Stable magnetic fields and changing starspots on Vega
T. Böhm, M. Holschneider, P. Petit, F. Lignières, F. Paletou, C. P. Folsom, M. Rainer · 2025
Read Stable magnetic fields and changing starspots on Vega by T. Böhm, M. Holschneider, P. Petit, F. Lignières, F. Paletou, C. P. Folsom, M. Rainer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13348.txt.
Introduction
Böhm and co-authors report a decade of ultra-deep observations of Vega's magnetic field and surface spots, in this 2025 paper. Vega is the flagship example of bright stars with extremely weak magnetism. Watching such fields over years reveals how they are born and how they endure.
The team gathered more than thirteen thousand spectra at two French observatories across several years. Maps rebuilt from the data show a steady pole spot and a tilted dipole that barely changed. Brightness spots, by contrast, wandered strongly over the years while keeping their contrast. No clear link tied the bright spots to the magnetic ones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | T. Böhm, M. Holschneider, P. Petit, F. Lignières, F. Paletou, C. P. Folsom, M. Rainer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 42 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13348
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Stable magnetic fields and changing starspots on Vega T. Böhm, M. Holschneider, P. Petit, F. Lignières, F. Paletou, C. P. Folsom, M. Rainer Abstract Aims. Monitoring magnetic and activity variations in A and B stars with ultra-weak magnetic fields is essential to understand the origin and evolution of these fields in this domain of the HR diagram. Vega is a prototype star of it’s category and its long-term monitoring is most promising. Methods. High resolution spectrocopic and spectropolarimetric data were gathered with SOPHIE/OHP in 2018 and NARVAL/NEO-NARVAL/TBL in 2018, 2023 and 2024. A total of 13108 individual spectra of Vega were obtained and analyzed in this article. Magnetic field maps were reconstructed with the Zeeman-Doppler imaging method and activity maps were reconstructed with an innovative code built for this purpose. They were then compared to previous results. Results. The rotation period of Vega was confirmed to be very close to the former reference period of 0.678 d. The average magnetic field confirms a negative spot of radial field on the pole with stable strength, while the magnetic maps confirm the long-term stability of an oblique dipole, as well as smaller magnetic features showing up consistently throughout our three observing epochs. However, brightness maps show strong variations of the spot location over a time-range of years, perhaps quicker. The spot contrast is very similar between 2012 2012 , 2018 2018 , 2023 2023 and 2024 2024 , with a normalized spectral amplitude of 0.0003. A direct correlation between magnetic field and brightness patches could not be revealed in the simultaneous SOPHIE and NARVAL 2018 2018 data set. Conclusions. Vega’s ”magnetic mystery” is getting more and more complex since indications point towards the presence of a fossil magnetic field but also to the presence of a dynamo-generated field, most likely concentrated on equatorial regions. An ultra-deep decadal survey at Pic du Midi and OHP 1 Introduction In 2009, the first important discovery of a weak magnetic field in a normal A-type star (Vega, -0.6\pm 0.3 G for the disk-averaged line-of-sight component) was announced by Lignières et al. 2009 . Since then, this prototype star has been studied extensively in spectroscopy, velocimetry, and spectropolarimetry. Vega’s characteristics and physical parameters are described in detail in Böhm et al. 2015 , the most important properties for this article being the recently redetermined quasi pole-on vision of i=6.4\pm 0.5^{\circ} , a v\sin i=21.6\pm 0.3\ \mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} and an equatorial velocity v_{\rm eq}=195\,\pm 15\,\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}} , based on an in-depth Fourier analysis of Vega’s spectral line profiles ( Takeda 2021 ) . Observations during five nights with SOPHIE/OHP in 2012 led Böhm et al. 2015 to the major discovery and unambiguous confirmation of a structured stellar surface at very faint amplitude levels in the dynamical spectra of \Delta{\rm F/Fc}\sim 5\times 10^{-4} (Fc being the continuum flux) corotating with the star. This first strong evidence that standard A-type stars can show surface structures opens a new field of research and asks the question about a potential link with the recently discovered weak magnetic field discoveries in this category of stars. In Petit et al. 2017 , based on the same data set, have been presented reconstructed Doppler Imaging maps of the star. Maps corresponding to different nights are mostly coherent, with apparent changes possibly due to the residual noise. Also, marginal indications were found for a differential rotation of Vega, with the pole and the equator rotating at higher rates than the intermediate latitude regions. Still, the overall spectroscopic magnetic field signature (averaged circularly polarized line profiles) and the derived surface magnetic maps for the different epochs between 2008 and 2018 remained very similar, showing a striking magnetic stability of Vega over one decade ( Petit et al. 2022 ) . Following the first discovery of a magnetic field in Vega in 2009, similar fields were detected in other bright Am stars ( Petit et al. 2011 , Blazère et al. 2016 ). The idea therefore gained support that very weak magnetic fields are present in many A and B type stars. A rotational modulation linked to the presence of star-spots might have been revealed in intermediate-mass stars lacking strong magnetic fields, the observations relying on Kepler photometry ( Balona 2017 , Balona 2019 ). These results are of major importance for our knowledge of the evolution of intermediate-mass stars. Before that, this category of stars with radiative outer layers was not supposed to show magnetic field generation. In contrast to lower mass stars with developed subphotospheric convection zones (like the sun), no mechanism of magnetic field and associated stellar surface structure generation has yet been established for this type of standard A-type star. Proposed scenarios include either decaying weak fossil field ( Braithwaite & Cantiello 2013 ) or dynamo fields constantly regenerated either in the thin He II convective layer ( Cantiello & Braithwaite 2019 ) or in the differentially rotating radiative envelope through Tayler ( Spruit 2002 , Petitdemange et al. 2024 ) or magneto-rotational instabilities ( Meduri et al. 2024 ) . Studying Vega as a prototype star extensively via spectropolarimetric observations will provide a first understanding of the nature of the magnetic field, i.e. fossil and/or dynamo, or a combination of both. A varying magnetic field in Vega would suggest that a dynamo process is at work in the envelope of intermediate-mass stars. At this stage we do not yet see an observational way of differentiating between the various amplification mechanisms possibly involved in a dynamo. The direct comparison of successive magnetic field maps produced by the Zeeman-Doppler imaging tomographic method, as well as spot maps produced in unpolarized light by Doppler imaging or similar reconstruction techniques enables us to constrain the origin and properties of the magnetic field, by unveiling possible temporal changes related to dynamo action. Beyond the question of intermediate-mass magnetism, the Vega Doppler maps also provide the first detailed constraints on the flow structure at the surface of a stellar radiative envelope. Section 2 presents the observations and data reduction, Sect. 3 presents the spectropolarimetric results, Sect. 4 presents the analysis of the activity tracing starspots present in the different data sets. Finally, a discussion and conclusion section follows in Sec. 5 . 2 Observations and data reduction Table 1 summarizes the high-resolution observations analyzed in this study. In 2018 Vega was observed simultaneously in spectropolarimetry with NARVAL (TBL/Pic du Midi, France, Aurière 2003 ) and SOPHIE/OHP ( Perruchot et al. 2008 , Bouchy et al. 2013 ). The goal was to combine stellar magnetic field observations with intensity observations obtained with an instrument stabilized in velocimetry - the intrinsic radial velocity variations of SOPHIE being lower than 2-3 \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}} . While NARVAL acquired spectra in polarimetric mode at R=65000 , SOPHIE was used in its high-resolution mode ( R=75000 ). The polarimetric results obtained with NARVAL in 2018 are already part of a first publication ( Petit et al. 2022 ) , while the intensity profiles were not exploitable at that time due to data reduction issues of the former pipeline; this was solved in this paper thanks to our new data reduction software described below. In 2019 NARVAL was upgraded to the highly stabilized spectropolarimeter/velocimeter NEO-NARVAL ( Böhm et al.