Contrastive Analysis of Constituent Order Preferences Within Adverbial Roles in English and Chinese News: A Large-Language-Model-Driven Approach
Yiran Rex Ma · 2025
Read Contrastive Analysis of Constituent Order Preferences Within Adverbial Roles in English and Chinese News: A Large-Language-Model-Driven Approach by Yiran Rex Ma (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-14054.txt.
Introduction
Yiran Rex Ma compares word order choices in English and Chinese news writing in a 2025 linguistics study. Comparable news corpora in the two languages were annotated with help from a large language model. The focus is chunks that play adverbial roles, such as time, place, and manner phrases, and where reporters prefer to place them.
English news tends to put core information first, with adverbial chunks following behind. Chinese news tends to present background first, placing those chunks early. Within subject-verb-object structure, further shared and differing patterns appear. The contrast shows how each language's news style stages a story for its readers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yiran Rex Ma |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-14054
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Contrastive Analysis of Constituent Order Preferences Within Adverbial Roles in English and Chinese News: A Large-Language-Model-Driven Approach DOI: https://rexera.github.io Journal: FACMP 123-A56-BU3 Yiran Rex Ma Abstract . Based on comparable English-Chinese news corpora annotated by Large Language Model (LLM), this paper attempts to explore the differences in constituent order of English-Chinese news from the perspective of functional chunks with adverbial roles, and analyze their typical positional preferences and distribution patterns. It is found that: (1) English news prefers linear narrative of “core information first”, and functional chunks are mostly post-positioned, while Chinese news prefers overall presentation mode of “background first”, and functional chunks are often pre-positioned; (2) In SVO structure, both English and Chinese news show differences in the distribution of functional chunks, but the tendency of Chinese pre-positioning is more significant, while that of English post-positioning is relatively mild; (3) When function blocks are co-occurring, both English and Chinese news show high flexibility, and the order adjustment is driven by information and pragmatic purposes. The study reveals that word order has both systematic preference and dynamic adaptability, providing new empirical support for contrastive study of English-Chinese information structure. 1 1 1 Project repository available at: https://github.com/rexera/constituent_order 1. Introduction Constituent order refers to the sequence of words or phrases as functional units within a syntactic structure ( Jacobson 1996 ; An 2006 ) . It is a subset of word order. Differences in constituent order are evident in English and Chinese sentences, particularly when conveying adverbial information such as time, location, and manner. These differences pose challenges for language learning, communication, and practical use. The primary difficulties include the following: (1) Second-language learners often struggle to accurately determine constituent placement ( Li and Liu 2020 ; Huang 2010 ) . For example, as illustrated in examples (1)a and (1)b, there are significant word order differences when delivering the same news information, showing clear preferences. (2) Translators need to adjust word order to maintain effective information transmission ( Zhang and Wang 2019 ) . For instance, as demonstrated in examples (1)b and (1)d, translators must align with the target audience’s expectations regarding word order. While existing studies provide qualitative assessments of constituent order preferences ( Yuan 1999 ; Wu 1995 ) , they fall short of offering systematic patterns of constituent usage. Scholars have engaged in extensive discussions on word order and the sequencing of adverbials, focusing primarily on the following areas: (1) the manifestation of word order in grammatical units such as attributes, adverbials, and subordinate clauses ( Hu and Lu 1988 ) ; (2) grammatical and cognitive factors influencing word order and adverbial placement ( Wasow 2003 ) ; and (3) cross-linguistic similarities and differences in word order and whether universal patterns exist ( Hawkins 1994 ; Rong 2000 ) . Previous research exhibits the following characteristics: First, in terms of analytical focus, studies often begin with specific grammatical units, emphasizing syntactic analysis but paying insufficient attention to semantic information transmission ( Li 2010 ; Zeng 2015 ; Müller 2021 ) . Second, regarding methodology, many investigations rely on inductive reasoning and subjective insights to infer word order differences, often constrained by limited data and lacking empirical support for universal patterns ( Guo 2012 ; Shuang 2016 ; Zhang and Wang 2022 ) . Third, in research priorities, while some studies highlight factors influencing word order differences, less attention is given to the distributional patterns of word order itself ( Futrell et al. 2020 ) . Hu and Lu 1988 define constituent order as the relationship and arrangement of “functional chunks.” Different languages, when expressing the same semantic function, may make similar or divergent choices in arranging these blocks based on their syntactic and semantic rules. With advancements in large language models such as GPT-4 ( OpenAI 2023 ) , the automated annotation of “functional chunks” within corpora has enabled the efficient analysis of large-scale word order patterns. Building on this, the present study employs a data-driven approach using automated annotation methods provided by large language models. It focuses on the distributional patterns of adverbial functional chunks in English and Chinese journalistic texts, aiming to uncover the preferences for constituent order in both languages. 2. Research Background 2.1. Typological Representation of Word Order Differences in English and Chinese Human languages universally exhibit correlations between syntactic positions and word order typology ( Dryer 1986 ) . For instance, although both English and Chinese share an SVO structure 2 2 2 English sentence structures are typically categorized into seven patterns: SV, SVO, SVC, SVA, SVOO, SVOC, and SVOA ( Quirk et al. 1985 ) , with the SVO pattern being the most common. For Chinese, interpretations differ. One view asserts that subject-verb-object (SVO) is the basic word order of Modern Chinese ( Wang 1980 ) . Another perspective argues that as a character-based language, Chinese cannot be fully represented by the SVO framework and is better described using a ”theme-rheme” structure ( Zhao 1968 ; Zhang 2011 ) . This study does not delve further into this debate. For the sake of comparison, we provi-sionally assume that both English and Chinese share SVO as the most prevalent sentence pattern. , they differ in the placement of modifiers: English tends to position modifiers after the headword, while Chinese generally places them before it ( Wang and Xiao 1981 ) . When conveying temporal, locative, and manner information, English and Chinese exhibit distinct preferences for constituent placement within sentences. These differences are prevalent across various grammatical units, including attributes, adverbials, and subordinate clauses ( An 2006 ) . Existing scholarly discussions often provide a coarse-grained categorization of these differences, offering limited insights into a comprehensive understanding of word order variations. While there is consensus that English and Chinese differ typologically in terms of word order, intuitive typological generalizations still dominate discussions, particularly regarding the flexible placement of adverbials. This makes it difficult to extract typical distributional patterns of word order ( Ding 2014 ) . Regarding the relationship between word order and syntax, Li 2010 observed that although Chinese is primarily SVO, it demonstrates an OV tendency in relative clauses and comparative structures, resulting in a typologically atypical mixed-order feature among global languages. Using word order indices, Jin 2019 further confirmed that while Chinese exhibits VO characteristics in verb-object structures, it displays OV tendencies in areas such as attributive and prepositional phrase placement. Additionally, Chinese relies on a “topic chain” to advance information, allowing for layered information expansion and permitting adverbials to appear at the beginning of sentences. In contrast, English more rigidly adheres to the subject-verb-object logical order ( Rong 2000 ) . However, these conclusions are predominantly based on introspective reasoning and speculative analysis, with insufficient empirical validation through large-scale corpora. 2.2. Semantic and Information-Structural Motivations In the evolution of human languages, a universal tendency toward “unidirectional change” aims to enhance the efficiency of syntactic processing ( Hawkins 1994 ) . This shared tendency leads to certain commonalities between English and Chinese in discourse-level information progression. For instance, Liu and Guo 2014 and Guo 2022 , applying Halliday 1985 ’s theme and rheme theory to broadcast and academic discourse, respectively, identified several shared thematic progression patterns in both languages. However, English