensor side throughout.

Catalog record

CREATOREoghan McDowell
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14788

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An explicit construction of the Weyl module as a quotient of symmetric tensors by dual Garnir relations Eoghan McDowell Abstract . The Weyl modules are the standard modules for the Schur algebra. Their duals (the costandard modules) have well-known constructions as quotients of exterior powers and as submodules of symmetric powers. This paper presents analogous constructions for the Weyl modules themselves, introducing relations that are a non-trivial dualisation of the Garnir relations. More generally, our constructions describe endofunctors on the category of representations of any group. 0 0 footnotetext: Affiliation : University of Bristol. Email : [email protected] . Webpage : eoghanjmcdowell.com . 1. Introduction The Weyl modules are the standard modules for the Schur algebra; in particular, their heads form a complete irredundant set of simple modules in the category of polynomial representations of \mathrm{GL}_{n}(k) , where n\in\mathbb{N} and k is an infinite field. It is well-known how to construct the dual of a Weyl module (a costandard module ) as a quotient of an exterior power and as a submodule of a symmetric power (see for example [§4]green2006polynomial, [§8]fulton1997youngtableaux, [§2]boeck2021plethysms or [§2]mcdowell2021inverseSchur, or [Proposition 4.5.2]donkin1998qschur for the q -analogue). Explicit constructions for the Weyl module itself, however, are lacking. The purpose of this paper is to provide such constructions. Comparisons with the existing literature are made in Section 1.3 . Both the existing and new constructions are functorial: they in fact describe, for each partition \lambda , a pair of endofunctors on the category of representations of any group over any unital commutative ring. We therefore work in this generality throughout. To obtain the Weyl and dual Weyl modules, apply the functors to the natural representation of \mathrm{GL}_{n}(k) . 1.1. Results We call the functors for constructing the dual Weyl modules the Schur endofunctors and denote them \nabla^{\lambda} . (The Schur endofunctors are often simply called Schur functors; we use the term “endofunctor” to differentiate them from functors arising in Schur–Weyl duality, such as the functor f in [§6]green2006polynomial.) We call the functors for constructing the Weyl modules the Weyl endofunctors and denote them \Delta^{\lambda} . 1.0 . Let G be a group and let R be a unital commutative ring. Let n\in\mathbb{N} and let \lambda be a partition of n . The Schur endofunctor \nabla^{\lambda} on the category of representations of G over R is defined as the quotient of an exterior power by Garnir relations, or equivalently as the subspace of a symmetric power consisting of polytabloids, as described in Section 3 : \nabla^{\lambda}({-})\cong\,{\mathchoice{\raisebox{4.96225pt}{$\displaystyle{\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}({-})}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-4.49501pt}{$\displaystyle{\mathsf{GR}^{\lambda}({-})}$}}{\raisebox{4.71225pt}{$\textstyle{\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}({-})}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-4.24501pt}{$\textstyle{\mathsf{GR}^{\lambda}({-})}$}}{\raisebox{3.62001pt}{$\scriptstyle{\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}({-})}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-3.24501pt}{$\scriptstyle{\mathsf{GR}^{\lambda}({-})}$}}{\raisebox{2.83333pt}{$\scriptscriptstyle{\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}({-})}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-2.45833pt}{$\scriptscriptstyle{\mathsf{GR}^{\lambda}({-})}$}}}\,\cong\mathsf{polytab}({-}). The Weyl endofunctor \Delta^{\lambda} is defined by pre- and post-composing the Schur endofunctor with duality (as defined in Section 2.5 ): \Delta^{\lambda}({-})=(\nabla^{\lambda}({-}^{\ast}))^{\ast}. This definition of the Schur endofunctor matches the presentations of Fulton’s Schur module E^{\lambda} [§8.1, Lemma 1, p. 107]fulton1997youngtableaux, and of Green’s dual Weyl module D_{\lambda,K} [§4.6]green2006polynomial. The definition of the Weyl endofunctor as the dual of the Schur endofunctor then guarantees that it yields the Weyl module, but does not give an explicit model for it. After recalling familiar multilinear algebra in Section 2 , and the well-known construction of the Schur endofunctor in Section 3 , we give our explicit constructions for the Weyl endofunctor in Section 4 . In particular, we define the following spaces: • \mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V)\subseteq\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}(V) , the space of copolytabloids (defined in Section 4.1 ); • \Sym_{\lambda}(V)\subseteq V^{\otimes n} , the space of row-symmetrised tensors (defined in Section 2.3 ); • \mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)\subseteq\Sym_{\lambda}(V) , the space of dual Garnir relations (defined in Section 4.2 ). We establish in Section 5 the following properties of these spaces. 1.1 . Let G be a group, let R be a unital commutative ring, and let V be a representation of G over R which is free and finitely-generated as an R -module. Let n\in\mathbb{N} and let \lambda be a partition of n . (1) There is a short exact sequence {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\Sym_{\lambda}(V)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V)} {\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces 0} \scriptstyle{\lx@inpgf@ignorespaces\mathsf{\Lambda}} where \mathsf{\Lambda} is the restriction of the projection map V^{\otimes n}\to\Wedge^{\lambda^{\prime}}(V) , which sends a row-symmetrised tensor labelled by a tableau t to the copolytabloid labelled by the tableau t . (2) The space \mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V) has R -basis consisting of copolytabloids labelled by semistandard tableaux. Finally in Section 6 we show that our constructions indeed yield the Weyl endofunctor, as stated below. Our proof of the first isomorphism, \Delta^{\lambda}(V)\cong\mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V) , is independent of the proof of Theorem 1.1 . 1.2 . Let G be a group, let R be a unital commutative ring, and let V be a representation of G over R which is free and finitely-generated as an R -module. Let n\in\mathbb{N} and let \lambda be a partition of n . Then \Delta^{\lambda}(V)\cong\mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V)\cong\,{\mathchoice{\raisebox{3.75pt}{$\displaystyle{\Sym_{\lambda}(V)}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-4.49501pt}{$\displaystyle{\mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)}$}}{\raisebox{3.75pt}{$\textstyle{\Sym_{\lambda}(V)}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-4.24501pt}{$\textstyle{\mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)}$}}{\raisebox{3.41666pt}{$\scriptstyle{\Sym_{\lambda}(V)}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-3.24501pt}{$\scriptstyle{\mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)}$}}{\raisebox{3.41666pt}{$\scriptscriptstyle{\Sym_{\lambda}(V)}$}\mkern-5.0mu\diagup\mkern-4.0mu\raisebox{-2.45833pt}{$\scriptscriptstyle{\mathsf{G}\hskip-1.0pt\operatorname{\rotatebox[origin]{180.0}{$\mathsf{R}$}}^{\lambda}(V)}$}}}\,. 1.2. Relationship to Specht modules for the symmetric group The well-known construction of the Specht modules due to James gdjames1978reptheorysymgroups can be obtained from the Schur endofunctors after an easy modification (restricting to subspaces spanned by elements labelled by tableaux with all entries distinct). This is the setting in which the term Garnir relations (or Garnir elements ) originates, following work of Garnir garnir1950theorie. The modification to the Schur endofunctors in the case of the Specht modules makes duality much simpler: the dual of a Specht module can be constructed as a submodule of a twisted Young permutation module (analogous to an exterior power) in essentially the same way as the Specht module can be constructed as a submodule of a Young permutation module (analogous to a symmetric power) (see [§7.4]fulton1997youngtableaux). Furthermore, as described in Section 4.2 below, the dual Garnir relations introduced in this paper reduce to relations of essentially the same form as the usual Garnir relations. Thus the novelty of our dual Garnir relations is for Weyl modules and other general applications of Weyl endofunctors. 1.3. Existing constructions of Weyl modules and Weyl endofunctors Akin, Buchsbaum and Weyman present the Weyl endofunctor (which they call the coSchur functor ) as a quotient of a divided power (isomorphic to the space of symmetric tensors) and as a submodule of an exterior power [Definition II.1.3]akin1982Schurfunctors: their definition is as the image of a map which is recursively defined by composing multiplications and comultiplications, and a description of the kernel occurs only implicitly (with unspecified integral coefficients) in the sketched proof of [Thoerem II.3.16]akin1982Schurfunctors. By contrast, our map \mathsf{\Lambda}\colon\Sym_{\lambda}V\to\mathsf{copolytab}^{\lambda}(V) has a straightforward definition that is easy to compute, we explicitly describe its kernel as the space of dual Garnir relations ( Sections 4.2 and 5.2 ), and the non-trivial dualisation of the usual “straightening algorithm” is presented in its entirety ( Section 5.2 ). We note that the dual Garnir relations are significantly harder to identify than the usual Garnir relations or quadratic relations in the quotient construct of the dual Weyl module. Carter and Lusztig, and later Green, describe the Weyl module as the set of tensors satisfying certain conditions ([§3.2]carterlusztig1974modularreps, [(5.2b)]green2006polynomial) and give a basis in terms of the action of the Schur algebra on a distinguished element ([§3.3–3.5]carterlusztig1974modularreps, [(5.3b)]green2006polynomial). Their conditions require the tensors to be antisymmetric, and so this construction is isomorphic to a subspace of an exterior power. Our construction, meanwhile, describes the elements (including a basis) explicitly in terms of the natural basis of the exterior power. (Carter and Lusztig introduced

Read the complete text