An Improved Solution to the Two Normal Means Problem via Regularization
Yang Liu Jonathan P. Williams · 2025
Read An Improved Solution to the Two Normal Means Problem via Regularization by Yang Liu Jonathan P. Williams (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-13012.txt.
Introduction
Yang Liu and Jonathan Williams revisit a tiny classic statistics problem in this 2025 note. The problem concerns just two data points drawn from normal curves. Their two means are known to lie close to each other. That closeness is extra information a good method should exploit.
Starting from a regularized maximum likelihood estimate, the authors build a new inferential machine for one of the means. Their tool stays valid, meaning its error guarantees hold. It also beats the standard approach that ignores the closeness clue. A recent rival method based on partial conditioning is outperformed as well. The note shows how even the smallest problems can still yield sharper statistical tools.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yang Liu Jonathan P. Williams |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-13012
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
An Improved Solution to the Two Normal Means Problem via Regularization Yang Liu Jonathan P. Williams Abstract The many-normal-means problem is a classic example that motivates the development of many important inferential procedures in the history of statistics. In this short note, we consider a further special case of the problem, which involves only two normally distributed data points with a constraint that the pair of means are not too far apart from one another. Starting with a regularized ML estimator, we construct a novel possibilistic IM for marginal inference on one of the two means. Not only does the new IM remain valid, it is also more efficient than the standard marginal inference ignoring the a priori information about the closeness of means, as well as the partial conditioning IM solution recently proposed in Yang et al., 2023 . keywords confidence intervals, inferential models, regularization, statistical inference 1 Introduction The problem of many-normal-means has been treated as a benchmark example for statistical inference and has been extensively studied in the literature ( Liu, 2022 ; Stein, 1956 ; Yang et al., 2023 , e.g.,) . In the most classic form, the problem concerns a sequence of independent but not identically normal random variables such that Y_{i}\sim\sN(\theta_{i},1) , i=1,\dots,n . The parameters of interests are the mean sequence \{\theta_{i}\} . Recently, Yang et al., 2023 investigated an interesting special case of the problem when the consecutive means in the sequence are in the neighborhood of one another, referred to as the Hölder constraints. In its simplest form, the constraints map onto the following restricted parameter space: \{\theta=(\theta_{1},\dots,\theta_{n}):|\theta_{i+1}-\theta_{i}|\leq B,\ i=1,\dots,n-1\}, (1) in which \theta is the collection of all the mean parameters, and B>0 is a known constant. An inferential model (IM) solution is derived in Yang et al., 2023 with a partial conditioning argument, which interpolates between the existing conditional and marginal IM solutions ( Martin and Liu, 2015a ; Martin and Liu, 2015b ) . It is demonstrated both analytically and numerically that, compared to competitive methods, the partially conditional IM yields shorter confidence intervals (CIs) for a focal mean parameter and the CIs are valid in the sense that the achieve their nominally stated frequentist coverage for finite samples. Motivated by the derivation of Yang et al., 2023 , we develop an alternative strategy to improve the efficiency of valid inferential procedures. The proposed approach hinges upon regularization, a technique of central importance in contemporary statistics. For ease of illustration, we focus on a simple two-means problem (i.e., n=2 ) that was discussed in Sections 2 and 3 of Yang et al., 2023 . In this special case, the Hölder constraint ( 1 ) reduces to requiring |\theta_{2}-\theta_{1}|\leq B . We show that Yang et al., 2023 ’s ( Yang et al., 2023 ) partial conditioning solution can be equivalently obtained from a regularized maximum likelihood (ML) estimator of the means. Moreover, we identify an even more efficient IM solution based on the same regularized estimator for the special case of n=2 . Our paper has three main contributions. First, we provide a modernized and more prescriptive argument to reproduce the partial conditioning solution of Yang et al., 2023 , using possiblistic IM, instead of the random-set IM construction employed in Yang et al., 2023 . Second, we show that a more efficient solution naturally emerges from the possibilistic IM construction, at least for the two-normal-means sub-problem. Third, we demonstrate how to incorporate regularization in the possibilistic IM construction, which not only showcases the flexibility of the IM but also highlights the key role of regularization in obtaining efficient inference. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. We begin with a brief overview of the possiblistic IM framework. We then reconstruct the Yang et al., 2023 partial conditioning IM solution with an alternative argument based a Wald-type test statistic computed from the regularized ML estimator. Next, we introduce our new IM solution that leads to more efficient inference, utilizing the same regularized ML estimator but a different test statistic. We demonstrate both analytically and numerically that our solution is more efficient than that of Yang et al., 2023 . The paper is concluded with discussions of limitations and possible extensions. 2 Foundations of Inferential Models IM is a completely general inferential framework that allows valid probabilistic inference with or without prior information. To situate our discussion, we present a concise overview of IM based on the calculus of possibility measures ( Dubois and Prade, 1988 ; Dubois, 2006 , e.g.,) . More details about the theory of possibilistic IM can be found in Liu and Martin, 2024 , Martin, 2022a ; Martin, 2022b ; Martin, 2022c , and Martin, 2025 . Suppose that the data Y\in\cY follow the distribution \pr_{Y|\theta^{*}} , in which \theta^{*}\in\cQ denotes the data generating (i.e., true) parameters, \cY is the data space, and \cQ is the parameter space. Given observed data y\in\cY , an IM represents degrees of belief about each parameter value in \cQ through a data-dependent map onto the unit interval [0,1] . This map, denoted by \pi_{y}:\cQ\to[0,1] , should satisfy \sup_{\theta\in\cQ}\pi_{y}(\theta)=1 and thus is a possibility contour . 1 1 1 We adopt this term from Liu and Martin, 2024 . In the literature of possibility theory ( Dubois and Prade, 1988 , e.g.,) , such a function is more commonly referred to as a “possibility distribution.” An IM possibility contour must also be valid in the frequentist sense: For any hypothesis H\subseteq\cQ and \alpha\in[0,1] , \pr_{Y|\theta}\{\pi_{Y}(\theta)\leq\alpha\}\leq\alpha. (2) An IM possibility contour can be conveniently constructed as a p -value function using a test statistic T:\cY\times\cQ\to\real by \pi_{y}(\theta)=\pr_{Y|\theta}\{T(Y,\theta)\geq T(y,\theta)\}. (3) The validity requirement ( 2 ) is established for ( 3 ) from the probability integral transform (e.g., Casella and Berger, 2002 , Theorem 2.1.10 and Exercise 2.10) . The test statistic T in ( 3 ) can be arbitrarily chosen. Standard constructions of possibilistic IM are often based on the relative likelihood ratio statistic Martin, 2022a ; Martin, 2022b ; Martin, 2022c . By establishing a possibilistic Bernstein-von Mises theorem, it is shown in Martin and Williams, 2025 that using the relative likelihood ratio statistic leads to asymptotically efficient inference. The asymptotic efficiency, however, relies on the classical Cramér or Le Cam regularity conditions for consistency of an ML estimate; in particular, it assumes a fixed parameter dimension as the sample size is taken to infinity. Accordingly, the efficiency of the relative likelihood-based possibilistic IM construction does not apply to the over-parametrized, many-normal-means problem. To deal with the over-parameterization, additional structure is needed, and a popular approach is to incorporate regularization constraints. We therefore consider and develop regularized , relative-likelihood-ratio-based IM extensions. In many practical problems, we are only interested in making inference about a single coordinate of \theta , referred to as the focal parameter . Without loss of generality, partition \theta=(\varphi,\nu) , in which \varphi\in\real denotes the single focal parameter and \nu denotes the nuisance parameters . Given a possibility contour \pi_{y} for overall inference on \theta that satisfies ( 2 ), a marginal possibility contour for \varphi can be obtained by taking the supremum over the nuisance parameters: \varpi_{y}(\varphi)=\sup_{\nu:(\varphi,\nu)\in\cQ}\pi_{y}(\varphi,\nu), (4) in which \pi_{y}(\varphi,\nu) is a