Necessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin
Michael Mandl, Erhard Seiler, Dénes Sexty · 2025
Read Necessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin by Michael Mandl, Erhard Seiler, Dénes Sexty (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14512.txt.
Introduction
Michael Mandl, Erhard Seiler, and Dénes Sexty derive rules for when a tricky simulation method gives correct answers, in a research paper from 2025. The method, complex Langevin, is used when standard sampling fails because the weights are not positive. It can settle on wrong results without warning.
Their conditions link correct answers to the theory's own balance equations plus some bounds on the values measured. The results hold beyond this one method, for general probability laws on complex spaces. Tests on simple toy models show the checks do catch wrong answers without needing the exact solution. The authors stress the rules are best used to flag bad runs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Michael Mandl, Erhard Seiler, Dénes Sexty |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14512
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Necessary and sufficient conditions for correctness of complex Langevin Michael Mandl, Erhard Seiler, Dénes Sexty Abstract We derive a family of correctness conditions for complex Langevin simulations. In particular, we show that if in a given theory the expectation values of all observables within a particular space satisfy the theory’s Schwinger–Dyson equations as well as certain bounds, then these expectation values are necessarily correct. In fact, these findings are not only valid in the context of complex Langevin simulations, but they also hold for general probability densities on complex manifolds, given an initial complex density on a real manifold. We test these criteria in a few simple one- and two-dimensional toy models and find that they are indeed capable of ruling out incorrect results without the need of exact solutions. 1 Introduction The numerical sign problem remains among the most challenging problems in many-particle physics to this day. It prevents the numerical evaluation of integrals over highly oscillating functions with a large number of degrees of freedom with standard techniques. Such integrals arise, for instance, in the nonperturbative study of strongly interacting quantum field theories with a nonzero density of fermions by means of first principle lattice simulations. Moreover, they are also prevalent in lattice approaches to the study of real-time quantum field theories, as well as in various other theories of interest in physics. The complex Langevin method [ 1 , 2 ] can be used – in principle – in situations where conventional lattice approaches cannot be applied due to the sign problem, thus providing a potential solution. For a theory whose path integral consists of the integration of an oscillatory integrand \rho over a real manifold \mathcal{M}_{r} , the complex Langevin approach makes use of the stochastic evolution in a complexified field space \mathcal{M}_{c} . Effectively, it replaces \rho by a real and nonnegative distribution P on \mathcal{M}_{c} , which thus allows for a probabilistic interpretation similar to the one used in usual Monte-Carlo approaches. The complex Langevin evolution is considered successful if and only if P is equivalent to \rho in the sense that both produce the same expectation values on an appropriate space of holomorphic observables. The existence of such a probability density P for a given \rho has been established quite generally [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . What is less clear, however, is whether complex Langevin is capable of producing such P for generic \rho . In fact, complex Langevin simulations may suffer from the infamous wrong convergence problem, meaning that they might fail to reproduce the correct expectation values, at least without additional modifications. Establishing the correctness of complex Langevin simulation results is thus of utmost importance in order to ensure the reliability of the method. While there is a plethora of potential correctness criteria to be found in the literature, none of them appear to be entirely satisfactory and free of loopholes. In this work, we attempt to fill this gap by deriving a set of conditions that are both necessary and sufficient to ensure that a probability density P on \mathcal{M}_{c} produces the same expectation values as a given complex density \rho on \mathcal{M}_{r} . The correctness criterion proposed here can thus be applied to complex Langevin results, but it is, in fact, more general than that. Indeed, it can be used in any situation where a complex density on a real manifold \mathcal{M}_{r} is traded for a probability density on the complexification of \mathcal{M}_{r} . This work is structured at follows: After introducing a number of useful definitions and terminology in Section 2 , we derive the new correctness condition in Section 3 . In Section 4 , we introduce the complex Langevin approach, which we then use to test the correctness condition. The results of this are presented in Section 5 . Finally, in Section 6 , we provide a few ideas on how to employ the criterion in more realistic models than the ones considered here, before concluding in Section 7 . The appendices contain some auxiliary results and derivations. 2 Generalities 2.1 Manifolds and densities We consider models defined on a real manifold \mathcal{M}_{r} , for instance the configuration space of a lattice gauge theory. The manifold \mathcal{M}_{r} generally is of the form \mathcal{M}_{r}=\mathbb{R}^{n}\times G^{m}\;, (1) where G is a compact Lie group such as \mathrm{SU}(N) . The case n=0 is interpreted as the absence of the factor \mathbb{R}^{n} , while m=0 is is interpreted as the absence of the factor G^{m} . On \mathcal{M}_{r} , we consider the measure d\mu\equiv d^{n}x\times d^{m}g\;, (2) i.e., the product of the Lebesgue measure d^{n}x on \mathbb{R}^{n} with the Haar measure d^{m}g on G^{m} . \mathcal{M}_{r} has a complexification to a complex manifold \mathcal{M}_{c} , \mathcal{M}_{c}=\mathbb{C}^{n}\times G_{c}^{m}\;, (3) where G_{c} is the complexification of G . We denote the arguments of functions on \mathcal{M}_{r} by (\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g}) and when complexified by (\mathbf{z},\mathbf{g}_{c}) . Occasionally, for notational brevity we will omit the arguments of functions in this work when they are evident from the context. The models we consider are defined by a complex density \rho(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g}) , which has a holomorphic continuation to \mathcal{M}_{c} . In many cases, \rho is given in terms of an action S(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g}) via \rho(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g})\propto\exp(-S(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g}))\;. (4) We assume \rho to be normalized, such that \int_{\mathcal{M}_{r}}\rho\,d\mu=1\;. (5) If \mathcal{M}_{r} is noncompact, i.e., n>0 , we furthermore assume that \rho_{m}(\mathbf{x})\equiv\sup_{\mathbf{g}\in G^{m}}|\rho(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g})| (6) goes to zero at least as fast as a Gaussian for |\mathbf{x}|\to\infty , i.e., \rho_{m}(\mathbf{x})\leq A\exp(-a|\mathbf{x}|^{2})\;, (7) with some positive constants A and a . This condition could likely be weakened, but it helps to keep the discussion as simple as possible. In any case, the condition is always satisfied in the usual lattice models. Another requirement that is met for most conventional models, which we also impose here, is that the first partial derivatives of \log\rho with respect to both the coordinates and the group degrees of freedom (see below) grow at most like a polynomial in \mathbf{x} for all \mathbf{g} . Finally, we assume that \rho does not vanish on \mathcal{M}_{r} : \rho(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g})\neq 0\quad\forall\,(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{g})\in\mathcal{M}_{r}\;. (8) This is not really a restriction because by Cauchy’s theorem we can always deform or shift the integration manifold \mathcal{M}_{r} away from any zeroes without changing the expectation values of observables. 2.2 Observables and Schwinger–Dyson operators Let us consider the (commutative) algebra \mathfrak{A} of observables generated by the coordinates of \mathbb{R}^{n} and the matrix elements 1 1 1 Notice that the matrix elements of \mathbf{g}\in G are functions of \mathbf{g} , such that the observables in \mathfrak{A} are really functions on \mathcal{M}_{r} . of the finite-dimensional representations of G^{m} (note that in the case of G=\mathrm{SU}(N) we only require the matrix elements of the fundamental representation as generators of the algebra). All the elements f\in\mathfrak{A} have analytic continuations to \mathcal{M}_{c} , which we denote by the same letter f . The constant function with value 1 is the unit element of \mathfrak{A} , denoted by \mathds{1} . It turns out, however, that we actually require a somewhat larger space of observables for our purposes, as will be explained below. It is well known that the correct expectation values of observables have to satisfy the so-called Schwinger–Dyson equations (SDEs),