Discriminating scalar ultralight dark matter from quasi-monochromatic gravitational waves in LISA
Jordan Gué, Peter Wolf, Aurélien Hees · 2025
Read Discriminating scalar ultralight dark matter from quasi-monochromatic gravitational waves in LISA by Jordan Gué, Peter Wolf, Aurélien Hees (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13847.txt.
Introduction
Jordan Gué, Peter Wolf, and Aurélien Hees ask whether the future space observatory LISA could tell a dark matter hum from a gravitational wave, in a 2025 paper. Ultralight scalar dark matter would tug test masses rhythmically through its coupling to ordinary matter, printing a Doppler wiggle on the laser links between LISA's spacecraft. That wiggle could masquerade as a near-monochromatic gravitational wave from a distant binary.
Using a year of realistic LISA orbits and Bayesian inference, the team simulated both signals and tried to separate them. LISA will indeed be able to discriminate the two, they find. The distinction matters: mistaking dark matter for a binary would corrupt the gravitational wave catalog, and mistaking a binary for dark matter would waste a discovery. The study supports adding dark matter searches to LISA's science case with confidence about false alarms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jordan Gué, Peter Wolf, Aurélien Hees |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 88 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13847
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Discriminating scalar ultralight dark matter from quasi-monochromatic gravitational waves in LISA Jordan Gué, Peter Wolf, Aurélien Hees Abstract A scalar ultralight dark matter (ULDM) candidate would induce oscillatory motion of freely falling test masses via its coupling to Standard Model fields. Such oscillations would create an observable Doppler shift of light exchanged between the test masses, and in particular would be visible in space-based gravitational waves (GW) detectors, such as LISA. While this kind of detection has been proposed multiple times in the recent years, we numerically investigate if it is possible to extract a scalar ULDM signal in a space-based GW detector, and in particular how to differentiate such a signal from a GW signal. Using one year of realistic orbits for the LISA spacecrafts and Bayesian methods, we find that LISA will indeed be able to discriminate between the two signals. I Introduction The microscopic nature of dark matter (DM) remains to this day one of the biggest puzzles of fundamental physics Bertone and Tait 2018 . While its gravitational impact on surrounding visible objects is well known (see e.g. Cirelli et al. 2024 for a review), the fundamental interactions of DM with the Standard Model particles are still to be discovered. Over the whole zoo of possible candidates, ultralight dark matter (ULDM), i.e. DM with mass well below the eV, makes an appealing solution to the DM problem, in particular it can address some challenges of the \Lambda CDM model at galactic scales, see e.g. Ferreira 2021 . At cosmological scales, ULDM can be described as a classical bosonic field which oscillates at its Compton frequency \omega , when \omega\gg H , the Hubble constant. In the Milky Way’s galactocentric frame, assumed to be the DM rest frame, the DM particles acquire a non-zero velocity dispersion which implies that the DM wave is not purely monochromatic but presents a characteristic frequency dispersion \Delta\omega\sim\omega/10^{6} Derevianko 2018 ; Foster et al. 2018 . Among those ULDM candidates, scalar fields, like dilaton or axionlike-particle, referred to as the axion in the following, induce spacetime variations of fundamental constants of Nature, like the fine structure constant or the electron mass through their couplings with various sectors of the Standard Model (SM) Damour and Donoghue 2010 ; Kim and Perez 2024 . As a consequence, the rest mass and the transition frequency of test masses or atoms are also dependent on the spacetime position, therefore such oscillations can be probed accurately using atomic clocks or tests of the universality of free fall (UFF) like atom interferometry Hees et al. 2016 ; Hees et al. 2018 ; Badurina et al. 2022 ; Gué et al. 2024 . It has recently been proposed to use gravitational wave (GW) detectors to probe such couplings by measuring the phase shift of the laser light exchanged between the test masses Morisaki and Suyama 2019 ; Yu et al. 2023 . The space-based GW observatory LISA (Laser Interferometer Space Antenna), as a joint mission between ESA (European Space Agency) and NASA (North American Space Agency), has recently been adopted Colpi et al. 2024 and is expected to be launched in 2035. It consists of three spacecrafts (S/C) in heliocentric orbit, separated by 2.5 million kilometers armlength. The six individual optical interferometers will serve to detect GW in the 10^{-4}-1 Hz frequency band, and in particular, LISA is expected to detect GW emitted by galactic binaries (GBs) Timpano et al. 2006 ; Toonen, S. et al. 2017 . In this case, the two massive bodies are far from the coalescence, such that the timescale of their inspiral phase is much larger than the mission duration, or in other words the signal is quasi-monochromatic. GW act on LISA arms through Doppler shifts of light exchanged between the S/C, induced by the oscillation of the physical distance between the test masses. DM also induces quasi-monochromatic oscillations of the physical distance between the test masses via the oscillations of their mass and thus their momentum. Therefore, both the DM and GW signals produce similar signals in Fourier domain, in the form of a quasi-monochromatic peak at the wave frequency. Then, a natural question arises: will space-based GW detector such as LISA be able to disentangle a scalar ULDM signal from a GW one? This is the question we aim to answer in this paper. Using Bayesian inference on mock scalar ULDM and monochromatic GW signals in one year of data generated using realistic orbits of the S/C Martens and Joffre 2021 based on LISAOrbits Bayle et al. 2022 , we evaluate if one is able to differentiate a DM signal from a GW one. Our main conclusion is that there is no degeneracy between the DM and GW signals. In other words, this means that Bayesian model selection allows to clearly identify an injected scalar ULDM signal within the data with respect to a GW signal. On the other hand, Bayesian model selection clearly shows that a scalar ULDM model cannot explain an injected monochromatic GW signal, such that the monochromatic GW model is preferred over the ULDM one. Therefore, we conclude that there is no substantial degeneracies between the two dataset as seen by LISA, and that the expected sensitivity curves on the dilatonic couplings computed in Yu et al. 2023 are valid. The paper is organised as follows. In Sec. II , we start by computing the acceleration induced by scalar DM candidates. Then, in Sec. III , we show how these accelerations produce an observable signal in space-based GW detectors, and we compare it with the signal induced by monochromatic GW. In Sec. IV , we dig into the main part of the paper, namely we describe our Bayesian analysis on the distinction between ULDM and GW signals in LISA, from the methodology to the results. In Sec. V , we compute the sensitivity of LISA to ULDM couplings, and we discuss our results in Sec. VI . II Test mass oscillating acceleration induced by scalar dark matter In this section, we briefly review some known results regarding the acceleration induced by scalar dark matter on test masses (see e.g. Damour and Donoghue 2010 ; Hees et al. 2018 ; Gué et al. 2024 for more details). II.1 Scalar field linearly coupled to Standard Model We will be interested in the coupling between a dimensionless dilaton scalar field \phi and the Standard Model, with the corresponding low-energy effective linear interaction Lagrangian Damour and Donoghue 2010 \displaystyle\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{int}} \displaystyle=\phi\left(\frac{d_{e}}{4\mu_{0}}F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu}-\frac{d_{g}\beta_{3}}{2g_{3}}G^{a}_{\mu\nu}G^{a\mu\nu}-\right.\, (1) \displaystyle\left.\sum_{i=e,u,d}(d_{m_{i}}+\gamma_{m_{i}}d_{g})m_{i}\bar{\psi_{i}}\psi_{i}\right)\,, where F^{\mu\nu},G^{a\mu\nu} represent the electromagnetic and gluonic strength tensors respectively, \mu_{0} is the vacuum magnetic permeability, g_{3},\beta_{3} are the dimensionless QCD coupling constant and QCD beta function for the running of g_{3} , m_{i} the mass of the fermions fields in units of energy, with spinors \psi_{i} and \gamma_{m_{i}} the anomalous dimension giving the energy running of the masses of the QCD coupled fermions. The d_{i} represent the dimensionless coupling constants between the scalar dilaton and the different matter fields. These interactions between the SM particles and the dilaton lead to variation of several fundamental constants of Nature, namely the QCD energy scale \Lambda_{3} , the electromagnetic fine structure constant \alpha , the electron mass m_{e} and the light quark