Phase space transport, quasilinear diffusion and locality in phase velocity.

Didier Bénisti · 2025

Read Phase space transport, quasilinear diffusion and locality in phase velocity. by Didier Bénisti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14657.txt.

Introduction

Didier Bénisti examines when charged particles surfing a set of electrostatic waves wander as if diffusing. His 2025 paper studies the case where transport is strong and particle speeds swing widely, though walls in phase space still cage the motion. The question is when a simple diffusion picture, with its classic quasilinear coefficient, tells the truth.

Calculations and simulations split two regimes apart. In the gentle regime, diffusion matches the classic value only when each particle feels mainly the waves moving near its own speed, a property called locality. In the chaotic regime, diffusion can proceed without locality, but then the coefficient is not the classic one. For the well-behaved regime he adds a simple formula for how the speed distribution evolves inside its cage.

Catalog record

CREATORDidier Bénisti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14657

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Phase space transport, quasilinear diffusion and locality in phase velocity. Didier Bénisti Abstract In this paper, we address the motion of charged particles subjected to a discrete spectrum of electrostatic waves. We focus on situations when transport dominates, leading to significant variations in particle velocity. Nonetheless, these velocity changes remain finite due to the presence of KAM tori bounding phase space. We analyze the conditions under which transport can be modeled as a diffusion process and evaluate the relevance of the so-called quasilinear value of the diffusion coefficient. We distinguish between traditional quasilinear diffusion, when wave-particle interaction is perturbative, and the so-called chaotic regime of diffusion, when the particle motion looks erratic. In the perturbative regime, we demonstrate both numerically and theoretically that diffusion occurs only when wave-particle interaction is local in phase velocity; that is, when wave contributions from phase velocities far from the particles instantaneous velocities are negligible. Conversely, numerical results indicate that chaotic diffusion can occur even when wave-particle interaction is not local. Furthermore, in regimes when quasilinear diffusion is applicable, we introduce a simple analytical expression for the time evolution of the velocity distribution function, that accounts for phase space boundaries. I Introduction Whether transport can be modeled by a Fokker-Planck equation remains one of the most fundamental issues in both basic and applied physics. From a foundational perspective, this amounts to addressing determinism. Indeed, the Fokker-Planck equation is mathematically equivalent to a stochastic Langevin equation. Hence if, as shown in Refs. [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , some deterministic systems may be modeled by a Fokker-Planck equation for an arbitrary long time and with an arbitrary accuracy, there is no way for an observer to know whether such systems are indeed deterministic or stochastic. In other words, it would be utterly impossible to ascertain whether all natural systems are fully deterministic or if some irreducible degree of randomness exists. Furthermore, deriving the particle distribution resulting from chaotic transport is essential in countless applications. This paper focuses on transport driven by a fixed spectrum of electrostatic waves, a scenario commonly encountered in plasma physics. The best known example is certainly the saturation regime of the warm beam-plasma instability (see for example Refs. 5 and references therein). To cite a few other examples, in space plasmas, interactions with broad wave spectra have been invoked to explain energetic ion observations in the magnetosphere [ 6 ] and electron losses in radiation belts [ 7 ] . Moreover, the present work is motivated by laser-plasma interaction when electrostatic waves result from stimulated Raman scattering or two-plasmon decay [ 8 ] . Such waves may generate energetic electrons [ 9 ] which are detrimental to inertial confinement fusion [ 10 ] , or beneficial for producing X-ray sources [ 11 ] with enhanced energies. For the application to laser-plasma interaction (and for many other ones), the wave spectrum may certainly not be assumed stationary. However, as shown in Section III , considering a fixed spectrum is enough to derive transport properties, provided that the modes growth rates vary slowly enough and that the maximum growth rate is much less than the total frequency extent of the spectrum. In plasma physics, transport induced by electrostatic waves is most often modeled as a quasilinear diffusion [ 12 ] . Although quasilinear theory has been the subject of considerable debate [ 13 ] , several papers provided a detailed discussion of its relevance for a nearly stationary spectrum (see for example Refs. [ 1 , 5 , 14 ] ). In particular, Ref. 1 shows that two types of diffusion may exist. In the first one, which is quasilinear and closer to the situation considered in the initial theory [ 12 ] , the particle motion may be described by making use of a first order perturbation analysis. It may be followed by a second, so-called “chaotic” diffusion regime, when the particle motion looks erratic. In this second regime, the diffusion coefficient may be different from the quasilinear one, although usually of the same order. Moreover, as shown in Refs. [ 1 , 3 ] , for large enough wave amplitudes, the initial quasilinear regime persists until the onset of the second, chaotic regime. In this situation, quasilinear diffusion is valid until the particules reach the phase space boundaries. Now, all the aforementioned results were derived for the dynamics defined by the following Hamiltonian, assumed to be paradigmatic, H_{p}=\frac{v^{2}}{2}+A\sum_{n=1}^{N}\cos(x-nt+\varphi_{n}), (1) where the \varphi_{n} s were random initial phases. The key point of the derivation was the proof of locality in phase velocity for the wave-particle interaction [ 15 ] . Here, locality means that, at all times, transport is essentially due to those waves whose phase velocity differ by no more than \Delta v_{R}\approx 6A^{2/3} from the instantaneous particle speed. Note that the quasilinear diffusion coefficient, as derived in Ref. 12 for a continuous spectrum, accounts only for waves with phase velocity exactly matching the particle speed, thus representing an infinitely local interaction. This would not make sense for a discrete spectrum and, for such a wave spectrum, the expression of the quasilinear diffusion coefficient was derived in Ref. 18 and recalled in Section III , Eq. ( 39 ). Clearly, the conclusions drawn from the Hamiltonian H_{p} raise several important questions, mostly (but not only) regarding their universality : 1. Does there exist a broad class of Hamiltonian dynamics whose transport properties are exactly the same as those derived from H_{p} ? 2. Is locality a universal property in wave-particle interaction ? 3. Does the first perturbative regime of quasilinear diffusion exist for all wave spectra ? 4. Is there a link between locality and the first quasilinear diffusion regime ? 5. Can chaotic diffusion exist without locality ? 6. Talking about diffusion is somewhat abusive for a finite discrete wave spectrum because particles only have access to a limited region of phase space, which raises the following question : can one derive an analytical expression for the time evolution of the velocity distribution function that accounts for phase space boundaries ? To the best of the author’s knowledge, no previous article specifically addressed the first fourth and sixth issues. In Ref. 5 , Vlasov simulations showed the relevance of quasilinear theory to model the warm beam-plasma instability in the strongly nonlinear regime, while non-quasilinear evolution was observed for intermediate nonlinear regimes, thus supporting some of the results derived from the Hamiltonian H_{p} . Moreover, on a more theoretical perspective, several papers, e.g. Ref. 14 , addressed the relevance of the initial quasilinear diffusion regime for more general wave spectra than that considered in Hamiltonian H_{p} . However, the authors of these papers implicitly made hypotheses that led to the validity of the initial quasilinear regime. In this article, we aim to address the 6 aforementioned issues for the general class of wave spectra leading to the dynamics defined by the following Hamiltonian, H=\frac{v^{2}}{2}+A\sum_{n=1}^{N}a_{n}\cos(k_{n}x-\omega_{n}t+\varphi_{n}), (2) where the \varphi_{n} s remain random initial phases, while the a_{n} s, k_{n} s and \omega_{n} s may be chosen arbitrarily. As for the pre-factor, A , it is introduced as a normalization constant to allow direct comparison with the results derived from

Read the complete text