Can Large Language Models (LLMs) Describe Pictures Like Children? A Comparative Corpus Study

Hanna Woloszyn, Benjamin Gagl · 2025

Read Can Large Language Models (LLMs) Describe Pictures Like Children? A Comparative Corpus Study by Hanna Woloszyn, Benjamin Gagl (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13769.txt.

Introduction

Children describe pictures in a voice of their own, and schools wonder whether AI text can sound the same. Hanna Woloszyn and Benjamin Gagl compared machine texts with German children's picture story descriptions. Two machine corpora were made, one from plain prompts and one from prompts showing examples with ages. The texts were weighed on word frequency, vocabulary richness, sentence length, word classes, and meaning similarity.

Machine texts ran longer but used a poorer vocabulary. They leaned on common words and used fewer nouns than children. Meaning maps showed low overlap with the child corpus. Example prompts helped only slightly. The authors warn that machine text for young readers may miss how children actually write.

Catalog record

CREATORHanna Woloszyn, Benjamin Gagl
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE30 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13769

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Can Large Language Models (LLMs) Describe Pictures Like Children? A Comparative Corpus Study Hanna Woloszyn, Benjamin Gagl Abstract The role of large language models (LLMs) in education is increasing, yet little attention has been paid to whether LLM-generated text resembles child language. This study evaluates how LLMs replicate child-like language by comparing LLM-generated texts to a collection of German children’s descriptions of picture stories. We generated two LLM-based corpora using the same picture stories and two prompt types: zero-shot and few-shot prompts specifying a general age from the children corpus. We conducted a comparative analysis across psycholinguistic text properties, including word frequency, lexical richness, sentence and word length, part-of-speech tags, and semantic similarity with word embeddings. The results show that LLM-generated texts are longer but less lexically rich, rely more on high-frequency words, and under-represent nouns. Semantic vector space analysis revealed low similarity, highlighting differences between the two corpora on the level of corpus semantics. Few-shot prompt increased similarities between children and LLM text to a minor extent, but still failed to replicate lexical and semantic patterns. The findings contribute to our understanding of how LLMs approximate child language through multimodal prompting (text + image) and give insights into their use in psycholinguistic research and education while raising important questions about the appropriateness of LLM-generated language in child-directed educational tools. [orcid=0009-0007-6641-4790, [email protected] ] *1 [orcid=0000-0002-2339-6293, [email protected], ] *1 keywords Large Language Models ,multimodality ,child language ,psycholinguistics ,corpus linguistics † † copyrightyear: 2025 † † copyright: Copyright for this paper by its authors. Use permitted under Creative Commons License Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0). † † venue: Preprint † † address: Self-Learning Systems Lab, Faculty of Human Sciences, Department of Special Education and Rehabilitation, Cologne, Germany † † corresp: Corresponding author. 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have impacted fields such as corpus linguistics, psycholinguistics, and natural language processing (NLP) by providing new ways to generate text in response to prompts ( Brown 2020 ; Schepens et al. 2023 , e.g.,) . LLMs’ accessibility and user-friendliness have supported their growing use in research and applications, such as chatbots ( Brown 2020 , e.g.,) . Recent work has explored using LLMs to support children’s creative writing skills ( Elgarf et al. 2024 ) , suggesting that LLM-generated output may scaffold and enhance children’s writing. However, these findings also highlight that LLM-generated texts lack lexical richness, raising questions about their effectiveness as linguistic models in educational contexts ( Liu and Fourtassi 2024 ; Schepens et al. 2023 ) . Here, we extend this evidence based on the state-of-the-art models that offer image prompt capabilities, generating text from text and visual prompts ( Tsimpoukelli et al. 2021 ; Alayrac et al. 2022 ) . These LLMs allow us to generate a unique yet child-specific corpus of texts that simulate children’s responses to a set of picture stories with accompanying text prompts ( Laarmann-Quante et al. 2019 ) . The study of child language and first language acquisition is foundational in linguistics, providing insights into cognitive development and mechanisms of language learning ( Tomasello 2005 , e.g.,) . Children undergo significant linguistic and interactive development during early childhood, making this period critical for understanding human language acquisition. Although, among others, classic German child-language corpora have supported acquisition research ( Schroeder et al. 2015 ; MacWhinney 2000 ) , their use in NLP remains limited due to ethical, practical, and availability constraints ( Casillas et al. 2017 ) . LLMs primarily rely on large-scale datasets dominated by adult and high-resource language data ( Luo et al. 2023 ) . Child language remains marginal in the models’ training data, especially in underrepresented languages (but see, e.g., Warstadt et al. 2023 ). As a result, there is limited research on whether LLMs can efficiently generate child-like text that mimics the linguistic patterns and conceptual structures of children’s writing (but see Liu and Fourtassi 2024 ; Schepens et al. 2023 ). Child language acquisition is a multimodal process ( Morgenstern 2023 ; Karadöller et al. 2024 ; Vigliocco et al. 2014 ) . From relating spoken words to objects in infancy, to multimedia aids helping children learn in school, the co-occurrence of visual and auditory language-related stimulation is critical for effective learning (e.g., Andrä et al. 2020 ). One particularly intriguing case is writing tasks. Here, children either describe a visual stimulus or should be able to write creative texts in response to a visual image after the instruction of, for example, a teacher ( Berkling 2016 ; Berkling 2018 ; Becker-Mrotzek 2022 ) . In our study, we exploit the recently developed multimodal capabilities of an LLM that allow text and visual stimulation. Using multimodal prompting (text and image), we can investigate if LLMs can generate child language based on complex visual stimulation, by comparing the texts to texts from children in response to the same images. Such approaches offer insights into how LLMs could support child language development, creative writing based on modalities different than text, as such modalities are common in children’s learning, yet still used much less in current LLM research due to its predominant focus on textual input. To address this gap, we compare LLM-based corpora to the Litkey Corpus of German children’s texts ( Laarmann-Quante et al. 2019 ) . This comparison offers insights into how well LLMs simulate child language and provides a framework for understanding the implications of using LLM-generated corpora in linguistic and NLP contexts. Moreover, in psycholinguistic research, corpora generated by LLMs for underrepresented languages and groups have the potential to expand current research beyond the predominantly studied populations and high-resource languages ( Gagl et al. 2022 , e.g.,) . Our study investigates whether LLMs and children generate similar descriptions of the exact same picture stories used in the Litkey Corpus (stories can be downloaded from: Litkey Corpus ). A comparative analysis examines the corpora across three linguistic levels: word-level (word frequency ( Schepens et al. 2023 ; Schroeder et al. 2015 ; Gregorova et al. 2023 ) , lexical diversity ( Schepens et al. 2023 ) and word-length in letters), syntax-level (i.e., parts-of-speech; POS ( Martinez 2012 ) and sentence-length), and semantic-level characteristics (i.e., vector-based semantic similarity with word embeddings Günther et al. 2019 ). The study investigates whether LLMs can replicate child language and assesses potential risks for educational use. By analyzing these patterns, we expect to uncover both similarities and key differences that provide insight into the capabilities and limits of LLMs in modeling child language. 2 Methods Figure 1: Methods overview: Comparison of the Litkey Corpus with two LLM-based corpora based on zero-shot prompting (LLM-ZS) and few-shot prompting (LLM-FS) method generated from the same picture stories. Figure 1 provides an overview of the current study. Using identical visual stimuli (eight picture stories; see the Litkey Corpus ), written texts were produced by 251 children (i.e., the Litkey Corpus; Laarmann-Quante et al. 2019 ) and by an LLM (GPT-4; Achiam et al. 2023 ) using two different prompt designs. The first prompt presented each picture story individually and the mean age of participating children; this formed the LLM zero-shot corpus (LLM-ZS). The second prompt also included the mean age but also two randomly drawn example

Read the complete text