Reliability, Embeddedness, and Agency: A Utility-Driven Mathematical Framework for Agent-Centric AI Adoption

Faruk Alpay Lightcap, Institut für die Zukunft [email protected] and Taylan Alpay Turkish Aeronautical Association, Aerospace Engineering [email protected] · 2025

Read Reliability, Embeddedness, and Agency: A Utility-Driven Mathematical Framework for Agent-Centric AI Adoption by Faruk Alpay Lightcap, Institut für die Zukunft [email protected] and Taylan Alpay Turkish Aeronautical Association, Aerospace Engineering [email protected] (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12896.txt.

Introduction

Faruk Alpay and Taylan Alpay set out math rules for when people stick with AI agent tools. Many tools spike in use, then fade. Their 2025 paper states three design axioms: reliability beats novelty, tools should embed where work already happens rather than demand a trip, and agency beats plain chat. They model adoption as a fading novelty term plus a growing utility term. Full proofs give the conditions for dips and overshoots in use over time.

The paper also checks when the model's parts can be told apart from data, and tests a rival curve shape on the same series. Extra tests vary the risk functions that link value change to uptake. The authors aim the framework at builders who want lasting use, not launch-week buzz.

Catalog record

CREATORFaruk Alpay Lightcap, Institut für die Zukunft [email protected] and Taylan Alpay Turkish Aeronautical Association, Aerospace Engineering [email protected]
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE36 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12896

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reliability, Embeddedness, and Agency: A Utility-Driven Mathematical Framework for Agent-Centric AI Adoption Faruk Alpay Lightcap, Institut für die Zukunft [email protected] and Taylan Alpay Turkish Aeronautical Association, Aerospace Engineering [email protected] Abstract We formalize three design axioms for sustained adoption of agent-centric AI systems executing multi-step tasks: (A1) Reliability > > Novelty ; (A2) Embed > > Destination ; (A3) Agency > > Chat . We model adoption as a sum of a decaying novelty term and a growing utility term and derive the phase conditions for troughs/overshoots with full proofs . We introduce: (i) an identifiability/confounding analysis for ( α , β , N 0 , U max ) (\alpha,\beta,N_{0},U_{\max}) with delta-method gradients; (ii) a non-monotone comparator (logistic-with-transient-bump) evaluated on the same series to provide additional model comparison; (iii) ablations over hazard families h ⁡ ( ⋅ ) h(\cdot) mapping Δ ​ V → β \Delta V\to\beta ; (iv) a multi-series benchmark (varying trough depth, noise, AR structure) reporting coverage (type-I error, power); (v) calibration of friction proxies against time-motion/survey ground truth with standard errors; (vi) residual analyses (autocorrelation and heteroskedasticity) for each fitted curve; (vii) preregistered windowing choices for pre/post estimation; (viii) Fisher information & CRLB for ( α , β ) (\alpha,\beta) under common error models ; (ix) microfoundations linking 𝒯 \mathcal{T} to ( N 0 , U max ) (N_{0},U_{\max}) ; (x) explicit comparison to bi-logistic, double-exponential, and mixture models ; and (xi) threshold sensitivity to C f C_{f} heterogeneity . Figures and tables are reflowed for readability, and the bibliography restores and extends non-logistic/Bass adoption references (Gompertz, Richards, Fisher–Pry, Mansfield, Griliches, Geroski, Peres). All code and logs necessary to reproduce the synthetic analyses are embedded as LaTeX listings. Conceptual map: novelty \rightarrow embedded utility \rightarrow agentic autonomy. U Novelty: “Try the chat” Embedded: in-tools help ✓ ✓ Agent: plans & acts Figure 1: Street-level schematic: the user ( U ) first tries a novel chat, then benefits from in-place assistance inside existing tools, and finally delegates to an agent that plans and acts. Time Adoption Peak Trough Plateau Launch Figure 2: Adoption trajectory segmented by phases (blue/orange/green). A1–A3 shift the curve upward/rightward by increasing reliability, embedding in workflows, and enabling agentic execution. 1 Background and Related Work Diffusion and adoption. Classical S-curve models include logistic ( Rogers 1962 ) , Bass ( Bass 1969 ) , Gompertz ( Gompertz 1825 ) , Richards’ generalized logistic ( Richards 1959 ) , and substitution views (Fisher–Pry) ( Fisher and Pry 1971 ) . Empirical literatures on diffusion emphasize timing, drivers, and parameter stability ( Mansfield 1961 ; Griliches 1957 ; Geroski 2000 ; Peres et al. 2010 ; Bresnahan and Trajtenberg 1995 ) . Recent experiments document productivity gains from generative AI ( Noy and Zhang 2023 ) and cautionary results about naive human–AI orchestration ( Vaccaro et al. 2024 ; Klingbeil et al. 2024 ) . Domain-embedded models often realize higher value ( Moor et al. 2023 ; Pai et al. 2024 ; Bodnar et al. 2025 ) , while instruction-tuning can trade off reliability ( Zhou et al. 2024 ) . HCI shows interrupt costs motivating embedding ( Monsell 2003 ; Czerwinski et al. 2004 ; Mark et al. 2008 ; Rubinstein et al. 2001 ) . Trust and levels-of-automation guide the step from chat to agents ( Lee and See 2004 ; Parasuraman et al. 2000 ) . 2 Operational Definitions and Measurement Definition 1 (Task distribution and utilities) . Let \mathcal{T} be a distribution over tasks t with value-of-success v(t)\geq 0 , base time B(t) , oversight time O(t) , and failure cost C_{f}(t)\geq 0 . A system policy \pi acts on t . Definition 2 (Reliability R ) . Reliability is R(\pi)=\mathbb{E}_{t\sim\mathcal{T}}\!\left[\Pr_{\pi}(\text{success}\mid t)\right], instantiated by domain-appropriate proper scores on an evaluation set disjoint from deployment logs. Definition 3 (Per-task net utility and U ) . Given R , u_{\pi}(t)=R_{\pi}(t)\,v(t)-\bigl(1-R_{\pi}(t)\bigr)C_{f}(t)-c_{\text{time}}\,\tau_{\pi}(t)-c_{\text{fric}}\,\phi_{\pi}(t), (1) where \tau_{\pi} is time-to-completion (incl. oversight) and \phi_{\pi} is context-switch/interaction cost (Sec. 5 ). Aggregate utility U=\mathbb{E}[u_{\pi}(t)-u_{\pi_{0}}(t)] . Microfoundations: from \mathcal{T} to (N_{0},U_{\max}) . Let (\mathcal{T},\mathcal{F},\mu) be a finite-measure space of tasks with weight w(t)\in[0,1] proportional to task volume, \int w(t)\,d\mu(t)=1 . Define the long-run net utility improvement \Delta u_{\infty}(t):=\lim_{k\to\infty}\mathbb{E}\big[u_{\pi}(t,k)-u_{\pi_{0}}(t,k)\big]=R_{\pi}(t)\,v(t)-(1-R_{\pi}(t))\,C_{f}(t)-c_{\text{time}}\,\tau_{\pi}(t)-c_{\text{fric}}\,\phi_{\pi}(t). Assume a monotone adoption rule at the task level: an agent eventually adopts for task t iff \Delta u_{\infty}(t)>0 . Then the utility carrying capacity equals the mass of tasks with positive surplus: U_{\max}\;=\;\int\mathbf{1}\{\Delta u_{\infty}(t)>0\}\,w(t)\,d\mu(t), (2) or more generally U_{\max}=\int s_{\infty}(\Delta u_{\infty}(t))\,w(t)\,d\mu(t) for a smooth saturation s_{\infty}\in[0,1] . For novelty, suppose a launch shock randomly seeds a fraction q_{0}\in[0,1] of (user,task) episodes independent of \Delta u_{\infty} . With exponential abandonment hazard \alpha>0 , expected novelty-driven usage decays as N_{0}e^{-\alpha t} with N_{0}=\int n_{0}(t)\,w(t)\,d\mu(t),\qquad n_{0}(t):=\Pr(\text{seeded novelty use on }t\text{ at }t{=}0). (3) Under the small-signal hazard model h (Sec. 4 ), the mean-field utility-growth rate satisfies \beta\propto\mathbb{E}[h(\Delta V(t))] with \Delta V(t) proportional to \Delta u_{\infty}(t) ; hence both U_{\max} and \beta are functionals of the task distribution via ( 2 ). Reliability gradient. Differentiating ( 1 ) w.r.t. R (allowing \tau_{\pi} to depend on R ), \frac{\partial U}{\partial R}=\mathbb{E}\!\left[v(t)+C_{f}(t)\right]-c_{\text{time}}\frac{\partial\tau_{\pi}}{\partial R}. (4) If improved reliability reduces oversight ( \partial\tau_{\pi}/\partial R<0 ), the second term is positive. 3 Adoption Model, Phase Conditions, and Identifiability Let A(t)=N_{0}e^{-\alpha t}+U_{\max}\bigl(1-e^{-\beta t}\bigr),\qquad\alpha,\beta>0. (5) Then A^{\prime}(t)=-\alpha N_{0}e^{-\alpha t}+\beta U_{\max}e^{-\beta t} . Lemma 1 (Critical time and phase type) . If \alpha\neq\beta , the unique interior critical point occurs at t^{*}=\dfrac{\ln\!\bigl(\frac{\alpha N_{0}}{\beta U_{\max}}\bigr)}{\alpha-\beta} whenever t^{*}>0 . Let r=\beta U_{\max}/(\alpha N_{0}) . If \alpha>\beta , then r<1 yields a unique trough; if \alpha<\beta , then r>1 yields a unique overshoot; for \alpha=\beta , no interior extremum exists. Corollary 1 (Type of extremum) . At t^{*} , A^{\prime\prime}(t^{*})=\alpha N_{0}e^{-\alpha t^{*}}(\alpha-\beta) , so t^{*} is a minimum (trough) when \alpha>\beta and a maximum when \alpha<\beta . Theorem 1 (Monotonicity) . A is nondecreasing for all t\geq 0 iff either (i) \alpha>\beta and \beta U_{\max}\geq\alpha N_{0} , or (ii) \alpha=\beta and U_{\max}\geq N_{0} . Sensitivity of t^{*} . For the trough case ( \alpha>\beta and \beta U_{\max}<\alpha N_{0} ), \displaystyle\frac{\partial t^{*}}{\partial N_{0}} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{(\alpha-\beta)N_{0}}, \displaystyle\frac{\partial t^{*}}{\partial U_{\max}} \displaystyle=-\frac{1}{(\alpha-\beta)U_{\max}}, (6) \displaystyle\frac{\partial t^{*}}{\partial\alpha} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{(\alpha-\beta)^{2}}\!\left(\frac{\alpha-\beta}{\alpha}-\ln\frac{\alpha N_{0}}{\beta U_{\max}}\right), \displaystyle\frac{\partial t^{*}}{\partial\beta} \displaystyle=\frac{1}{(\alpha-\beta)^{2}}\!\left(\ln\frac{\alpha N_{0}}{\beta U_{\max}}-\frac{\alpha-\beta}{\beta}\right). (7) Identifiability and parameter confounding Lemma 2 (Identifiability from boundary moments) . Assume noiseless continuous-time observation of A(t) and U_{\max}\neq N_{0} . Then N_{0}=A(0),\qquad U_{\max}=\lim_{t\to\infty}A(t), and with d_{1}=A^{\prime}(0) and d_{2}=A^{\prime\prime}(0) , the rates (\alpha,\beta) solve \displaystyle-\alpha N_{0}+\beta U_{\max} \displaystyle=d_{1}, \displaystyle\alpha^{2}N_{0}-\beta^{2}U_{\max} \displaystyle=d_{2}, yielding the quadratic N_{0}(U_{\max}-N_{0})\,\alpha^{2}-2N_{0}d_{1}\,\alpha-(d_{1}^{2}+d_{2}U_{\max})=0 with the positive root determining \alpha and \beta=(d_{1}+\alpha N_{0})/U_{\max} . Thus (\alpha,\beta,N_{0},U_{\max}) are identifiable when U_{\max}\neq N_{0} . Remark 1 (Confounding and ill-conditioning) . When U_{\max}\approx N_{0} or when data are truncated near t=0 or t\to\infty , the quadratic in Lemma 2 becomes ill-conditioned, yielding strong negative correlation between \widehat{\alpha} and \widehat{\beta} in finite samples. The Fisher information for (\alpha,\beta) under homoskedastic Gaussian errors exhibits large off-diagonal elements in those regimes, implying wider CIs and reduced power to distinguish trough vs. monotone dynamics. Practical mitigation: (i) ensure early and late coverage; (ii) regularize with weakly informative priors or inequality constraints guided by Theorem 1 ; (iii) report profile-likelihood CIs for t^{*} using the gradients above. Fisher information and CRLB for (\alpha,\beta) Consider observations (t_{i},y_{i}) , i=1,\dots,n , of y_{i}=A(t_{i};\theta)+\varepsilon_{i} , with \theta=(\alpha,\beta,N_{0},U_{\max})^{\top} . Let

Read the complete text