PENTAGRAMMA MIRIFICUM. II
Vadim Schechtman · 2025
Read PENTAGRAMMA MIRIFICUM. II by Vadim Schechtman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13586.txt.
Introduction
Vadim Schechtman continues his study of miraculous pentagrams in this 2025 sequel. The pentagramma mirificum is a classical five-pointed figure with elegant right-angle properties, first explored in the Gauss era. Schechtman describes the space of all such pentagrams, which turns out to be a del Pezzo surface of degree five. Examples tied to Fibonacci numbers appear along the way, and the discussion connects the figure to Fermat-style ascent arguments and the Poncelet theorem on polygons inscribed between curves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vadim Schechtman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
PENTAGRAMMA MIRIFICUM. II Vadim Schechtman Abstract 1 Introduction 1.1 Main topics This article is a continuation of [ S ] . We discuss here the following topics. (a) The moduli space of miraculous pentagrams as the del Pezzo surface S_{5} of degree 5 . (b) Relation to the Vinberg’s most algebraic K3 surface, [ V ] . (c) Some particular miraculous pentagrams which we call Fibonacci pentagrams . (d) Fermat’s ascent and the Jacobi’s proof of the Poncelet theorem. 1.2 The surface S_{5} and the root system A_{4} The del Pezzo surface S_{5} of degree 5 may be defined as the blowup of {\mathbb{P}}^{2} at 4 points, say p_{1},\ldots,p_{4} , in general position, cf. [ M ] , Ch. IV, §2, Thm. 2.5. It contains 10 lines: 6 strict transforms of the lines passing through p_{i},p_{j},i\neq j , together with 4 exceptional divisors; denote these lines \ell_{i},1\leq i\leq 10 . They meet at 15 points; their incidence graph is the Petersen graph P , [ P ] . In the language of [ M ] , Ch. IV the surface S_{5} corresponds to the root system R=R_{4} of type A_{4} , so R\subset H^{2}(S_{5};\mathbb{Z})\subset H^{2}(S_{5};{\mathbb{R}})\overset{\sim}{=}{\mathbb{R}}^{5}. (we identify Pic(S_{5}) with H^{2}(S_{5};\mathbb{Z}) using the first Chern class). The Weil group W(R) is the symmetric group \Sigma_{5} which coincides with Aut(S_{5})=Aut(P) . In [ M ] , Def. 1.7 and Thm. 1.8 the root system R and the set of exceptional curves I_{4} are identified explicitly. 1.2.1 Exercise Describe the set of exceprional curves I_{4}=\{\ell_{1},\ldots,\ell_{10}\}\subset H^{2}(S_{5};\mathbb{Z})\overset{\sim}{=}\mathbb{Z}^{5} explicitly using Manin’s description in [ M ] , Ch. IV, §1, Def. 1.7. See the Petersen graph therein. Solution. See [ M ] , Ch. IV, §4, Fig. 4. The Petersen graph is \Gamma_{4} , in a somewhat unusual shape. 1.3 Three modular interpretations The surface S_{5} admits three modular incarnations: (a) it is a compatification of the space {\cal M}_{0,5} of 5 -tuples of points on {\mathbb{P}}^{1} ; (b) it is the moduli space {\cal P}_{5} of miraculous pentagrams - certain 5 -tuples of points on {\mathbb{P}}^{2} . The isomorphism between these two models is provided by the Veronese embedding v:\ {\mathbb{P}}^{1}\longrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}^{2},\ v(x:y)=(x^{2}:xy:y^{2}). (c) The surface {\cal P}_{5} is the complexification of a surface {\mathbb{R}}{\cal P}_{5} over {\mathbb{R}} . According to Gauss [ Ga , S ] , {\mathbb{R}}{\cal P}_{5} may be interpreted as the moduli space of miraculous pentagrams — certain 5 -tuples of points on the sphere S^{2} . Such pentagram is defined by 5 numbers \alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta,\epsilon satisfying 5 simple equations, see ( 2.1 ) in 2.1 below. These equations define what is now called the cluster algebra of type A_{2} , cf. [ FZ , Example 1.3] . For a point p\in{\cal P}_{5} we call the numbers \alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta,\epsilon the Gauss coordinates of p . Jacobi has associated to a point p\in{\cal P}_{5} an elliptic curve E(p) ; its explicit equation in the Legendre form was written down by Gauss. On the other hand we can see the same curve in (a) realization as well. 1.4 Vinberg K3 surface and the Poncelet-Jacobi pencil There is a remarkable K3 surface X_{4} introduced by Vinberg [ V ] ; it can be defined as follows. Take four points in general position p_{1},\ldots,p_{4}\in{\mathbb{P}}^{2} . We have six straight lines in {\mathbb{P}}^{2} connecting the pairs of distinct points p_{i},p_{j} . Let P\longrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}^{2} be the double covering branched at these six lines; P is singular at the inverse images of p_{i} . If we blowup them we get a nonsingular surface which is X_{4} , see 4.1 below. Alternatively, we can consider the double covering of S_{5} ramified at ten lines \ell_{i} , and then blow up their 15 points of intersection; the resulting surface will be isomorphic to S_{4} . Thus we have the projection \pi:X_{4}\longrightarrow S_{5} For the analog of the Peterson graph in X_{4} see 4.3 below. 1.4.1 Elliptic pencil in X_{4} The del Pezzo S_{5} admits a pencil of conics \phi^{\prime}:S_{5}\longrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}^{1}, cf. 3.3 below. Let \phi=\phi^{\prime}\pi:\ \ X_{4}\longrightarrow{\mathbb{P}}^{1}. For each p\in S_{5} we can identify the corresponding Jacobi elliptic curve E(p) with the fiber E(p)=\phi^{-1}\phi^{\prime}(p)\subset X_{4}. These curves form an elliptic pencil in X_{4} , the Poncelet pencil , or pope , with 3 degenerate fibers whose Kodaira type is the affine D_{6} . 1.5 Fibonacci pentagrams Among the miraculous pentagrams there is a distinguished one p_{0} which corresponds to the regular pentagon. The corresponding elliptic curve E(p_{0}) is degenerate, its Legendre equation is y^{2}=1-x^{2}. The Gauss coordinates of p_{0} are all equal to the golden ratio \alpha_{0}=\frac{1+\sqrt{5}}{2}. It admits the well-known expression as (the simplest among all existant) continuous fraction, whose convergeants are ratios of Fibonacci numbers. In Section 5 we define a sequence of points p_{n}\in{\cal P}_{5}({\mathbb{Q}}) such that \lim_{n\longrightarrow\infty}p_{n}=p_{0}. The Gauss coordinates of p_{n} admit very simple rational expressions through the Fibonacci numbers, see ( 5.1 ). The elliptic curve E(p_{n}) is defined over a real quadratic extension {\mathbb{Q}}_{n} of {\mathbb{Q}} . 1.6 Fermat and Poncelet In Sections 6 - 12 we discuss the Fermat’s ascent method for solving the Diophantus ”double equations” and its relation to the Poncelet theorem. 1.7 Notation We will use the notation from [ S ] . Our ground field will be {\mathbb{C}} . So {\mathbb{P}}^{2} will denote the projective plane over {\mathbb{C}} ; if necessary, we will consider {\mathbb{R}}{\mathbb{P}}^{2}\subset{\mathbb{P}}^{2} , etc. 1.8 Acknowledgement I am grateful to Alexander Kuznetsov for numerous consultations. In particular the idea to realize the Jacobi-Poncelet elliptic curves inside the Vinberg wonderful K3 surface belongs to him. I am grateful to Gil Bor for the collaboration at the initial stage of this work. 2 Miraculous pentagrams and the del Pezzo surface S_{5} Pasquale del Pezzo , Duke of Caianello and Marquis of Campodisola (1859 –– 1936). 2.1 A surface related to the Napier laws of spherical trigonometry The laws of spherical trigonometry were expressed by John Napier in 1614 as follows. Given a spherical right triangle, one labels its 5 ‘parts’ (2 angles and 3 side lengths) by \alpha_{1},\alpha_{2}^{\prime},\alpha_{3},\alpha_{4}^{\prime},\alpha_{5} , where \alpha^{\prime}:=\pi/2-\alpha . Define x_{i}:=\tan^{2}\alpha_{i},\quad i=1,\ldots,5. Then one finds that \begin{gathered}1+x_{1}=x_{3}x_{4},\quad 1+x_{2}=x_{4}x_{5},\quad 1+x_{3}=x_{5}x_{1},\\ 1+x_{4}=x_{1}x_{2},\quad 1+x_{5}=x_{2}x_{3}.\end{gathered} (2.1) Below we will use the notation (\alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta,\epsilon)=(x_{1},x_{2},x_{3},x_{4},x_{5}) as well. Note that these 5 formulas are obtained from any one of them by cyclic permutation of the five variables. It follows that the same formulas hold for the four other triangles obtained from the original one by cyclically permuting the five parts of the original triangle. The five triangles form a pentagramma mirificum (”miraculous pentagram”), a spherical right-angled five-pointed star. The hypotenuses form a self-polar pentagon (each vertex is perpendicular to the opposite edge). Theorem 1 The space of solutions to equations ( 2.1 ) is a smooth surface in {\mathbb{R}}^{5} . Its closure S\subset{\mathbb{R}}{\mathbb{P}}^{5} is a smooth compact surface, whose complexification is a smooth complex compact surface S_{\mathbb{C}}\subset{\mathbb{C}}{\mathbb{P}}^{5} . We leave the proof to the reader. 2.2 Three definitions of S_{5} A del Pezzo surface is a smooth projective surface V with the very ample anticanonical bundle \omega=\Omega_{V}^{-1} . The degree of V is d=(\omega_{V},\omega_{V}) , cf. [ M ] . We will be interested in the del Pezzo surface S_{5} of degree 5 . It is unique up to an isomorphism. It admits several