Algorithmic Collusion is Algorithm Orchestration
Cesare Carissimo, Fryderyk Falniowski, Siavash Rahimi, Heinrich Nax · 2025
Read Algorithmic Collusion is Algorithm Orchestration by Cesare Carissimo, Fryderyk Falniowski, Siavash Rahimi, Heinrich Nax (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14766.txt.
Introduction
Cesare Carissimo and co-authors argue that when pricing algorithms learn to collude, the real collusion sits one level up. Their 2025 paper reframes algorithmic collusion in Bertrand-style price games, where economists have read machine-learned high prices as tacit collusion between firms.
The authors model the designers as players in a meta-game: each tunes an algorithm, and the tuned algorithms then compete on price again and again. On their account, the joint tuning needed to reach collusive prices usually amounts to a form of explicit coordination, which they call algorithm orchestration. The meta-level view reveals fresh equilibria and fresh collusion patterns that the standard reading misses. The paper speaks to both theory and antitrust debate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cesare Carissimo, Fryderyk Falniowski, Siavash Rahimi, Heinrich Nax |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14766
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Algorithmic Collusion is Algorithm Orchestration Cesare Carissimo, Fryderyk Falniowski, Siavash Rahimi, Heinrich Nax Abstract This paper proposes a fresh ‘meta-game’ perspective on the problem of algorithmic collusion in pricing games a la Bertrand. Economists have interpreted the fact that algorithms can learn to price collusively as tacit collusion. We argue instead that the co-parametrization of algorithms – that we show is necessary to obtain algorithmic collusion – requires algorithm designer(s) to engage in explicit collusion by algorithm orchestration. To highlight this, we model a meta-game of algorithm parametrization that is played by algorithm designers, and the relevant strategic analyses at that level reveal new equilibrium and collusion phenomena. Algorithmic collusion is a growing phenomenon and a major challenge for the law and regulators ( Schwalbe 2018 ) . Already prior to the advent of AI and the rise of pricing algorithms, because one cannot ‘read the minds of managers,’ collusion was notoriously difficult to detect. And things have now become even more difficult as pricing algorithms operate faster and by themselves. In fact, the law in most countries is such that not all behaviors resulting in collusion are deemed unlawful. In particular, it is not generally unlawful for price setters to sustain high prices through self-enforcing pricing strategies with reward-punishment schemes – where competitors tacitly recognize the reward of supra-competitive prices as well as the threat of punishment via low prices. The current interpretation of antitrust in many countries deems collusion as unlawful when there is explicit communication between price setters. In legal language, an agreement among competitors to limit competition is unlawful but conscious parallelism is not as long as it is competitively arrived at, […] not because such pricing is desirable (it is not), but because it is close to impossible to devise a judicially enforceable remedy for ‘interdependent’ pricing ( Harrington 2018 ) . 1 1 1 From Clamp-All Corporation versus Cast Iron Soil Pipe, 851 F.2d 478 (1st Cir. 1988). An emerging economic literature studying algorithmic collusion is interpreted as having shown that the conditions for tacit collusion, which would not be deemed illegal, are increasingly met as algorithms are able to communicate indirectly through actions without involved competitors ever directly communicating in a traditional sense. We shall discuss this literature in detail in the next section. The point we want to make here now is that our paper takes a stance that is fundamentally quite different from the existing literature. Our perspective is that a strategic analysis of the individual algorithms’ designs ought to be conducted, in order to establish whether the interdependent algorithms are designed competitively, that is, as best responses to one another seeking higher payoff unilaterally, or non-competitively, even collusively, so as to increase payoffs jointly. Our main finding is that algorithmic collusion can only strive if algorithms are orchestrated, that is, co-parametrized non-competitively in the pursuit of supra-competitive prices and joint payoff improvements. By contrast, algorithms set competitively will end up pricing close to competitively. We believe our perspective provides a timely alternative to the existing criteria according to which algorithmic collusion is evaluated, especially as internet platforms increasingly distribute their custom pricing algorithms to their market participants. Evidently, there is a massive conflict of interest for the platform as the algorithm orchestrator to not deploy competitive algorithms but to curate the entire landscape jointly. Indeed, this conflict of interest has been acknowledged in applied legal scholarship which is stuck with the traditional economic framework of tacit versus explicit collusion as a function of communication. As such criteria appear ill-suited for algorithm regulation, and in the absence of more nuanced economic analyses, some legal scholars have gone as far as recommending a general ban of all kinds of algorithms that condition their prices on the history of opponent prices ( Harrington 2018 ) . We think such a ban is not realistic and indeed not necessarily welfare-enhancing. Instead, we propose a fresh line of thought and a novel distinction between legal and illegal collusion according to whether the interdependent algorithms are competitively parametrized or the result of algorithm orchestration. Indeed, we show that outruling algorithms altogether may not benefit consumer surplus much, as algorithms that are parametrized as best responses to one another would behave approximately competitively in the pricing game. By contrast, we find that the kind of highly collusive pricing behaviour as previously identified in the literature would require explicit collusion in parameter setting by the designers of the algorithm. We obtain our results by embedding the algorithmic interaction of competing algorithms in a ‘meta-game’ of algorithm design that is played by algorithm designers who decide on the parameters of the algorithms that then compete to play the pricing games. You may think of this meta-game as played by algorithm designers who pick the (hyper)parameters of their algorithm, thus affecting both their own and the other parties’ payoffs. 2 2 2 A hyperparameter determines how an algorithm learns. It must be distinguished from the ‘weights’ (sometimes called parameters) which the algorithm learns by interacting. Importantly, we postulate that the relevant players playing the meta-game (i.e. the algorithm designers) must tune their algorithm against their algorithmic opponents seeking to maximize their payoffs unilaterally. To the best of our knowledge, this kind of analysis is novel in economics, yet deemed relevant in principle by legal scholars who recognize the dynamic improvement process of ‘The Algorithm Game’ ( Bambauer and Zarsky 2018/2019 ) which was a source of inspiration. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. First, section 1 is dedicated to a review of the literature on algorithmic collusion. In subsection 2.1 , we introduce the meta-game formally, and then in subsection 2.2 we introduce the computational setup we use to evaluate designer incentives. The following sections show our results concerning designer best responses in section 3 and designer collusion in section 4 . Finally, in section 5 , we discuss avenues for future work, and conclude with a proposal of a simple test to differentiate between collusive and competitive algorithms by analysis of emergent price patterns. 1 The Economics of Algorithmic Collusion 1.1 Q-learning in Bertrand duopoly A growing body of economic literature studies learning in games of competition (a la Bertrand, Cournot, etc.) and other games (e.g. Prisoner’s dilemma games) as played by interacting algorithms. Several papers identify situations where learning algorithms converge to collusive outcomes that yield supra-competitive payoffs. In this section, with a focus on Q-learning in Bertrand duopoly games, we review the relevant design choices made in the literature and relate them to the kinds of convergent phenomena that have been observed. We organize the existing literature according to the following two dimensions along which existing studies differ: (i) the learning algorithms being used—algorithms differ according to how they evaluate payoffs and how they select among available actions. Much of the literature, and indeed the one we shall focus on and contribute to more narrowly is concerned with Q-learning algorithms that vary in terms of their hyperparameters, especially concerning exploration (exp_), being \epsilon -greedy ( \epsilon -g), where the rate \epsilon can be decayed or fixed during learning. We also distinguish papers by whether they allow agent asymmetry (asym_). (ii) how the chosen algorithm