Massive spin 3 and Metric-Affine Gravity
Roberto Percacci · 2025
Read Massive spin 3 and Metric-Affine Gravity by Roberto Percacci (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14211.txt.
Introduction
Gravity can be written with a ruler alone, or with a ruler and a free compass of axes at each point. Percacci and co-authors explore the second script in 2025, in its mirror-symmetric form. The gap between the two frames is a three-index field, and it carries a spin-three wave, a rare beast in physics.
The puzzle is health: spin-three waves usually sicken a theory with ghost states. The authors show dials exist where the wave stays sound, alone or paired with a spin-zero mate. That is a first for this bent form of the field. A sound spin-three sector keeps a whole family of gravity theories in play. The check is done at the wave level, the standard first gate.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Roberto Percacci |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14211
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Massive spin 3 and Metric-Affine Gravity Roberto Percacci Abstract MI-HET-863 Symmetric Metric-Affine Gravity is a theory of gravity with an independent non-metric connection, and zero torsion. It can be thought of as ordinary metric gravity coupled to a rank–3 tensor Q , symmetric in one pair of indices. This field carries a spin-3 degree of freedom. We find that, in contrast to the totally symmetric case, it is possible to arrange the parameters in the Lagrangian, so that, at the linearized level, the spin-3 state, either alone or in combination with a spin-0 state, has a healthy propagation. 1 Introduction Particle states can be viewed as irreducible representations (irreps) of the Poincaré group and in particle physics we are accustomed to using one field for each particle species. In particular, every boson of spin s is associated to a totally symmetric tensor of rank s . 1 1 1 This is the situation for fields with parity P=(-1)^{s} . For fields with opposite parity, see Appendix . This, however, is a reducible representation, and only the highest dimensional irrep is used. If the free Lagrangian is chosen so that the spin s components propagate correctly, the other, lower spin, components will typically present some pathologies. For example, the Proca Lagrangian has a specific form such that the spin zero (longitudinal) component of the vector does not propagate, because if it did it would be a ghost. A similar situation arises in the linearized Einstein Lagrangian. In higher spin theories, however, the number of irreps is larger and it becomes possible to find Lagrangians for a single field that correctly propagate more than one type of particle. One context where this happens is Metric-Affine Gravity (MAG), a vast class of generalized theories of gravity where the connection is independent of the metric [ Hehl:1994ue , Blagojevic:2013xpa ] . The connection is not a tensor and it is more convenient to use as an independent variable the difference between the independent connection and the Levi-Civita connection, which is a tensor. One can then recast MAG as a normal metric theory of gravity coupled to a rank three tensor. When linearized around flat space, this field carries in general several irreps, including one with spin 3. This is therefore a natural context in which a higher spin field arises in a theory of gravity. It has been known for a long time that there are examples of MAGs where the connection correctly describes the propagation of more than one type of particle [ Sezgin:1979zf , Lin:2018awc , Aoki:2019snr ] . Motivated by these examples, we shall seek free MAG Lagrangians that, at the linearized level, correctly describe the propagation of a massive spin-3 particle and possibly some other lower spin state, in addition to the graviton. An independent motivation for this work comes from the theory of higher spin fields. It is well known since the work of Singh and Hagen that the description of a massive higher spin field involves, in addition to the totally symmetric tensor, also auxiliary fields [ Singh:1974qz ] . In particular, in the case of spin 3, one auxiliary scalar is used. One may wonder whether there are ways of describing the massive spin 3 particle without introducing additional fields, or in other words whether some of the lower spin states carried by the rank-3 tensor can play the role of the auxiliary fields. Whereas normally one demands that the rank- s tensor describe the propagation of a spin- s only , we can relax this condition and allow for the propagation of other lower spin states. We shall see that for s=3 , as long as we use a totally symmetric tensor, this is not enough: there is no free Lagrangian for a totally symmetric rank-3 field that describes the propagation of a massive spin-3 particle and any combination of lower spin states, avoiding ghosts and tachyons. At this point, partly motivated by MAG, we will relax the condition of total symmetry and demand that the field be symmetric in two indices only. (In the geometrical language of MAG this corresponds to allowing the connection to carry nonmetricity, but to have zero torsion.) In this case, we will see that it is possible to find (many) Lagrangians that propagate either only a massive spin-3 particle or a massive spin-3 and a massive spin-0 particle (other combinations may also be possible, but we have not systematically explored all possibilities). In a sense, in this way we did not have to introduce auxiliary fields. However, the symmetric field can be decomposed algebraically and uniquely in a totally symmetric part and a hook symmetric part (symmetric in a,b but such that \Phi_{(abc)}=0 ). For those Lagrangians that propagate a spin-3 particle only, one could view the hook symmetric part as being an auxiliary field. In our models we do not have lower rank fields, except possibly for the rank-2 graviton field h_{\mu\nu} , that could mix with some of the spin 2^{+} components of the three-tensor. This field has to satisfy the linearized Einstein equations. It lives a life of its own and will be ignored in most of this work. We conclude with some remarks about the earlier literature on spin 3 and MAG. Baekler, Boulanger and Hehl [ Baekler:2006vw ] found a choice of parameters in a gauge theory of gravity, such that at linearized level it describes the propagation of a spin 3^{-} state. We comment more extensively on their work in Section . For related results using the spin projector formalism see [ Baldazzi:2021kaf , Mikura:2024mji , Barker:2025xzd , Barker:2025rzd ] . All these papers discuss the embedding of the (massless) Fronsdal Lagrangian in the linearized MAG Lagrangian. Their limitation is that it seems very unlikely that the tensorial gauge symmetry of the Fronsdal Lagrangian can be extended to a fully interacting theory, as has been reviewed in [ Bekaert:2010hw ] . For this reason, it seems more promising to look for a massive spin 3^{-} field, that does not have such a symmetry. Using the spin projector formalism, Marzo found a Lagrangian for massive spin 3^{-} and spin 1^{-} [ Marzo:2021esg ] . His approach differs from ours in that he used a vector and a scalar as auxiliary fields. The aim of this paper is to not introduce additional lower rank fields; instead, in a sense, we use the hook symmetric components of nonmetricity as auxiliary fields. This seems more natural in MAG, where nonmetricity is in general a three-index field, symmetric in two indices only. The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we briefly describe the spin projector toolbox. In Section 3 we treat the case of a totally symmetric rank-3 tensor field and in Section 4 we generalize to the case of a rank-3 tensor field that is symmetric in two indices only. The relevance of these results to MAG and aspects of interactions is discussed in Section 5. 2 The spin projector toolbox In determining the spectrum of the theory and analysing the ghost and tachyon freedom conditions, it is convenient to use the spin projector formalism. Assume that the dynamical field is \Phi_{A} , where A stands