TIRAMISU: Non-LTE radiative transfer for molecules in exoplanet atmospheres

Charles A. Bowesman, Sergei N. Yurchenko, Ahmed Al-Refaie, Jonathan Tennyson · 2025

Read TIRAMISU: Non-LTE radiative transfer for molecules in exoplanet atmospheres by Charles A. Bowesman, Sergei N. Yurchenko, Ahmed Al-Refaie, Jonathan Tennyson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2508-12873.txt.

Introduction

Charles Bowesman and co-authors present a code that computes molecular spectra for exoplanet skies without assuming local equilibrium in a 2025 paper. High in a planet's atmosphere, collisions grow too rare to keep molecules in thermal balance, and standard tools misread the light. Their program calculates the needed opacities on the fly for self-consistent atmosphere models.

Using the ultra-hot Jupiter KELT-20 b as a test case, they hunt where the effect becomes visible. Excited hydroxyl molecules should betray themselves through mid-infrared hot bands and faster breakup in visible light. Letting that molecule depart from equilibrium boosted its total destruction rate a hundredfold high in the atmosphere. The authors warn that equilibrium-only retrievals can misjudge abundances, and they discuss the collision data future modeling needs.

Catalog record

CREATORCharles A. Bowesman, Sergei N. Yurchenko, Ahmed Al-Refaie, Jonathan Tennyson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508-12873

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

TIRAMISU: Non-LTE radiative transfer for molecules in exoplanet atmospheres Charles A. Bowesman, Sergei N. Yurchenko, Ahmed Al-Refaie, Jonathan Tennyson Abstract The TIRAMISU code, a new program for computing on-the-fly non-LTE molecular spectra and opacities for solving self-consistent radiative transfer problems in exoplanet atmospheres, is presented. The ultra-hot Jupiter KELT-20 b is used as a case study to identify the wavelength regions at which non-LTE effects may be detectable. It is shown that upper atmospheric OH in vibrational non-LTE should be observable primarily via hot bands in the mid-infrared and enhanced photodissociation in the visible. Varying the abundance of OH in non-LTE demonstrates a non-linear relationship between the abundance and the strength of non-LTE effects. Using recent calculations of the photodissociation probabilities of OH it is shown that non-LTE effects can increase the total photodissociation rate by two orders of magnitude in the upper atmosphere, which is likely to have a significant impact on atmospheric and chemical modelling. Increases and reductions in the molecular opacities under non-LTE conditions may lead to the mischaracterisation of molecular abundances in retrievals that only consider opacities computed under LTE. Collisional data requirements to support future non-LTE modelling for a variety of exoplanet atmospheres and across a wide range of wavelengths are discussed. show][email protected] I Introduction While the ability to characterise exoplanet atmospheres continues to be enhanced by the development of new instruments and analysis techniques, many studies still rely on molecular opacity data computed under the assumption of local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE) conditions. Non-LTE effects, specifically where the quantum mechanical energy level populations of a molecule deviate from those given by the Boltzmann distribution, are known to be important for modelling observed spectral features in Earth’s atmosphere ( A. G. Feofilov & A. A. Kutepov 2012 ) which are in turn important for modelling its structure ( M. López-Puertas & F. W. Taylor 2001 ) . Elsewhere in the solar system, non-LTE effects are known to be important in the atmospheres of Venus ( M. López-Valverde et al. 2007 ; G. Gilli et al. 2009 ) , Mars ( M. A. Johnson et al. 1976 ; 16PiLoMa.nLTE ) , Saturn ( 11TaBaFu.planets ) , Jupiter ( 24SaLoGa.CH4 ) , Uranus ( T. Encrenaz et al. 2004 ) and Neptune ( L. N. Fletcher et al. 2010 ) , as well as in other objects such as Titan ( M. García-Comas et al. 2011 ; 13ReKuFa.nLTE ) and Pluto ( E. Lellouch et al. 2025 ) . Beyond this, non-LTE effects are well known to be important in environments from cool molecular clouds ( F. Lique et al. 2009 ) to stellar photospheres ( M. Asplund 2005 ) . Given the ubiquity of non-LTE effects in the solar system, it would stand to reason that they would likely play a role in the atmospheres of exoplanets. Indeed, such effects are increasingly being considered in the modelling of exoplanet atmospheres ( L. Fossati et al. 2021 ; F. Borsa et al. 2021 ) , though many studies have focussed on their application to atomic spectra ( C. Fisher & K. Heng 2019 ; 20YoFoKo.exo ; L. Fossati et al. 2025 ) or have been limited to rotational non-LTE ( M. Chatzikos et al. 2023 ) . The non-LTE problem is more complex for molecules owing to the considerably larger number of energy levels. The number of radiative transitions between these levels is therefore much greater; comprehensive knowledge of transition probabilities is essential for modelling the radiative processes that inform the non-LTE statistical equilibrium. Methods of simplifying non-LTE calculations exist, such as the Treanor method that instead parametrises the Boltzmann distribution using two decoupled rotational and vibrational temperatures ( 68TrRiRe.nLTE ) . Non-LTE effects arising from such a distribution have been shown to significantly impact the modelled absorption spectra of several molecules believed to be important in exoplanet atmospheres ( 22WrWaYu.nLTE ) . In practice however, neither the rotational nor vibrational distributions need to be Boltzmann-like in non-LTE. The ExoMol project ( jt939 ) provides a database of atomic and molecular line list data, as well as cross sections and k-tables pre-computed under LTE conditions ( K. L. Chubb et al. 2021 ) . As part of this project, a new line list for the hydroxyl radical (OH) was recently calculated, refined against laboratory measurements such that it reproduces experimental transition frequencies in the observed bands ( G. B. Mitev et al. 2025a ) . A study of the photodissociation dynamics of OH in its ground X {}^{2}\Pi state was also performed, considering three different dissociation channels ( G. B. Mitev et al. 2025b ) . This allows for the computation of temperature and pressure dependent photodissociation cross sections of OH. As with absorption cross sections arising from bound-bound transitions, the magnitude of photodissociation or continuum absorption cross sections are dependent on the initial state populations. This means they will vary as a function of temperature under both LTE and non-LTE conditions; enhanced excited state populations in non-LTE environments can considerably increase the photodissociation cross section and in turn the photodissociation rate. These rates are important for modelling the chemical equilibria of exoplanet atmospheres and can have a significant impact on the derived structure and composition, even if the molecule is not directly observed. The solution to the non-LTE statistical equilibrium equation is implicitly coupled to the radiative transfer problem, owing to the dependence of the rates of stimulated emission and absorption on the radiation in the media. Many methods have been developed to solve this non-linear problem, most of which rely on linearisation techniques ( L. H. Auer & D. Mihalas 1969 ) . Perhaps the most prominent is the method of multilevel approximate Lambda iteration (MALI) of 85ScCa.nLTE and 91RyHuxx.nLTE ; 92RyHuxx.nLTE . This method employs the Lambda operator splitting of C. J. Cannon 1973 to apply preconditioning terms to the statistical equilibrium equations, significantly accelerating the convergence of the method. This preconditioning also circumvented the main failure of regular Lambda iteration, which was the pseudo-convergence to false minima due to the trapping of photons in optically thick media ( J. Lambert et al. 2015 ) . 95TrFaxx.nLTE showed that application of a Gauss-Seidel (GS) iteration scheme, rather than the Jacobi-like iteration of MALI, yielded improved convergence speed and was more resilient in environments highly deviated from LTE. A. Asensio Ramos & J. Trujillo Bueno 2006 provide a detailed overview of these methods. Here the non-LTE radiative transfer code TIRAMISU (Tridiagonal Integrated Radiative transfer And Molecular opacity Iterative Solver Utility) is presented with a case study of its application to non-LTE OH in the atmosphere of an ultra-hot Jupiter. The code is designed for solving the coupled radiative transfer and statistical equilibrium problem in exoplanet atmospheres, comprising an arbitrary mixture of atomic and molecular opacity sources and with full consideration of the cross-coupling between overlapping opacity sources in the same and adjacent regions of the atmosphere. Section 2 outlines the method for solving the non-LTE radiative transfer problem. Section 3 details the data available for modelling the rates of collisional processes for OH. Section 4 describes the model atmosphere constructed for testing the new code and section 5 gives the results obtained from modelling OH in

Read the complete text