Consumer Autonomy or Illusion? Rethinking Consumer Agency in the Age of Algorithms

Pegah Nokhiz, Aravinda Kanchana Ruwanpathirana · 2025

Read Consumer Autonomy or Illusion? Rethinking Consumer Agency in the Age of Algorithms by Pegah Nokhiz, Aravinda Kanchana Ruwanpathirana (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13440.txt.

Introduction

Shoppers feel free to choose, yet apps and platforms quietly steer what they see, want, and buy. Pegah Nokhiz and Aravinda Kanchana Ruwanpathirana question that freedom in this 2025 paper. Hidden fees make some spending near-mandatory. Tailored recommendations spark impulse buys. Irregular work schedules wreck planning.

The authors build formal models of spending under limits that bound a consumer's agency. Set scenarios test each pressure on its own: forced payments, algorithm-pushed splurges, and income that arrives at random times. Even fully rational shoppers lose room to maneuver under these binds. The framework shows when choice is real and when it is an illusion. Policy and platform design both come under its lens.

Catalog record

CREATORPegah Nokhiz, Aravinda Kanchana Ruwanpathirana
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE86 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13440

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Consumer Autonomy or Illusion? Rethinking Consumer Agency in the Age of Algorithms Pegah Nokhiz, Aravinda Kanchana Ruwanpathirana Abstract Consumer agency in the digital age is increasingly constrained by systemic barriers and algorithmic manipulation, raising concerns about the authenticity of consumption choices. Nowadays, financial decisions are shaped by external pressures like obligatory consumption, algorithmic persuasion, and unstable work schedules that erode financial autonomy. Obligatory consumption (like hidden fees) is intensified by digital ecosystems. Algorithmic tactics like personalized recommendations lead to impulsive purchases. Unstable work schedules also undermine financial planning. Thus, it is important to study how these factors impact consumption agency. To do so, we examine formal models grounded in discounted consumption with constraints that bound agency. We construct analytical scenarios in which consumers face obligatory payments, algorithm-influenced impulsive expenses, or unpredictable income due to temporal instability. Using this framework, we demonstrate that even rational, utility-maximizing agents can experience early financial ruin when agency is limited across structural, behavioral, or temporal dimensions and how diminished autonomy impacts long-term financial well-being. Our central argument is that consumer agency must be treated as a value (not a given) requiring active cultivation, especially in digital ecosystems. The connection between our formal modeling and this argument allows us to indicate that limitations on agency (whether structural, behavioral, or temporal) can be rigorously linked to measurable risks like financial instability. This connection is also a basis for normative claims about consumption as a value, by anchoring them in a formally grounded analysis of consumer behavior. As solutions, we study systemic interventions and consumer education to support value deliberation and informed choices. We formally demonstrate how these measures strengthen agency. 1 Introduction The ability to make informed choices about spending and saving (autonomy in consumption) is crucial for promoting individual empowerment, financial and mental health, social equity, and sustainable economic practices [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . However, consumer behavior is shaped not only by individual preferences but also by social norms and peer influences. In the digital economy, algorithms and personalized marketing further complicate these dynamics. Algorithms frequently generate filter bubbles, restricting access to diverse viewpoints. Through manipulative design strategies and persuasive advertising, they steer consumers toward impulsive buying decisions, thereby diminishing their sense of agency [ 4 , 5 ] . Systemic barriers also play a critical role in limiting agency. For example, attributing the purchase of unhealthy groceries to personal laziness (overemphasizing individual choice and placing individual blame) neglects broader structural issues related to consumers’ self-determination, such as limited access to affordable nutritious food and the pervasive presence and promotion of unhealthy options [ 6 ] . These dynamics raise critical concerns about the authenticity of consumer agency in the digital age: Are individuals today genuinely making independent decisions about their saving and spending, or is agency in consumption becoming increasingly illusory? Consider the following examples, Obligatory Consumption: Obligatory consumption encompasses essential expenditures driven by social, cultural, legal, or economic pressures, such as taxes, insurance premiums, tuition fees, loan repayments, and child support. In the digital age, this phenomenon has intensified due to subscription-based models and dependencies on digital ecosystems. A few examples among many include recurring payments that are often overlooked but accumulate to substantial amounts, such as subscriptions for software like Microsoft Office, streaming services like Netflix [ 7 ] , gaming memberships [ 8 ] , and IoT devices relying on subscription-based models [ 9 , 10 ] . Additionally, hidden fees from delivery apps, in-app purchases, and transaction charges further raise consumer costs [ 11 ] . Remote work expenses [ 12 ] and educational e-resources, such as digital textbooks and e-learning subscriptions, also place additional strain on budgets [ 13 , 14 ] . Algorithmic Persuasion & Impulsive Consumption: Algorithms embedded in digital platforms employ psychological tactics to influence consumer behavior, often leading to impulsive purchases and financial strain. Consumers have explicitly stated that they attribute excessive consumption to such marketing strategies [ 15 ] . For example, strategies such as Buy Now, Pay Later systems encourage overspending by deferring payments [ 16 , 17 ] , time-limited promotions and personalized recommendations create a sense of urgency and artificial need [ 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] , dynamic pricing and freemium models restrict free features and encourage in-app purchases [ 22 , 23 ] , social media algorithms amplify the social pressure to conform [ 16 , 24 , 25 ] , and techniques like fear of missing out (FOMO)-driven scarcity alerts further prompt impulsive buying [ 21 , 26 ] . Work Schedule Instability: Unpredictable work schedules significantly harm workers’ financial security and well-being, particularly affecting vulnerable groups like part-time employees, those with lower incomes or education, and food service and retail sectors with more erratic schedules [ 27 , 28 ] . The instability of work hours leads to burnout, conflicts between work and personal life, and financial disruptions [ 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 ] . This inconsistency in earnings complicates financial planning, undermining workers’ ability to make informed decisions about saving and spending, thus reducing their consumption autonomy. At the same time, the increasing use of digital tools and algorithms in workforce management, particularly for labor scheduling, can further undermine workers’ consumption agency. While these technologies improve efficiency, they can also lead to greater instability in workers’ schedules [ 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 ] . For example, reports from The New York Times highlight that these tools have made work hours more unpredictable, as they can dynamically and in real-time adjust schedules with little to no advance notice [ 34 , 38 ] . Our Work. In response to the earlier question of whether individuals today are truly making independent choices or if agency in consumption is becoming more illusionary, we argue that in the age of algorithms, many consumers are subject to value capture , where externally imposed values (such as those embedded in manipulative marketing) are adopted without critical reflection or personal adaptation [ 39 ] . Furthermore, systemic barriers, including socio-economic inequality, algorithmic biases, and the misuse of algorithms in areas like automated work scheduling, undermine consumer agency by restricting individuals’ ability to make decisions aligned with their unique values and needs. In this context, consumption agency must be recognized as a value to be actively cultivated, rather than assumed. Thus, to strengthen agency, it is critical to showcase the impacts of these challenges on consumption autonomy more than ever before. For consumers, understanding these dynamics helps them make more informed decisions about their immediate and future financial needs. They can move toward true consumption agency , which enables individuals to make independent decisions about what, when, and how to consume, based on their own values and preferences, without being influenced by external pressures, manipulative strategies, or systemic limitations. For policymakers, these insights provide valuable guidance for anticipating economic behaviors and developing interventions, such as regulatory frameworks and social welfare programs [ 40 ] . Acquiring these insights therefore requires examining consumption behavior (i.e., how individuals make decisions about spending and saving) within the constraints of limited agency. To carry out this study, in this paper, we utilize discounted utility

Read the complete text